Tags: SMOB
March 16, 2010
SMOB candidate Q & A
It's that time of year again. Students across Montgomery County will make their voices heard on Election Day when they vote for their next Student Member of the Board (SMOB). But before they can step into the voting booths, they'll have to get to know the candidates on the ballot. If you've been wondering what major changes the candidates want to make, or more importantly, what their true feelings on the Snuggie are, this Silver Chips Online Q & A has got you covered.
Meet your 2010 SMOB candidates, Richard Montgomery sophomore Alan Xie and Damascus High School junior Nick Maggio.
Q: What are some qualities that make you a good SMOB?
AX
1. Involvement and experience. On a regular basis, I interact with representatives of MCR-SGA (county-level student government), representatives of MASC (state-level student government), SMOBs of other counties and members of the Maryland General Assembly. Currently, I serve as a Special Programs Coordinator on the MCR-SGA Executive Board and I manage workshops at General Assemblies. I also serve as a councilmember on the Maryland Youth Advisory Council and am on the Legislative Committee, which is chaired by Prince George's County SMOB Edward Burroughs.
2. Time management. SMOB would definitely be my top priority because representing your interests is my priority. I will effectively manage my time because I realize that things must get done to ensure your quality of education. Nothing's more important than that.
3. Enthusiasm and understanding. I've been a student of MCPS my entire life. I can't emphasize how important this school system is to me. I've gone to school in places throughout the county and I've seen MCPS from multiple perspectives. As SMOB, I will never forget where how lucky I am to come from a county where the students can have such a powerful influence on important issues.
NM
Some qualities that I will bring to the board table are experience, dedication and determination to make our education the very best it can possibly be.
Q: What are some of your weaknesses and how are you planning to work through them?
AX
I've been called demanding and stubborn because I try too hard and refuse to yield, which could be detrimental in political negotiations. Through self-introspection, I will take a critical eye to myself to take advantage of this weakness and make it an asset in our unyielding fight for what we deserve in our budget.
NM
I sometimes find myself taking on many responsibilities and trying to handle them all by myself. If elected SMOB, I would work to modify the SMOB 2.0 Initiative in a way that would allow a distribution of tasks and would promote others to take a more active role in their education.
Q: What is your most important goal as SMOB?
AX
Those blizzards were great, but they worsened our budget crisis. Now we're facing an even bigger deficit of around $761.5 million, and Councilman Andrews of the County Council has said that there's no way our budget will be fully funded. As SMOB we must preserve all of the programs that are necessary to our education. Programs that aren't vital that siphon our valuable resources must be eliminated. However, the SMOB needs additional voting rights to have a voice on the budget. Even now as a candidate, I'm actively fighting for full SMOB voting rights so that our next SMOB can fully express our concerns.
NM
My main goal if elected SMOB is to improve education in MCPS, despite the economic situation we are in. I feel as though we cannot become complacent, but rather become more motivated to initiate positive change and improve the standards of education in Montgomery County.
Q: What are some of the biggest changes you want to make as SMOB?
AX
I'm against the unfair LC policy; fortunately, it's being rescinded as of next year. This is a huge accomplishment that we've been working towards for a really long time. On a separate note, a lot of students really want to get open lunch privileges and iPod/cell phone rights at lunch. MCPS Policy JEF-RA (on the MCPS website) describes how students can get open lunch. As SMOB, it'd be a priority to work with school SGAs to get open lunch at every high school. On top of that, I'd like to make cell phone/iPod policies consistent. I know that some schools let students have electronic devices at lunch or in the hallways between classes, but others don't. This isn't fair and we can't withhold this privilege from some students while giving it to select others.
NM
There are three main goals that I look to achieve. One: To increase accountability, both with the budget and inside our classrooms. Two: To increase consistency, with both our grading policy and with our disciplinary action. And three: Work to benefit students directly with a new online course registration, the funding of after school programs, and actively advocating for other student concerns.
Q: What would you have done differently from the current SMOB, Tim Hwang? What changes of his would you keep working on?
AX
In all honesty, I would change the music playing in Tim's YouTube videos. I don't see much to change because Tim's done a fantastic job so far. He's definitely changed the system by increasing student advocacy and fighting for our budget, especially with SMOB 2.0. But whenever I attend meetings, I'm bothered by the fact that I never see any new faces. A lot of our student government organizations don't accurately represent the county, and I plan to expand Tim's SMOB 2.0 into a larger council with students from every middle and high school through SGA communication. I definitely want to involve more middle school students.
NM
Tim has done an excellent job as for us as SMOB this year. As his High School Communications Director for the SMOB 2.0 Initiative, I know what areas we need to address. The SMOB 2.0 Initiative was a great start, a great first step, but I plan on taking it to another level. I plan on making the structure of SMOB 2.0 more concrete by making sure that we have representatives at each and every school. From here, I can get a better understanding of what is going on inside each school and can enhance communication among my constituents.
Q: Why are you running for SMOB?
AX
For all my life, I've attended school in different areas of the county. I've seen firsthand the diversity and potential of our students. There's no county that can match ours, and we need to maintain our high standards during this budget crisis. I can lead our county through this perilous ordeal with my experience, innovation and expanded communication. We need to realize the potential and influence of our students – because only when we're united can we fight for and attain what we deserve.
NM
I'm running for SMOB because I know how powerful the students of Montgomery County are and I know what we can accomplish if we work together. I believe that I can lead this movement towards a better education, even during the present budget crisis. That is why I am running for SMOB, to improve the standards of education and to work tirelessly for all of you, the students of Montgomery County.
Q: If you were a Winter Olympic athlete, what sport would you compete in? Why?
AX
A lot of my friends have been going crazy over J.R. Celski, Kim Yu-Na, or Shaun White. But I'd want to try half-pipe snowboarding. Whether you love him or hate him, Shaun White's simply amazing because he's done so much for the sport. Plus it's ridiculously awesome to pull tricks that high up in the air.
NM
If I were a Winter Olympic athlete, I would compete in cross-country skiing. Next year, by all accounts, will be one of the toughest years MCPS has faced in a long time and none of our problems will go away overnight. I will bring the endurance it takes to fulfill all the responsibilities of SMOB and to get us through our current problems, much like a cross-country skier must do during the competition.
Q: If you could be anyone in the world right now, who would it be and why?
AX
Myself. With everything going on, I don't have any personal time. If I did, I'd go base jumping. Flying is my favorite superpower. The Alps sound nice.
NM
Bill Gates or Warren Buffet. If I were either of them, I could take a fraction of my net worth and dig MCPS out of this budget hole, fixing most of our problems.
Q: Where do you see yourself ten years from now?
AX
Out of college and graduate school. Nothing is ever set in stone. I've got my future outlined but it's definitely not certain. "May you find what you are looking for." (I saw that in a TV show, not a fortune cookie.) So would that be a curse or blessing? I want to live in New York City and win an Oscar for Best Original Score.
NM
In 2020, I see myself working hard at whatever I'm doing. I see myself, by 2020, as a college graduate and pursuing an occupation in business, which is what I plan to major in.
Q: What should people think when they see your name in the voting booth?
AX
When students look at my name while they vote, I hope they'll vote for me – because I'll advocate their policies every step of the way and I have the ability, innovation and experience to do so. On top of that, in Chinese, my middle name is "love" and my last name means "thanks." Much love and thanks to everyone who's supported me!
NM
When people see my name, Nick Maggio, in the voting booth, I want them to think three things. One: "Nick has proven through his experience in student advocacy over the course of six years, that he processes the dedication and commitment to the students of MCPS that is needed in a SMOB." Two: "Nick has an outlined plan of action, a detailed platform on which he is running and will use that platform to represent me." And three: "With Nick Maggio as my SMOB, I feel comfortable that my opinions will be well represented and our education will grow stronger even in these financial circumstances."
Q: What is your favorite movie, book, band/musician, color, food, TV show?
AX
Movie: 500 Days of Summer
Book: Outliers: The Story of Success by Malcolm Gladwell
Musician: Anything from Warped Tour or Lollapalooza bands to Hans Zimmer's "Pirates of the Caribbean" score, Michael Giacchino's "Up" score and Top 40 Radio. I've got diverse interests.
Color: Something outspoken. Shades of purple and light green or blue.
Food: Robeks smoothies
TV show: Psych (I never get his references), Greek, Community, Dollhouse
NM
Movie: It's a Wonderful Life
Book: Faster than the Speed of Light by Joan Magueijo
Musician: Bruce Springsteen
Color: Navy blue
Food: Chipotle Burrito
TV show: The Office
Q: How do you feel about the Snuggie?
AX
Well, the Snuggie looks silly and seems impractical but I'd have to say it would come in handy on one of those days when I just need to sleep and relax. A mental health day.
NM
Although I don't own a Snuggie, I know many people that do. Many of my friends that own a Snuggie seem to really enjoy what it has to offer. But, the creation of the Snuggie represents more than just a blanket with sleeves. There is much to be learned from its creators. In Montgomery County, now more than ever, we need creative people (like those who came up with the Snuggie) to work together and find innovative solutions to solving our budget problems.
Q: What is your hidden talent?
AX
I really wish my talent was flying, but that's probably not going to work out. I'll settle for Wolverine's powers then. He can't die. In real life, I'm actually a prestigious illusionist. I'm also a leader. My real talent is that I help others find their talents.
NM
When I have the time, I'm pretty good at playing old, classic video games.
Q: What is your favorite place in the world?
AX
Do people make a place great? I think they do. They make things meaningful. I've always wanted to lie down in a field next to a lake and stare at the clouds. Or gaze down into a valley from a meadow at the top of a mountain. Any place in the world can be meaningful and great - you just have to see the magic that's inside it. Kind of like with people.
NM
New York City. I grew up in northern New Jersey, close to New York, before moving down to Maryland in the summer of 2000. We used to go into New York City often when I was little, and I have such fond memories of it. Now that I'm older, I have a stronger appreciation for the city and enjoy visiting even more.
Q: In 10 words or less, describe why we should vote for you
AX
Neither slob nor snob, I'm dedicated to be your SMOB.
NM
Through experience and dedication, I will effectively represent your interests.
Q: How upset were you when you heard Oprah was ending her show?
AX
I'm kind of disappointed I never got to be in the studio audience. But it's been 25 seasons (according to Wikipedia, anyways) and the Oprah effect lives on. She'll probably get her own network, so that's cool beans. She doesn't need the show to be a philanthropist or do good things.
NM
Personally, I wasn't overly upset. I've only seen the show a handful of times, so I don't have the strong tie to the show that many other Americans do. However, I do feel bad for those around the country who watch the show daily. I would be very upset if NBC were to cancel "The Office," so I could imagine what Oprah's viewers are going through.
Junior Nick Maggio and sophomore Alan Xie are running for Student Member of the Board (SMOB) 2010.
Q: What are some qualities that make you a good SMOB?
AX
1. Involvement and experience. On a regular basis, I interact with representatives of MCR-SGA (county-level student government), representatives of MASC (state-level student government), SMOBs of other counties and members of the Maryland General Assembly. Currently, I serve as a Special Programs Coordinator on the MCR-SGA Executive Board and I manage workshops at General Assemblies. I also serve as a councilmember on the Maryland Youth Advisory Council and am on the Legislative Committee, which is chaired by Prince George's County SMOB Edward Burroughs.
2. Time management. SMOB would definitely be my top priority because representing your interests is my priority. I will effectively manage my time because I realize that things must get done to ensure your quality of education. Nothing's more important than that.
3. Enthusiasm and understanding. I've been a student of MCPS my entire life. I can't emphasize how important this school system is to me. I've gone to school in places throughout the county and I've seen MCPS from multiple perspectives. As SMOB, I will never forget where how lucky I am to come from a county where the students can have such a powerful influence on important issues.
NM
Some qualities that I will bring to the board table are experience, dedication and determination to make our education the very best it can possibly be.
Q: What are some of your weaknesses and how are you planning to work through them?
AX
I've been called demanding and stubborn because I try too hard and refuse to yield, which could be detrimental in political negotiations. Through self-introspection, I will take a critical eye to myself to take advantage of this weakness and make it an asset in our unyielding fight for what we deserve in our budget.
NM
I sometimes find myself taking on many responsibilities and trying to handle them all by myself. If elected SMOB, I would work to modify the SMOB 2.0 Initiative in a way that would allow a distribution of tasks and would promote others to take a more active role in their education.
Q: What is your most important goal as SMOB?
AX
Those blizzards were great, but they worsened our budget crisis. Now we're facing an even bigger deficit of around $761.5 million, and Councilman Andrews of the County Council has said that there's no way our budget will be fully funded. As SMOB we must preserve all of the programs that are necessary to our education. Programs that aren't vital that siphon our valuable resources must be eliminated. However, the SMOB needs additional voting rights to have a voice on the budget. Even now as a candidate, I'm actively fighting for full SMOB voting rights so that our next SMOB can fully express our concerns.
NM
My main goal if elected SMOB is to improve education in MCPS, despite the economic situation we are in. I feel as though we cannot become complacent, but rather become more motivated to initiate positive change and improve the standards of education in Montgomery County.
Q: What are some of the biggest changes you want to make as SMOB?
Richard Montgomery sophomore Alan Xie, who was elected 33rd SMOB, meets with Edward Burroughs, Prince
George's County SMOB and Yoonjin Min of the Maryland Association of
Student Councils (MASC).
I'm against the unfair LC policy; fortunately, it's being rescinded as of next year. This is a huge accomplishment that we've been working towards for a really long time. On a separate note, a lot of students really want to get open lunch privileges and iPod/cell phone rights at lunch. MCPS Policy JEF-RA (on the MCPS website) describes how students can get open lunch. As SMOB, it'd be a priority to work with school SGAs to get open lunch at every high school. On top of that, I'd like to make cell phone/iPod policies consistent. I know that some schools let students have electronic devices at lunch or in the hallways between classes, but others don't. This isn't fair and we can't withhold this privilege from some students while giving it to select others.
NM
There are three main goals that I look to achieve. One: To increase accountability, both with the budget and inside our classrooms. Two: To increase consistency, with both our grading policy and with our disciplinary action. And three: Work to benefit students directly with a new online course registration, the funding of after school programs, and actively advocating for other student concerns.
Q: What would you have done differently from the current SMOB, Tim Hwang? What changes of his would you keep working on?
AX
In all honesty, I would change the music playing in Tim's YouTube videos. I don't see much to change because Tim's done a fantastic job so far. He's definitely changed the system by increasing student advocacy and fighting for our budget, especially with SMOB 2.0. But whenever I attend meetings, I'm bothered by the fact that I never see any new faces. A lot of our student government organizations don't accurately represent the county, and I plan to expand Tim's SMOB 2.0 into a larger council with students from every middle and high school through SGA communication. I definitely want to involve more middle school students.
NM
Tim has done an excellent job as for us as SMOB this year. As his High School Communications Director for the SMOB 2.0 Initiative, I know what areas we need to address. The SMOB 2.0 Initiative was a great start, a great first step, but I plan on taking it to another level. I plan on making the structure of SMOB 2.0 more concrete by making sure that we have representatives at each and every school. From here, I can get a better understanding of what is going on inside each school and can enhance communication among my constituents.
Q: Why are you running for SMOB?
AX
For all my life, I've attended school in different areas of the county. I've seen firsthand the diversity and potential of our students. There's no county that can match ours, and we need to maintain our high standards during this budget crisis. I can lead our county through this perilous ordeal with my experience, innovation and expanded communication. We need to realize the potential and influence of our students – because only when we're united can we fight for and attain what we deserve.
NM
I'm running for SMOB because I know how powerful the students of Montgomery County are and I know what we can accomplish if we work together. I believe that I can lead this movement towards a better education, even during the present budget crisis. That is why I am running for SMOB, to improve the standards of education and to work tirelessly for all of you, the students of Montgomery County.
Q: If you were a Winter Olympic athlete, what sport would you compete in? Why?
AX
A lot of my friends have been going crazy over J.R. Celski, Kim Yu-Na, or Shaun White. But I'd want to try half-pipe snowboarding. Whether you love him or hate him, Shaun White's simply amazing because he's done so much for the sport. Plus it's ridiculously awesome to pull tricks that high up in the air.
Damascus High School junior Nick Maggio is running for SMOB 2010.
If I were a Winter Olympic athlete, I would compete in cross-country skiing. Next year, by all accounts, will be one of the toughest years MCPS has faced in a long time and none of our problems will go away overnight. I will bring the endurance it takes to fulfill all the responsibilities of SMOB and to get us through our current problems, much like a cross-country skier must do during the competition.
Q: If you could be anyone in the world right now, who would it be and why?
AX
Myself. With everything going on, I don't have any personal time. If I did, I'd go base jumping. Flying is my favorite superpower. The Alps sound nice.
NM
Bill Gates or Warren Buffet. If I were either of them, I could take a fraction of my net worth and dig MCPS out of this budget hole, fixing most of our problems.
Q: Where do you see yourself ten years from now?
AX
Out of college and graduate school. Nothing is ever set in stone. I've got my future outlined but it's definitely not certain. "May you find what you are looking for." (I saw that in a TV show, not a fortune cookie.) So would that be a curse or blessing? I want to live in New York City and win an Oscar for Best Original Score.
NM
In 2020, I see myself working hard at whatever I'm doing. I see myself, by 2020, as a college graduate and pursuing an occupation in business, which is what I plan to major in.
Q: What should people think when they see your name in the voting booth?
AX
When students look at my name while they vote, I hope they'll vote for me – because I'll advocate their policies every step of the way and I have the ability, innovation and experience to do so. On top of that, in Chinese, my middle name is "love" and my last name means "thanks." Much love and thanks to everyone who's supported me!
NM
When people see my name, Nick Maggio, in the voting booth, I want them to think three things. One: "Nick has proven through his experience in student advocacy over the course of six years, that he processes the dedication and commitment to the students of MCPS that is needed in a SMOB." Two: "Nick has an outlined plan of action, a detailed platform on which he is running and will use that platform to represent me." And three: "With Nick Maggio as my SMOB, I feel comfortable that my opinions will be well represented and our education will grow stronger even in these financial circumstances."
Q: What is your favorite movie, book, band/musician, color, food, TV show?
AX
Movie: 500 Days of Summer
Book: Outliers: The Story of Success by Malcolm Gladwell
Musician: Anything from Warped Tour or Lollapalooza bands to Hans Zimmer's "Pirates of the Caribbean" score, Michael Giacchino's "Up" score and Top 40 Radio. I've got diverse interests.
Color: Something outspoken. Shades of purple and light green or blue.
Food: Robeks smoothies
TV show: Psych (I never get his references), Greek, Community, Dollhouse
NM
Movie: It's a Wonderful Life
Book: Faster than the Speed of Light by Joan Magueijo
Musician: Bruce Springsteen
Color: Navy blue
Food: Chipotle Burrito
TV show: The Office
Q: How do you feel about the Snuggie?
AX
Well, the Snuggie looks silly and seems impractical but I'd have to say it would come in handy on one of those days when I just need to sleep and relax. A mental health day.
NM
Although I don't own a Snuggie, I know many people that do. Many of my friends that own a Snuggie seem to really enjoy what it has to offer. But, the creation of the Snuggie represents more than just a blanket with sleeves. There is much to be learned from its creators. In Montgomery County, now more than ever, we need creative people (like those who came up with the Snuggie) to work together and find innovative solutions to solving our budget problems.
Q: What is your hidden talent?
Xie at the Awards Ceremony for the 2010 MASC Convention held
in Ocean City, Md.
I really wish my talent was flying, but that's probably not going to work out. I'll settle for Wolverine's powers then. He can't die. In real life, I'm actually a prestigious illusionist. I'm also a leader. My real talent is that I help others find their talents.
NM
When I have the time, I'm pretty good at playing old, classic video games.
Q: What is your favorite place in the world?
AX
Do people make a place great? I think they do. They make things meaningful. I've always wanted to lie down in a field next to a lake and stare at the clouds. Or gaze down into a valley from a meadow at the top of a mountain. Any place in the world can be meaningful and great - you just have to see the magic that's inside it. Kind of like with people.
NM
New York City. I grew up in northern New Jersey, close to New York, before moving down to Maryland in the summer of 2000. We used to go into New York City often when I was little, and I have such fond memories of it. Now that I'm older, I have a stronger appreciation for the city and enjoy visiting even more.
Q: In 10 words or less, describe why we should vote for you
AX
Neither slob nor snob, I'm dedicated to be your SMOB.
NM
Through experience and dedication, I will effectively represent your interests.
Q: How upset were you when you heard Oprah was ending her show?
AX
I'm kind of disappointed I never got to be in the studio audience. But it's been 25 seasons (according to Wikipedia, anyways) and the Oprah effect lives on. She'll probably get her own network, so that's cool beans. She doesn't need the show to be a philanthropist or do good things.
NM
Personally, I wasn't overly upset. I've only seen the show a handful of times, so I don't have the strong tie to the show that many other Americans do. However, I do feel bad for those around the country who watch the show daily. I would be very upset if NBC were to cancel "The Office," so I could imagine what Oprah's viewers are going through.
Discuss this Article
I agree with whymercy
He seems really, really by-the-book?
er maybe not
but not very creative =.=
I don't see anything that Nick offers that any other SMOB candidate wouldn't. I think Alan would be a really interesting and dynamic presence as SMOB... and beating the upcounty kids would be real nice :]
That aside, he also has in depth knowledge of the issues.
nick maggio tries too hard.. look at that, he keeps trying to squeeze as much smobstuff in as possible. even on the questions that have nothing to do with smob.
If this is truly who you want to be our SMOB because he can talk the talk yet knows close to nothing about the actual walk, I'm disappointed, MCPS
That being said, they do have different personalities, as some of you have mentioned above. If you feel drawn to either candidate, don't be afraid to email Alan at Alan_Xie@mcpsmd.org or Nick at Nick_Maggio@mcpsmd.org to see how you can help out! Blair is the largest school in the county and they're both in need of campaign staff from our wonderful school. (SGA presidents can't really campaign due to protocol, so I'm counting on everyone else to make sure Blair knows what's up in this election.)
Great job both of you! Hoping for an exciting election season!
ALAN!
To "whymercywhy": You say that Nick seems "robotic," like Tim. But I think we can all agree that our current SMOB has done a whole lot more for this county than most other SMOBs in the past. Both Alan and Nick agree with this. But Tim is "robotic," yes? My question being, is Tim's ability to get things done tampered by his "robotic" qualities? Absolutely not. In the same sense I think it is unfair to judge Nick's character based on what are undoubtedly solid, professional responses to the interview questions.
We have to keep in mind that we are electing an employee of Montgomery County. A composed, mature candidate would be better respected by his colleagues and in turn be able to pass legislation that would help better our education. I know Nick personally (I am not a part of his campaign staff, yet I often talk to him at various county events) and he is a friendly, personable guy who is genuinely concerned with the dilemmas that our county faces.
I would even go as far to say that this interview is biased in favor of Alan. Not only are all of his answers placed first (not in alphabetical order, I should add), but the article also features pictures of Alan with other students-meanwhile, Nick is only shown in his professional SMOB portrait photograph.
Nick's responses are poised and feasible-He is running on a campaign backed by knowledge of what can be done. And I think this needs to be noted before the students of MCPS choose a SMOB on the basis of how "fun" he seems. At this time during our very serious, NOT fun budget crisis, we need a SMOB who is realistic, pragmatic, and ready to work.
If I remember correctly, Tim was heavily reprimanded on this very same comments section last year for being "too cold" or too "robotic" to get anything done. Oh how the haters were wrong.
And another thing: this interview was probably not the best way to gauge people's personalities.... The way someone writes and the way someone acts can be totally different.
love and thanks
" I've always wanted to lie down in a field next to a lake and stare at the clouds. Or gaze down into a valley from a meadow at the top of a mountain. Any place in the world can be meaningful and great - you just have to see the magic that's inside it."
what is this, this isnt lay on the ground member of the board of ed
hes no slob, look at his pictures, but he might just be a snob
you never interact with him outside of SGA, so how would you "know him personally?" that's just a lie to give yourself credibility.
" I've always wanted to lie down in a field next to a lake and stare at the clouds. Or gaze down into a valley from a meadow at the top of a mountain. Any place in the world can be meaningful and great - you just have to see the magic that's inside it."
what is this, this isnt lay on the ground member of the board of ed
hes no slob, look at his pictures, but he might just be a snob
If you want your statements to be treated as fact, please stand behind them. Don't leave your name as "dude" and hide behind the anonymity of the Internet. This goes for everyone. :)
Oh, and how can Alan say he's not a snob with a straight face after this nonsense?
"Through self-introspection, I will take a critical eye to myself to take advantage of this weakness and make it an asset in our unyielding fight for what we deserve in our budget."
"Self-introspection," huh? Maybe he should focus on writing a convincing response instead of fluffing it with meaningless buzz words.
–noun
a word or phrase, often sounding authoritative or technical, that is a vogue term in a particular profession, field of study, popular culture, etc. " -Dictionary.com
"Self-introspection", while reduntant, does not sound authoritative or technical, and is not particulary in vogue. Ergo, it is not a buzzword. Furthermore,
"Introspection:
–noun
1.observation or examination of one's own mental and emotional state, mental processes, etc.; the act of looking within oneself."
- Dictionary.com
Introspection is a crucial skill for any office-holder. It provides for integrity, dedication, and honesty as well as serving as an indicator for a commitment to self-improvement.
Oh, and did you even read the definition for buzzword? "Often sounding authoritative or technical" does not mean "always sounding authorititative or technical."
You know what's also a crucial skill for an office-holder? The ability to respond concisely and meaningfully, and that reply was neither concise nor meaningful.
@Eli: I'd rather a SMOB who uses pretty buzzwords than one who throws the same old stuff at me (all while seeming rather lifeless). Tim brought new ideas to the table - and got stuff done. Let's continue that streak.
On the other hand, I agree that the interview questions need work. This isn't Miss America, and our candidates should really be judged by more than which Olympian they want to become...
Captcha: cockade 28. what?
Interviews with politicians on the news are always about serious issues, yet politicians have a way of making the issues fun. Alan brings individuality and political prowess to the table, something Nick seems to lack. How will our SMOB be able to negotiate for our voting rights, budget, and programs if he cannot effectively communicate and talk with prominent leaders and play the game of politics?
Playing "by the book" will lead us to stagnation. Does Nick being "boring" automatically make him qualified? Not at all. Just because Alan has some vestige of a personality (albeit a warped sense of humor) does NOT mean he's not knowledgeable and experienced.
Alan's unique qualities will be far more beneficial to our county. Although his proposals regarding open lunches and iPod rights do seem optimistic, his mentioning them demonstrates Alan's political prowess in that he acknowledges the desires of his constituents. Not only that, Alan also discusses SMOB voting rights and the budget as real problems, addressing them more thoroughly than Nick does.
Just because Nick gave boring answers does not mean he took this interview seriously - in fact, his answers seem to lack thought while Alan seems well thought out.
Ultimately, just by coming this far, both Alan and Nick have proved that they are serious candidates who know what they're doing.
However, I will vote for Alan because he has the potential and enthusiasm to lead us through anything. His experience makes him qualified, and he will definitely be a great SMOB.
But I can tell you there's no bias with the pictures. I believe the editors simply asked the candidates for pictures, and I guess Alan just provided more.
I'd like to state that the reason Alan's responses are first is simply because he was interviewed first. For the pictures, each candidate sent in the pictures they wanted posted and all the ones sent in are posted in this article. This article is not meant to favor one candidate over another, just provide a forum through which students can get to know the SMOB candidates. Thanks for reading!
Still: your criticism regarding Alan's positions on open lunch and iPod rights are unfounded. Regardless of whether they are practical or possible, Alan's act of addressing those issues shows that he cares about all of the issues of the students - not just the budget and solely the budget. Sure, Nick talks on and on about SMOB 2.0 and the "budget crisis", but there's no details. And how many students honestly know what SMOB 2.0 is and are part of it? Alan's trying to reach out to all of the students by representing their interests across the board. Not only does he talk about iPods and open lunch, but he also spends a significant part of the interview talking about SMOB voting rights and the budget crisis, and cutting/keeping programs.
The SMOB has to represent all of MoCo, and simply focusing on the budget would be missing the point. Even though our crisis is dire, letting it overshadow all of our other concerns would be a mistake. We have to work to solve the budget crisis and at the same time focus on all the other normal education issues that we face.
Think of it this way: at least nobody promised double A exemption. Apparently That's impossible to get.
oh, and by the way nick, you totally lost everyone's votes when you said you didn't care about oprah.
I believe that the way the questions are answered can tell us a lot about each candidate, but I also believe that drastic generalizations must be avoided!
For example, Alan's extensive and humorous answers could convey his enthusiasm towards becoming SMOB. His extensive answers could also show his determination to relate with the students and also display his preparedness in taking the role as SMOB.
Nick Maggio's concise answers could be interpreted as serious and carefully thought. His manner could display his wish in demonstrating to everyone his determination to be SMOB as well.
Of course, this simple analysis could go more extensively.
However, it is important to realize that both candidates show a lot of care towards the wording of their answers.
I think, though, that Alan's extensive answers display his determined attitude to serve the MCPS students. His extensive answers which involve humour evoke his inner studentness! He is just like all the students, he takes SMOB seriously like Nick, but he knows that when serious matters are a topic... most students are likely to get bored; by using humour Alan is able to draw attention to what is necessary. It is very important to do this because all in all, it is the students who will decide who will be SMOB, it is the students who will be the circle of attention, and it is the students that will shape the policies; and having having Alan as SMOB will allow the students to have a virtuous, serious and stronger voice in the MCPS system.
-I rather not display my name.
he's well-spoken but fun at the same time. his answers are serious when appropriate but he gives a fun answer every once in while.
However, Nick seems more dependable. Some may call it generic or boring, but it seems to be more solid and trustworthy.
i hide under his porch.
(because i love him)
You can't judge Alan's qualifications or ability based on his answers to the "for fun" questions. These questions were obviously thrown in to lighten up the article and make it easier to read. There's no reason, then, why a candidate shouldn't let loose a little bit and show a sense of personality when answering these non-substantive questions.
There is no bias in the article simply based on the order in which the candidates' answers are presented. Either way, one candidate would have their answers printed first. The number or type of pictures shown of each candidate do not cause bias; Alan simply has posted many more pictures of himself with other students on his website than Nick has.
Of course, pictures don't show everything. Alan is doing more than just shaking hands with people, he is doing work and being serious. The pictures are just the 'symbol' to show he is getting to know the people he will be hopefully leading.
I support Nick, I think? But not like him.
i didnt know that being a delegate really counted for anything.
as far as im concerned, all you need to do to be a delegate is to show up. anyone can do that
Alan: His answers indeed are humorous, but at the same time they are very thoughtful. As many of you put it, it shows his attitude towards this campaign.
Nick: Yes his answers are thoughtful but it's "typical" as one of you commented. Plus, when asking about personal interests he seems to always relate it back to SMOB. There isn't really a need for that.
If I knew both of them, though, I'm sure they're great people :]
So why bother, except to make him look badly? Shame on you. You don't deserve to support someone as great as Nick.
What experience does Alan have? He's on the Executive Board of MCR-SGA, and serves on the Maryland Youth Advisory Council, where he DOES interact with General Assembly Members - the council is actually run by a Senate member and House member.
As for delegates not actually doing anything than showing up - think again. A delegate to MASC Convention, for instance, has to sacrifice 3 days of school work and make up all of it beforehand in order to attend such an event. Especially for somebody with the workload of the IB program, that's a lot to demand. Leadership is an action, not a position.
Also, his email's Alan_Xie@mcpsmd.org, and I'm pretty sure he wouldn't give out his private email to anyone he didn't knew...let alone post it on a message board where anybody can see it and send him emails.
Let's stop being childish. If you support Alan or Nick, let it be on the policies - not the candidates themselves. Both have proven themselves experienced and knowledgeable. So what's their stance on issues, and who would be better suited for interaction with the Board members and other prominent political groups made of adults and students?
vote for alan.
he made a lot of fun responses to questions, while nick's answers were hard to get through.
after a while, all i read were alan's answers and not nick's!
blair people, vote for alan!
(: cus hes cool.
he just started anything related to student government this year. It wasnt until literally a week before the deadline he decided to run. He did not do anything in any of his positions until after he applied for smob, that means half a year of no work, i doubt this can be overlooked by a 2 months of trying to reamp his resume. MYAC is a joke and nothing is ever really accomplished. you write bills but very few if any pass. alan is a better speaker thats all he has over nick. He doesnt care about the county. He cares about his resume.
Nick.
been in Studnet Govt for years knows topic from experience not from paper. Horrible Speaker. monotonous voice. Boring at times. Tries to hard at all the answers...sounds like a robot no doubt about it
I find it funny how you claim to know when Alan decided to run for SMOB. Do you personally know him that well? Not only that, you'd have to be Michael Washington (MCR Special Programs Director) to know what Alan's done in his job. If you attended any of the MCR General Assemblies, you'd have seen that Alan led quite a few breakout groups throughout the year. Last but not least, it's interesting how you decided to comment that MYAC is a joke. Do you have a personal grudge against Thomas Senecal or Ed Burroughs? I can understand the latter, especially since this is Montgomery County. Still, MYAC is important because it's got representation of multiple SMOBs from across the county and has a voice in the MD General Assembly. MASC is more about having fun with other kids than actual serious business. MYAC also has numerous guest speakers at meetings (related to education) and has a specifically designated date for lobbying and discussion of issues. This allows each councilmember to have a private discussion about issues with their representatives. And finally - the icing on the cake - is that MASC itself lobbied to create MYAC in the first place. Why call it useless if you worked so hard to make it happen?
Your disparagement of both candidates ultimately reflects your negative political attitude. Something that we need to do is "heal the broken politics of this county" and move away from this.
Taken as a whole, your critique seems to favor Nick over Alan just by looking at the amount of time you spent writing about each candidate.
Think about it this way. Obama may not have spent the same amount of time in the Senate as McCain, yet he was elected. And with an especially strong representation among young people at that. Is it a trend?
all this stuff you're saying, all these fingers you're pointing. seems like you're his friend or something. all this stuff you claim, i dunno if it's true, but you seem like you know a lot about him or think you do. and now you're on the internet talking crap about him... ouch, i don't know why he has a "friend" like you.
I know who you are. I think I know why you're trying to paint him badly. Good job being a friend.
Also, if you seem to lean towards Nick. What's the point in calling him a horrible speaker and boring like a robot? You obviously haven't read his voter guide. It's somewhat interesting.
Do you truly believe Nick has the leadership abilities and is politically savvy enough to pull off what it takes to be SMOB? You trumpet his knowledge of county and state politics.
Yet I see that Alan also has quite a broad understanding of such politics and issues as well. Neither candidate seems uninformed, and both seem to know what they're doing.
Knowledge is irrelevant factor because it can always be gained. If this was the deciding factor, I'd say that both have an equal knowledge - yet they're both eclipsed by Tim. Simply because Tim knows it better and is also privy to insider information.
It's the ability that really counts. Who do you want to represent Montgomery County's youth voice? He has to be able to interact with all kinds of adults and youth across the spectrum. I believe that Alan has the political ability and knowledge to do so.
Nick and Alan have some big shoes to fill.
So who's going to be better suited at maintaining communication with students and increasing student advocacy to establish county-wide collaboration in student government and other youth groups?
Who is more effective at communication and appealing to their constituents; essentially, who is the better politician?
Those who vote for him are taking a risk in that he could turn out to be a great SMOB or flounder like most of the SMOBS we have had already.
Still, many will be swayed by the way Alan presents himself, which seems much more appealing than Nick's delivery.
It's a tough choice to make. Both candidates seem to have qualities that the other lacks.
-----
Q: If you could be anyone in the world right now, who would it be and why?
AX
Myself. With everything going on, I don't have any personal time. If I did, I'd go base jumping. Flying is my favorite superpower. The Alps sound nice.
-----
What do the Alps, flying or base jumping have anything to do with the person you want to be?