Saturday, February 11, 2012 4:05 pm
Montgomery Blair High School's Online Student Newspaper
Tags: print
March 28, 2003

American Idol: Pick Yours!

by Laurel Jefferson, Page Editor
Reality television has overwhelmed American society in the past few years in a deluge of trashy dating shows, cleverly masked popularity contests, and publicized ventures in human humiliation. But one show seems a little less tarnished by the real-life soap opera phenomenon, one show seems to have a bit more honest merit: American Idol. Averaging over fifteen million viewers a week, the second installment of this reality television series is a singing contest in which the American public chooses the winner.
Simon Cowell
Simon Cowell

American Idol began with auditions in several major cities in which the three judges, Simon Cowell (the mean one), Paul Abdul (sickeningly sweet), and Randy Jackson (in-between), voted on whether or not candidates received the chance to travel to Hollywood and perform again. Next, the hundreds of Hollywood contestants were narrowed to twelve finalists who now compete each week in hopes that they will not be the one contestant fickle America eliminates.

With only nine contestants left out of the twelve, the stakes are getting higher for the superstar hopefuls. Carmen Rasmusen, Corey Clark, Ruben Studdard, Joshua Gracin, Clay Aiken, Kimberly Locke, Kimberly Caldwell, Rickey Smith, and Trenyce make up the finalists, with America already having dismissed the late (and generally unmourned) Julia DeMato, Charles Grigsby, and Vanessa Olivarez.
The final 8
The final 8

Out of all the names and faces, Clay Aiken and Ruben Studdard are the two favorites, with stellar voices and endearingly normal physiques. Both are incredibly charming, humble, and talented. As "nice" judge Abdul put it, “I think America is having a love affair with Ruuuuben," noting the audience’s new cheer for contestant Studdard.

But Silver Chips wants to know who your favorites are in the American Idol competition— whether it’s the cutesy Carmen or the country Joshua, the hometown Ruben or the charismatic Kimberly Caldwell. Write in with your hopes and predictions!

American Idol airs on Tuesdays at 8:00 p.m. and on Wednesdays at 8:30 p.m.

Discuss this Article

  • Blazerette (View Email) on March 28, 2003
    I love Clay! He has a great voice. So does Ruuuuben. In season two of American Idol, unlike last season, the males seem to have more of a fan following than the females.
  • Chris Mulligan (View Email) on March 28, 2003
    Smokey the Bear says: 'Only you can prevent awful reality TV! Turn it off!'
  • Clay luva 4 life on March 29, 2003
    Clay should win!!!! No one else can sing half as good as he can!!! yes he may be a little different but hey, that's what makes him so charming. he's so great! if he doesn't win, then american idol is wrong. kelly clarkson was right to win last year so i hope they make the right decision this time too.

    and also, what's with this new kelly and justin movie?? that's just weird. who's going to actually see that movie? i mean, please, they sing, true, but that doesn't mean they can act.
  • robert garcia on March 30, 2003
    who cares! who would idolize a retarded singer anyways. if americans idolize these pathetic retards then who knows who will be their idols next- bin laden? I side with the bald guy, this reality crap has got to go. Its america at its worst.We need physicists, environmentalists and writers to be a little girls role model instead, so the world can be a better place.
  • katie 05 on March 30, 2003
    ruben all the way!!!!!!
  • Kevin L. (View Email) on March 31, 2003
    Clay has some serious skills. All of the top 8 or 9 have some awesome voices though; last year's top 10 SUCKED in comparison!
  • cindy (View Email) on March 31, 2003
    i think that clay and ruben will be the top two, and i hope that clay wins...he is sooo talented and i think that he has the total all american package.
  • Amanda (View Email) on March 31, 2003
    Clay Aiken should definately win! He's cute, charming, he has the best voice than all the other contestants. He absolutely has a right to win. America, vote 4 clay. But hey, even if he doesn't make it, than the producers must've counted the votes wrong!
  • Rita (View Email) on March 31, 2003
    Clay's my pick!
    I admire some of the others, but Clay touches my heart.
    His voice, his phrasing, his style and his
    look capture me in a way that only a handful of performers ever have.


  • politicaly incorrect on March 31, 2003
    it'll be the battle of the thin white guy and the fat black guy, ruben vs. clay.
  • I dream of Ruben on April 1, 2003
    I totally love Ruben. He is so sweet and charming. He has such a beautiful voice. I mean, so does Clay, but Ruben is so amazing. I really hope they are the final two. Last year, they made the mistake of having Justin Guarini be in the top two instead of Tamyra Gray. I hope nothing like that happens this year. I would be happy with Clay or Ruben though, since both will end up getting record deals. It's just that one will be more famous than the other.
  • Maria on April 2, 2003
    Clay's voice is wonderful. I'd buy his CD today!! Ruben is the same old stuff week after week, and not much range. Simon needs to use a q-tip next week!
  • kim (View Email) on April 2, 2003
    I love RUBEN he has such a wonderful voice everytime i hear RUBEN's voice i get chills he is such a wonderful person and had the best voice ....ruben all the wayyyyyyyy...love ya ruben !!! !!!!!
  • RuuuubanAllTheWay (View Email) on April 2, 2003
    I don't think any of the contestants can measure up to Ruban. Many feel that Clay will win this. Than any goofy looking constipated singing boy has a chance. GO RUBAN!!!
  • Olivia on April 2, 2003
    I absolutely adore Clay. What an amazing guy with an amazing voice.
    I think America is sick of all the Britney's, Justin's and Ashanti's...and I think we want something else. Clay is unique and refreshing.
    He is so adorable too. I'm rooting for Clay all the way!!!
  • Amberly (View Email) on April 2, 2003
    Clay is an IDOL ALL AROUND! Special Ed. Teachers and students are Idols in their own way and that's why Clay should be the next American Idol! GO CLAY!

    Amberly, NC
  • Mely (View Email) on April 2, 2003
    Ruban is really good! I also think that Clay is good, even though he does seem gay, because he can sing long without taking a breath . Josh is good too! I hope he doesn't have to go to war, but it is his job. I also think that Trenyce sings really good. Kimberly Locke sang the disco good but nothing else. I think that Kimberly Caldwell and Carmeran should just get out. Ricky's good but not as good as the others.
  • Danita (View Email) on April 2, 2003
    It's Clay all the way!!!!
  • Lindsey (View Email) on April 2, 2003
    Hey I just want u to all know, im the biggest clay lover ever!!!! I have shirt with clay on it, I named my new baby goat clay, even though she is a girl, and even call my self miss.Aiken! Anyways I think that ruben is awsome but any black man could be capable of singing like him! NO OFFENSE TO OTHER PEOPLE!! But hey, Clay has the looks, the talent, and that absolutly beautiful mysteryious velvet voice. :) just so Ya'll kno!! If u disagree or agree plz e-mail me!

    foxylindsey62@aol.com
  • CLAY LOOOVER!!! (View Email) on April 2, 2003
    HOW DARE simon say That Clay is absolutly terrible!! I LOVE CLAY!! its like i kno him.. man i wish i could ask him out!
  • Nan (View Email) on April 2, 2003
    I love Clay Aiken and I think he will be the next American Idol for sure .
  • claylover on April 2, 2003
    i heart clay
  • diane and denise on April 2, 2003
    jeffrey osborne for Reuben!!!!!!!!He will sing it so good!!!!!!!!!
  • Danielle on April 2, 2003
    Ruben is the all time best man ever. and to all u fools that are dissn on ruben and hate american idol, keep your rude comments to yourself. go watch the discovery channel. YA RUBEN!!!!!
  • ClayisanANGEL (View Email) on April 2, 2003
    I really hope Clay wins this thing, he really deserves it. He is a sweet, humble, talented and sincere man. I wish him the best of luck !
  • kristin (View Email) on April 2, 2003
    I am completely head over heels for Clay. He is incredible! He is my AI!
  • Manny (View Email) on April 3, 2003
    Clay needs to sing Billy Joel's "Uptown Girl" He will fly with this tune...
  • Jennifer Collins (View Email) on April 3, 2003
    i think either trenyce or ruben should win this competition. they are the best ones out there. if either one of them is voted off, i would be extremely shocked at the public.
  • Jennifer Collins (View Email) on April 3, 2003
    ruben is the velvet teddy bear!!!!!!
    i luv ruben!!!!!!! :-)
  • Jennifer Lynn (View Email) on April 3, 2003
    Ruben has the most powerful voice of any young sing I have ever heard. He is so touching. MY spine tingles all over when I here him. I live only 1 hour from his home town B-ham. I hope to meet him one day. He is truly my Idol. I call and vote for him like 100 times every Tuesday night. I hit flash, redial, flash, redial.....I agree with Simon. Ruben should win this competition.You go sweetheart. Win this thang!
    Jennifer Lynn
  • Elvis (View Email) on April 3, 2003
    For what it's worth, at this point, all of the "Idols" will have the careers they dreamed of, whether they win the show or not. At this point, none of them are bad, and everyone can have an off night. I agree with Simon that Carmen is very commercial. She has that bubblegum appeal, but she's not my favorite. Kim Caldwell has it all...a unique voice, a killer body, charisma and confidence galore. She will end up on TV or Albums either way. Ruuuuuuubin is awesome, very comfortable and a great delivery in every performance. Clay is just great, as well...and now that he's performed those Disneyesque songs, I can't imagine him doing anything but that....making sound tracks for mice movies :) He just has that kind of voice. With all that said...it seems that this competition is very reliant on the demographic watching. For the show on 4/2/2003, there is no way the right 3 ended up on bottom. Where was JOSH? OMG! Singing Celebration was painful, even for him! And Ricky, while a humorous attempt at capturing the 70's, had pitch problems, and timing problems. Frustrating to say the least, but I am sure that they will all land quite interesting careers thanks to their talent and TV time.
  • Hollyg9211 (View Email) on April 3, 2003
    there are a lot more talented people on AI this year but only Clay Aiken makes my inner 13 yr old girl go "EEEEEEEEEEEeeeeeeeeee!!"
  • CLAYmate#24 (View Email) on April 3, 2003
    CLAY!!!
    CLAY!!!
    CLAY!!!
    but then maybe....ummmm CLAY!!!!
  • i LoVe U cLaY =) on April 3, 2003
    i LoVe cLaY!!!! hehe..first off, clay is amazing..he astounds me every tuesday with his incredible voice, style and humility. The way he carries himself on stage is so pleasing to watch. So everyone, let's get together and vote for the true american idol -- clay aiken!! He definently deserves it the most..i love u clay!!!!
  • i LoVe U cLaY =) on April 3, 2003
    i LoVe cLaY!!!! hehe..first off, clay is amazing..he astounds me every tuesday with his incredible voice, style and humility. The way he carries himself on stage is so pleasing to watch. So everyone, let's get together and vote for the true american idol -- clay aiken!! He definently deserves it the most..i love u clay!!!!
  • Rene (View Email) on April 3, 2003
    RUUUUUUUBEN........205 BABY.......ALL THE WAY!!!!!
  • elisa on April 3, 2003
    Ruuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuben ROCKS!!!
  • the obvious on April 3, 2003
    The sad thing is, if Ruben wins American Idol, the show will find some way to disqualify him because he is "fat." I mean, Hollywood is sick, with 95 lbs models at 5'10" of both sexes.
  • jennifer (View Email) on April 3, 2003
    hi...my favorite american idol is Clay Aiken. i hope he wins...but i think the top five are Clay Aiken, Reuben Studdard, Josh Gracin, Kimberly Caldwell, and Trenyce
  • mal (View Email) on April 3, 2003
    clay is the best! i looove his voice!
    he definitely should be the next american idol!
  • Rita (View Email) on April 3, 2003
    Clay Aiken is the ONLY reason I watch American Idol. He's got a unique talent and
    powerful charm.
  • Christine (View Email) on April 4, 2003
    CLAY AIKEN MAKES MY DAY!!!!!!!!!!!!! WHOOOOOOOOO HOOOOO!! O MAAN...wut can i say?? (whoa that rhymed) He has a beautiful voice, as ANYONE would say if you just asked them. He's sooooooo cute, and kind. He helps children with special needs. COme on. If the true AMERICAN IDOL is someone who is not onlY a talented singer, but a humanitarian, and humble person, then CLAY AIKEN IS YOUR MAN! I REALLY HOPE HE WINS. I can honestly say that he deserves it 100%! CLAY BAYBEE!!!!!!!! tHANK YOU=)
  • Lindsey (View Email) on April 4, 2003
    Clay is for sure the cutest! You gotta love him!
  • Ashley (View Email) on April 4, 2003
    Ruuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuban ROCKS, kick ass!! YEah, CLAY IS HURTIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Jeboduuza (View Email) on April 4, 2003
    Dude, Clay or Ruben wil win I know. But! I personally like Rickey Smith. He is nice and can sing well, but everyone looks at the outstanding Ruben and Clay, I hope he ends up with a contract after this.
  • Alix (View Email) on April 4, 2003
    I'm Aiken for Clay.
  • Diana Johnson (View Email) on April 4, 2003
    Clay Aiken He has my vote to be the next American Idol. He is very unique ! He has a great voice and very charming ways ! I t is great to see America voting away from the pretty,perfect types ! Rubin is sweet and very entertaining but I feel that Clay is more interesting and less main stream entertainer. I will vote Clay all of the way !
  • Diana Johnson (View Email) on April 4, 2003
    Clay should blow everyone away with his favorite song 'Unchained Melody"
  • Diana Johnson (View Email) on April 4, 2003
    Clay should blow everyone away with his favorite song 'Unchained Melody"
  • carriec (View Email) on April 4, 2003
    i think the night julia demato was voted off, phone lines were blcked. i checked 15 states and all reported being unable to get through for 45 minutes. sounds funny and fishy to me. she did perform her best that tuesdaybut maybe producers didnt want her to go on because of pooer 2 performences. i would like to see a girl with no experience go on than other contestants with late admissions of arrests and previous record cover-ups. treynece should go as well as corey. her past two performances were not up to par
  • carriec (View Email) on April 4, 2003
    i think the night julia demato was voted off, phone lines were blcked. i checked 15 states and all reported being unable to get through for 45 minutes. sounds funny and fishy to me. she did perform her best that tuesdaybut maybe producers didnt want her to go on because of pooer 2 performences. i would like to see a girl with no experience go on than other contestants with late admissions of arrests and previous record cover-ups. treynece should go as well as corey. her past two performances were not up to par
  • ME (View Email) on April 4, 2003
    i have to say clay is the one, but everyone knows that..so i am rooting for my girl carmen!!!! THATS RIGHT CARMEN!!11
  • Clay must win! (View Email) on April 4, 2003
    Clay is a dreamsicle! Not only can he sing, not only is he adorable, but he also seems to have a genuinely good heart. I would love to see someone with his kind of integrity as a role model for a change. So vote for Clay!!!!!
  • Emily (View Email) on April 4, 2003
    I THINK CLAY SHOULD WIN!!!!!!!!!!! HE"S THE BEST!!!!!!!!!!!
  • kennedy (View Email) on April 4, 2003
    Hi carmen is my favorite she is so cute and very good. She has a great voice for how young she is! I think people should vote for her their just not giving her a chance! She is a real sweetie! Shes young but shes a real nice girl and a good singer!
  • Keidi on April 4, 2003
    *holds out "We *heart* Ruben!" banner...Err...=D I'm hoping for Ruben, but I have a feeling Clay is gonna win this one. His voice annoys me for some reason. Maybe since it's a little too Broadway/theatrical for my tastes, but he has talent none the less. I just wouldn't buy his album. (I'd go crazy from the voice). :)
  • Jane (View Email) on April 4, 2003
    NOBODY ON AMERICAN IDOL IS GAY!!
    All you people are just jealous that they have fame and fortune and y'all are LOSERS!
  • justathought on April 5, 2003
    personally i feel either ruben or trenyce should go ahead to win it, they're the only two whos really got the real talent up there on that stage. however we're looking for idols here, remember that... i mean can u imagine putting up a picture of ruben on your wall? i cant! i can imagine kimberly c or carmen on my wall though, pity they're lacking in soul. my vote goes for trenyce! u go girl!
  • Chris Johnson (View Email) on April 5, 2003
    I believe the next American Idol should be Clay Aiken. He has the most beautiful voice of all of the singers and he is absolutely adorable. He seems like such a nice guy. My 23 year old daughter has a huge crush on him. He's the kind of guy a mom would be happy to have as a son in law.
  • Sonya (View Email) on April 5, 2003
    RRRRRRRUUUUUUBBBBBBBBBBBEEEEEEENNNNNN!!!!!
  • Kevin L. (View Email) on April 5, 2003
    Hey Mely, you're an idiot, singing long phrases with one breath is called breath control. Way to screen THAT comment editors...
  • Patty Patty (View Email) on April 5, 2003
    RUBBBBBBEEENNN ALL THE WAY...YOU GO MAN U ROCK!!! LIKE TOTALLY I LOVE YOU.....IF U PEOPLE DONT VOTE FOR RUBEN YE GUYS ARE SO CRAZY ...OMG RUBEN!!IDOL ....CLAY IS GOOD DONT GET ME WRONG BUT TOTALLY RUBEN ALL THE WAY! BEST WISHES FOR U RUBEN MAN..U NO U ARE THE BEST!!!
    OO AND CARMEN U ROCK TO GURL!!!
    AWESOME!
  • rylee (View Email) on April 5, 2003
    I love carmen and you guys are crazy not to vote for her! You should next week! Shes a aweosme person and should stay in the competition! Give her a chance what if she was dating one of the guys on the show that you liked? you would keep her in because you would want him to be happy!
  • Erik (View Email) on April 5, 2003
    KIMBERLY CALDWELL RULES!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • tech on April 6, 2003
    Clay should win. He can sing and hold notes longer than anyone. It's a shame that each week Fox makes them sing different types of music. As we all know a recording star sings the type of music their most comfortable with. Let the singers decided for themselves and then we'll have a real competition.
  • Wade Needham (View Email) on April 6, 2003
    RUBEN IS DA MAN! GO BIG RUUUUU!!!! http://velvetteddybear.cjb.net/
  • Jenn (View Email) on April 6, 2003
    The extremely talented and adorable Clay Aiken? If I could vote, I'd vote the whole two hours for him. Not sure if any beeshes over here in Canada will captivate like Clay does.
  • Alexia (View Email) on April 6, 2003

    ???
    ?$atch American Idol because of him. His powerful voice TOTALLY blows me away each week and I get a tingly feeling down my spine when I listen to him. I truly think that he deserves to win this competiton. CLAY ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Cane (View Email) on April 7, 2003
    Ruuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuban Studard all the way forever and ever and ever goooooooooooooooooooo Ruben u are the man aint no body can top you not even Gerald Lavert
  • Clay Girll on April 7, 2003
    Clay is DEFINETLY going to win. Ruban has a greet voice too. I think the top 2 will be Clay and Ruban and Clay will win. My friend thinks he looks like a mouse so, she calls him mouseboy. I think he's the cutest person in the WHOLE WORLD!
  • Clay Girll (View Email) on April 7, 2003
    Does anyyone think Simon and Paula are dating? If you think they are email me. You can still email me even if you think they aren't. Please email me. PLEASE!
  • Trinia Mimms (View Email) on April 7, 2003
    Reuben not only has TRUE talent, he also has charisma, the attitude and personality to fit the description of an American Idol. He indeed should win the contest. He has his own uniqueness withs sytle and creativity!! I believe that Reuben Studdard can and will be The next American Idol.
    You have my vote!!!!
  • Maria (View Email) on April 7, 2003
    I think all ogf the comtestins can sing great.But i think the winner of American Idol weill be......Clay Aiken . He has a great srong voice. And as Simon saud he will be the won everyone has to beat and you know what i actually belive him. I wish all the contestins good luck especially Clay Aiken. GO CLAY!!!!!!!!!!!!

    BYE HE HE
  • Maria (View Email) on April 7, 2003
    If Clay Aiken makes a record i will be the first one on line to buy.

    GO CLAY ! ILL BE WIT U 100%
  • Maria (View Email) on April 7, 2003
    I think all off the comtestins can sing great.But i think the winner of American Idol weill be......Clay Aiken . He has a great srong voice. And as Simon saud he will be the won everyone has to beat and you know what i actually belive him. I wish all the contestins good luck especially Clay Aiken. GO CLAY!!!!!!!!!!!!

    BYE HE HE
  • Marisa (View Email) on April 7, 2003
    RUUUUUUUUUUUUBAN Hands down is the best!!!!! Go Ruban
  • madelle (View Email) on April 7, 2003
    I think Clay is by far the best singer on AI2. His voice if intoxicating. Reuben has a nice voice also but I don't get chills when he sings. Here's hoping Clay wins it all! Clay would make an excellent role model for young kids, instead of those sleazy pop stars of today.
  • Clay Girll (View Email) on April 7, 2003
    If you think Simon and Paula are dating email me. Even if you don't think they're dating email me. I hope Clay wins.
  • danelle (View Email) on April 7, 2003
    I agree three-hundred and fifty percent with those who want Clay to be the ultimate winner. I think what really attracts me to his style of singing is the purity of both his voice and his soul. Not only does he sound like a gift from heaven when he holds the mike, he acts as a caregiver to those who need it as a worker with a young man with autism. That's just so much more than a true performer; that's a true Idol. He's got my vote all the way. (But I won't shed a tear if Ruben wins either!)
  • Florence (View Email) on April 7, 2003
    My fingers are crossed for CLAY. I love his voice,style,and offbeat look.I think if allowed to select his own material instead of having to perform standard material everyone would agree that he is superior to all the others including Rueben who is excellent but pretty much has the same sound I have heard by already famous singers.CLAY FOR AMERICAN IDOL!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • sandra j. traficante (View Email) on April 7, 2003
    Clay has given our whole family something to cheer for. Never in my life, and I'm way over "30" do I remember being so excited by a voice. My daughters who are in their early 20's are also captivated. He is already our American Idol. We will buy anything he sings, and travel to see him. For us it is Clay all the way!
  • Robin (View Email) on April 8, 2003
    Clay all the wayyyyyy! I just admire and respect Clay Aiken, and like many other women think he's a hotttie! Its just something about his mysterious southern charm, I guess. But I really could see him singing on Broadway one day. Love him!
  • Sara (View Email) on April 8, 2003
    Clay all the Way!!
  • D Ray on April 8, 2003
    Clay has the best overall voice!! YES RUEBEN IS GOOD, BUT.....he does not have the range as Clay does. Rueben has an incredible voice but is considered MONO-TONE!!! Clay is the performer and singer that you would want for a contract!!!
  • Clay on April 8, 2003
    Clay has an amazing voice, and is so modest and charming. (Ruben also gets some points here.)
    P.S. I can't believe I watch this show...
  • Liz (View Email) on April 8, 2003
    Clay is by far the most talented! He is the person this country needs as our Idol. I have never felt so strongly about a performer before. He is incredible!!
  • Liz (View Email) on April 8, 2003
    Clay is by far the most talented! He is the person this country needs as our Idol. I have never felt so strongly about a performer before. He is incredible!!
  • Jen (View Email) on April 8, 2003
    I truly hope Clay is our next American Idol. He has an amazing voice and as a mother of 4 I would love to see someone with morals such as Clay's be a rold model for my kids!
  • Shawna McGinnis (View Email) on April 8, 2003
    I think that rubin is going to win the whole thing. He is the only person that simon likes every single week, and if simon tells you that you can sing,then YOU CAN SIG! He has a great attitude, and i just think he would be a great american idol.
  • Melissa (View Email) on April 8, 2003
    I have a confession to make, I am in love with Rubin Studdard. If I could, I'd vote for you a thousand times, but since I can't I'll pray for you in hopes that you'll be my American Idol, and we can be together for ever and ever.
  • celeste (View Email) on April 8, 2003
    kimberly caldwell has a 5 note range...she can't sing! and carmen sounds like a sick, dying goat. not good at all, guys. clay, ruben, and josh will be the final 3.
  • S. P. (View Email) on April 8, 2003
    Clay's voice, tone, control and style are nearly perfect, much like a Frank Sinatra or Judy Garland. It's hard to name someone in "Pop" with this skill. It would be nice to see Carmen at the end with Clay. She is an honest and true talent and deserves it.
  • melzah (View Email) on April 8, 2003
    Reuban is going to win this compitition no arguement there mate!!!He is the best there is in this compitition and you all know it...
    Reuban Reuban Reuban Ruuuu Ban.yeah!He's the man.And as for clay well he'll be my second choice,not too far behind reuban i say!! see ya later.GO REUBAN GO REUBAN GO REUBAN!!!YEAH
  • MELZAH (View Email) on April 8, 2003
    RRRUUUUUUUUBANNNNNNNN IS THE MAN THAT IS GOING TO TAKE THIS COMPITITION AND YOU ALL KNOW IT.GO HARD BIG BOY FROM 205.
  • Alison Cottingham (View Email) on April 8, 2003
    RUUUUUUUUUUBEn Definitely! He is Great and brings it to us every time. And he never forgets who he is or where he is from (GO 205)!
  • jeannie (View Email) on April 8, 2003
    oh my god. am i the only one that doesn't get the whole clay aiken hype? i was impressed with his voice too when i first heard him audition. but i am getting very sick of hearing him sing the same melodramatic songs week after week. if this show is looking for a pop star, clay aiken should definately not be the new american idol. he is the next person i would like to see go. it looks like that is not going to happen so i am just going to stop watching american idol altogether. *lol* ruben is always great. kimberly caldwell has a nice unique voice. trenyce can sing her ass off. but my favorite was charles. he was such a cutey. too bad he got voted off. :(
  • heather (View Email) on April 8, 2003
    I hope that either Clay or Ruben is the American Idol. They are both very good no matter what they sing . Carman and Kimberly could've probably switched songs then they would've been good tonight ( tues. the 8th )
    They both have good voices and they both have the looks and style but they can only sing to certain songs to where they are good . Joshua needs to stick with country songs he is very good at them .Trenyce needs to stay with Whitney Houston songs she does good on those .
  • Elizabeth (View Email) on April 8, 2003
    I LOVE RUBEN!!! Ruben is the most talented one up there, no doubt. It's obvious either he or Clay will win, but I think Ruben and Trenyce are the two best ones. They both have AMAZING voices!! Although my vote goes for Ruben, he's just a big 'ole teddy bear! He ROCKS!!! Even if he doesn't win, I just know he's going to make it big in the music world!
  • holly nelson (View Email) on April 8, 2003
    clay is an american idol and he will win!!!
    i like everybody else on there but CLAY is the best.
    he is sweet cute and hot hot hot!!!!!!

    this is a given but he is the bestest singer in the entire world!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    ill love you for ever clay
    love
    holly nelson
  • Sarah (View Email) on April 8, 2003
    Josh has my vote all the way!
  • sandy (View Email) on April 8, 2003
    I think the judges are showing favoritism toward ruben because he is black. I think the show feels that two white people were the top two last time and they do not want to look like racists...Clay is the best singer, but the say its ruben...its weird and I will not watch the show next year if ruben wins...he is not the best singer!
  • bobbie cornelius (View Email) on April 8, 2003
    Reuben Studdard... he's the one! The others aren't even in the same ballpark. They should just call it a no-contest and announce to the world that Reuben won. He is just too good for the group.
  • Shelley Mitai (View Email) on April 9, 2003
    I think Rueben is the most outstanding performer I've ever heard and seen. He is incredible and a awesome performer. Tumeke Rueben Good luck from Aotearoa (New Zealand)
  • Jake Summerlin on April 9, 2003
    A lot of people tell me that with my good looks and great voice that I should have tried out. Alright bye.
  • Ann (View Email) on April 9, 2003
    CLAY AIKEN IS THE MOST TALENTED AND MOST COMMERCIAL....HOPEFUL THE PUBLIC WILL CHOOSE THE ONE WHO SELLS.
  • Wab on April 9, 2003
    Geez... I just don't get what's so great about Ruben. His voice is okay, but not superb... it's not way better than everyone else's. If he was a thin white guy with that voice, he'd be already gone. Or, if he was just a thin guy, he'd be gone. Blah. He probably will win though, which sucks.

    Clay fans unite! Everyone vote for Clay billions of times in the last night, okay?

    One thing about this American Idol... all the people don't seem too idol-ish. The only people who seem like normal easily commercializable people are Trenyce, the blonde Kimberly and Carmen. But, Kimberly's all country-ish and the other two don't sing too well...
  • sarahdorwart on April 9, 2003
    Simmon is a prick to good singers. I think Kimberly Coldwell shoud win big time. She has a great voice and your always showing up in fashion. Good Luuuuuuck Kimberly!!!!!!!!
  • ME! (View Email) on April 9, 2003
    its definatly going to be Ruben. His voice is absolutely amazing and he continues to be wonderful week after week. I love Clay too, but his performances are to similar I'm getting sick of him. Anyways, I hope it's Ruben!
    Bye :)
  • Meg (View Email) on April 9, 2003
    OMG!! I LOVE RUEBEN!!!!!!!!!! HE ROCKS MY WORLD!! I LOVE HIM SOO MUCH AND HE BETTER WIN! HE IS THE SWEETEST, KINDEST PERSON I THINK I HAVE EVER SEEN IN MY LIFE! RUEBEN, IF YOU SEE THIS, THEN I JUST WANT U TO KNOW THAT EVERYONE LOVES YOU, AND THAT YOU ROCK EVERYONES WORLD! I LOVE YOU BABY!!!!
  • BERT W W (View Email) on April 9, 2003
    YO,YO, YO, THE BIG GUY 205, WERE LISTENING TOO YOU UP HERE IN NORTHERN MAINE ,, AND WE LOVE YOUR SOUND ,,, WE KNOW YOU WILL WIN,BECAUSE WHEN THE GROUND BEGINS TOO SHAKE AND THE MOUNTAINS BEGIN TOO QUAKE ,, WE ALL KNOW THAT IT IS RUUUUUUUUBEN THAT HAS BEGUN TOO SING BECAUSE HE IS THE ONLY ONE THAT CAN WIN!!!!!
  • jessica (View Email) on April 9, 2003
    Hi my name is Jessica Lemke. I am your biggest fan, and I would appritiate if you could come to our school and sing, we just think that you should be the next American Idol. Every one thinks you deserve it and you should call me @754-4254. I am only 12 years old but could you please come to your school and sing, or send me a letter or you could call me or even give us free tickets to American Idol,because we are sort of poor right now becase of the whole war thing going on in Iraq. That would be really nice of you. OOOOOOOOOOOh yeah could you please send me a picture of you and could you sign it please!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! thank you
    My address is 107 Sth. 6th. St. Reedsville,wiscon sin 54230 This means so much to me!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Oren James (View Email) on April 9, 2003
    Clay Aiken has the best voice and is the most enjoyable to watch. Although, Carmen is hot...Kimberly Caldwell is painful...she needs to go. I cant believe Rickey got voted off before her.
  • *Amber* (View Email) on April 9, 2003
    I think Ruben ROCKS THA HOUSE!!!!!!! He is so awesome!! I hope he wins!! he deserves it!! He is representing Alabam!!! Birmingham, Alabama!! He is soo cool!! He has a really good mellow voice and he hasnt messed up once!! All the others have messed up!! I like most of them but Ruben is THE BEST!!!! He should be the next American Idol! GOOOO RRRRRUUUUUUUUUUUBBBBBEEEEEENNN!!!
    ~*Amber*~
  • Addie (View Email) on April 9, 2003
    what can I say hummmmmm..I love you Ruben,
    You are the "BOMB".....
  • Audrey (View Email) on April 10, 2003
    Clay is the American Idol!!!!!!!!!! I love every part of him and he has the most amazing voice I have evr heard in my entire life. He can sing any type of music and sound incredible on everything. I wait all week long just to see him and hear his heavenly voice. Clay is ten times more talented then Rueben and I think that The judges favor him(especially randy) because he is big and black. I think that Rueben has talent but he doesn't even clome close to Clay. Clay For American Idol!!!!!! I love Clay and I know that if for some reason he dosn't win American Idol he will be one of the biggest pop stars ever. I think that he is the most talented, kind, selfless, caring, loving, funny, adorable person that has ever been in the media. I think that if Clay wins American Idol than he will change people's outlook on life like he has changed mine. I love Clay always and forever and he is my American Idol!
  • Christy (View Email) on April 10, 2003
    SANDY--Get a life! Rueben is clearly talented (more than any other contenstant). I can't believe in your ignorance you would make this an issue of race. Yes, Clay has a nice voice but the fact is: Clay's voice is more theatrical. The American Idol show is looking for a recording artist, not a broadway musical star. Rueben has it and your statement was utterly RACIST AND IGNORANT. Oh, in case you didn't know...duh! JUSTIN IS NOT WHITE. He is biracial...definitely not white. Obviously you missed all of the pictures of his parents.
  • Nora on April 10, 2003
    Sandy- the two top contestants were not white. Justin is half black, I think. Oh and Laurel is the coolest.
  • Jennifer (View Email) on April 10, 2003
    Why does Reuben wear 205 all the time???????
  • Korri on April 10, 2003
    Ruben is so much better than ANY of the other contestants. He should win easily. I do not understand the appeal of Clay. His voice is good, but he is not an AMERICAN IDOL! I predict that he will have much success in Broadway musicals. Clay certainly does not have the Idol look......I don't recall ANY skinny, pasty, pale men ever being IDOLS!
  • Brooke (View Email) on April 10, 2003
    Ruben Studdard is awesome!! He is like a velvet teddy bear is what Paula said and I agree 100 percent!!! He is so sweet cool and has the best voice I have ever heard. I think the should be the next American Idol.
    Randy gave Ruben a standing ovation and Simon said that he is the best one out there. He has never gotten a bad report from a judge!! Go Ruben!!!!!!!!
  • Brooke on April 10, 2003
    I think that Ruben is completly flawless! If anybody should win it should be Ruben. He has never screwed up and he sings so incredably great! This whole competition is about him!
  • ClaYs ThE bOmb (View Email) on April 10, 2003
    First thing is first, yes Ruben is good, that "cute little teady bear" as everyone calls him. BUT, the REAL talent here is definitly, DEFINITLY, Claayyyyyyy!!!!!!! Not only is he the hottest one on the show, but his voice is just amazing. He's completly real and unique-exactly what an idol should be. Do wat is good for ya:
    !VOTE CLAY!
  • Amanda (View Email) on April 10, 2003
    I don't see why anyone who has a problem with Clay uses the reasoning that he's too "Broadway-like." Most, if not all Broadway singers have more talent than any "Idols." I think it's time America looked outside of the box and appreciated real, raw, amazing talent. CLAY ALL THE WAY!!!!
  • Max gerald jean (View Email) on April 10, 2003
    RUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUban is my next american idol because he is too faaat.
  • Shauna (View Email) on April 10, 2003
    Ruben is awesome! i hope he wins he deserves it. it's about time we got a big guy as an american idol instead of some girl that only one becaus eof her looks. clay is awesome to but ruben is way better. I HATE kimberly caldwell and carmen they need to go some where they can't really sing!
  • Darcie on April 10, 2003
    WOW CLAY IS DEFINETLY THE BEST... ALSO NOT TO MENTION THE CUTEST!!! HES THE ONLY MAN I WANT TO SING TO ME AT NITE...AND THE ONLY ONE I WANT TO LISTEN TO WHEN I WAKE UP! GOD HES SO GOOD HE CAN MAKE ME MELT RIGHT WHERE I AM!! MUAH!
  • dan wise (View Email) on April 10, 2003
    Okay, Kimberly Caldwell rocks my world!!!!
    She has the most awesome amazing voice!!! She has so much star quality, and is really in to what she is doing. She's always focused. I do agree the last two weeks she has not performed as well, but she's still my favorite!!! The very first time I saw her on AI, I said she's gonna be in the top 10! She makes you want to get up and dance!!! I love her voice!! So amazing!!!! amazing!!! I guess I agree with her being in the bottom 3 this last week, but there were people worse than her, Rickey and Kim Locke!! Kim L.'s been in the bottom 3 three times already!!! Carmen SHOULD HAVE been voted off this week, she sucks!!!! Her voice is terrible. Even Simon doesn't like her. She's shit! My prediction is that she'll be voted off next week. And that Kimberly Caldwell is going to give the best performance of the night next week. She knows she has to raise the bar, and pick a song that really fits her. She can do it! And she will! And she will not be in the bottom 3 next week!!! My predicition for next week's bottom 3- is Carmen Rasmusen, no doubt! She sucks, and should've already been voted off, that vibrato crack--head! Can't even carry a tune! It will be Carmen, Josh Gracin, and the third spot for safety is up for: Kim Caldwell, Trenyce or Kim Locke. I'm really pushin' for Kim Locke, though. She's a great singer, but it's time to get a little more critical. And personally Trenyce and Kim C. should stay!!!! in the top 5! along with Ruben and Clay! Okay, Kim Caldwell is the bomb!!!! Go, Kim!
    -Dan Wise
    Stevens Point, WI
  • Amy (View Email) on April 10, 2003
    Sandy, race has nothing to do with it. Maybe you have a problem with race if you're going to the extreme of not watching if Rubin wins. Sounds like you have issues, hon. Rubin is awesome. Clay is good too. But don't be so narrow minded, girl!
  • Genny (View Email) on April 10, 2003
    I predict that Ruben will win this. And I really like Kimberly Locke. That girl can blow!! She should be runner up. Clay is good, but I don't think I will run out and by his CD, his voice is to redundant. Every song he sings sounds the same......boring!
    Ruben all the wayyyyyyyy!
  • Jay (View Email) on April 10, 2003
    Ruben IS the American Idol! There is no doubt..no, not any. Woo hoo! Sure Clay and Kim L can sing, but I can't help smile when I see Ruben. Like Simon says, "he's infectious". Go RUUUUBEN!
  • Jon (View Email) on April 10, 2003
    i want rubin the win cause he is FAT and i am FAT. i bet he has a nice rack too!
  • dan (View Email) on April 10, 2003
    so, here are my views on american idol 2:

    kimberly locke - okay, but chances are she will not win, probably because of the way that she looks.

    clay - probably will win, but i seriously am not a fan. sounds way to broadway for every song. ugh.

    ricky - so long, far well..., okay you know the rest of the sing (don't be scared to sing it as you're reading)

    trenyce - i totally agree with simon, she sucked. she shouldn't have sang that celine dion song...blah.

    joshua - okay, he is way too country sounding for me, but some people like country music. people like him because of the fact that he is a marine and 'dedicated to his country'.

    rubin - i have to admit that he can sing, but i really don't like him that much. wouldn't be surprised to see him in the top three.

    kimberly caldwell - that bryan adam's song was a big mistake. seriously, she sucked. she looked good, but her singing sucked. her voice is to smoky and wraspy for a slow song. i hope she gets the boot next week.

    carmen rasmusen - last but not least, we come to carmen. i like her, seriously. okay, she has had some problems with song choices, but she CAN sing really well ( i liked the blondie thing). she also has a great stage presence and has a good sense of style, or a good stylist. whatever. i know that she probably won't win, but if i had it my way, she would come in #1, or at least in the top 3.

    if you feel the same or have a problem with my choices, let me know.
  • fz123 on April 10, 2003
    how can you vote off ricky smith he probably had no no i know he was in the top 3 in the best performance wednesday now what dumbies who thought carmen or joshua were better you obviously are judging on who looks good and not on clearly the better talent which ricky smith has. and if clay wins this then it clearly shows you are not going by talent because if the people who vote go by talent you should choose RUUUUUUBEN STUDDARD
  • Kitty (View Email) on April 11, 2003
    My prediction is it will be down to Clay and Ruben. I hope Carmen wins though.
  • jenna (View Email) on April 11, 2003
    ruben desearves this win, he is clearly americas teddy bear, go ruuuuuuben, 205.... love ya babe!!!!!!!
  • Karen (View Email) on April 11, 2003
    Rueben Studdard is very gifted and talented. He makes it appear so easy. He should definitely be the next American Idol. His performances has been errorless.
  • Charles Delevigne (View Email) on April 11, 2003
    I've been watching the show for about two months now and the talent that has been shown has been of high standard and it's a pleasure to watch young talent get the chance at being a star. I really think the Simon Cowell doesn't know ahwt he is talking about, how he has managed to be a success in the music industry is dodgy, but I suppose with money , anything can be bought!
    It is getting harder to choose which is the best performer as they are all so talented and can sing in an musical style. It is an enjoyable, intertaining show that keeps my family glued to the TV. Give lots of encouragement to the daugs that are left, as they will succeed and become stars in their own right!
  • lizzie (View Email) on April 11, 2003
    CARMEN ROCKS!!!
    I hope she wins CLAY is awesome but Ruben is just like whoppie who gives!!!
  • lizzie (View Email) on April 11, 2003
    GO CARMEN shes my Utah-mormon girlie!!! carmen all the way!!!! ruben is boring he sounds the same every week YAWN but Carmen is MY idol!!!
  • Amanda B. (View Email) on April 11, 2003
    I love Clay so much. If you could I would enjoy it so much if you wrote back and told me his last name so that I could get pictures of him on the internet. Thank you so much.
  • Maine (View Email) on April 11, 2003
    hey we all know who the american idol is. my husband, ruuuuuuuuuben studard. he is the cutest thing i've ever seen and he can sing. he is the true american idol. my one wish is to get a hug from him.
  • Deb (View Email) on April 11, 2003
    Clay deserves to win because he's definitely the most talented. Ruben picks songs that everyone likes no matter what-- much like bands do at weddings. That's why Clay's performance in Motown blew everyone away. Everyone loves Motown songs. Check out KaZaA for a lot of other songs Clay has done like "Still the One" or "Love of my Life," "Set Me Free," and "Something New" and you'll see how versatile and incredible his singing is.
  • John Stockton (View Email) on April 12, 2003
    Rasmussen is god awful....she sounds like a damn yoddler...i cringre while she sings...kim caldwell has a deeper voice than most men.. she sucks too....i hate clay.. he looks like a rat..or a toy soldier..hes so dramatic and gay.. i hope josh or trenyce wins.
  • Chelsie (View Email) on April 12, 2003
    RUBEN IS GOING TO BE THE NEXT AMERICAN IDOL
  • Ashley Hogans (View Email) on April 12, 2003
    I think they all have a very good God given talent, but Ruben knows how to use it!!!!!!!!
    I really think Ruben deserves to be an American Idol because he sings for everyone not just for himself, and he sings from his heart and you can tell that it's coming from his heart because you can feel it and if you can't something is wrong with you!!

  • ChelzeE (View Email) on April 12, 2003
    Clay Aiken - SUCKS BIG TIME!!! OMG!!! He might sing okay, but his looks...........OMG OMG OMG!!! EWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW!!!!!!!!!! Who called the Adams Family?! Those ears......OMG!! DUMBO!!!! And his face.............SO PALE!!!! Ya, and his HAIR!!! Don't even get me started on his HAIR!!! EW EW EW EW EW!!!!

    Kimberly Caldwell - Dresses nicely, but her singing SUX!!!! She should get off sooooooooooooooon!!!! She's definetly not going to be the next American Idol!

    Ruben Studdard - IS THE BEST EVER!!!!!!! He has a great voice and he's a little teddy bear!!!! He has never messed up, unlike the others! Man, he is sooooooooooooo good!!!! HE IS THE NEXT AMERICAN IDOL!!!!! I mean, the whole thing is HIM!!!!
  • Andrea (View Email) on April 12, 2003
    Sandy open your eyes girl RACE is not the issue here TALENT is!!! If everyone was the same color and looked the same GOD what a boring world we would live in!!! I look at Ruben and see a person with great talent, pride, and beauty and the judges see that!! The rest of the contestants are all unique in the way they sound and look!! They are all great!! Ruban baby I know you will be the next Amercian Idol because of the way you represent yourself and of course your smooth irrestible voice!!!!!!!!!

    Andrea,
    Canada
  • Elizabeth (View Email) on April 12, 2003
    ok all i have to say is the person that comes in every week with a different voice and is good at it and who always gots the look it would definatly be Kimberly Caldwell i mean like she has so many different voices it's so great! i mean clay has that gross classical voice and Ruben i can't even understand what he's singing so vote for Kimberly Caldwell do you notice that kelly clarkson and Kimbberly Calwell have the same anitials?
  • brittany (View Email) on April 13, 2003
    THE ONLY reason carmen would win is cause she looks like A wanna be Brittney Spears. Kimberli Caldewell is a God awful mess. Anyone that keeps these 2 on is the downfall of the show. Don't hate because yall kinow Ruben can SING! Clay needs to go ahead and sing for Disney or somethin. Kim Locke can sing to but I don't think she should win. Trenyce can sing too,
  • Brittany (View Email) on April 13, 2003
    Sandy please come to your sences! When's the last time anyone was shown favor for being black. Maybe U haven't noticed but the "blacks" are slowly but surley leaving again. Speaking of Discrimination Tamira Gray a (black girl) should have won she can sing too plus she sales better!!!!! way better
  • Dee on April 14, 2003
    Yall suck for voting Ricky off. He really didnt deserve it. You should've voted off Carmen, she sucked wit that shaky voice
  • Justin (View Email) on April 15, 2003
    Everyone thinks Ruben is so good. Now, he can sing, but he's not anything special. He reminds me of a gospel singer. I think CLAY is the best!He should win the whole thing. His voice is so pure and strong. I also think Trenese is great, but might get voted out like Tamyra did on the first show. But, if it comes down to Rooben or Clay, people will pick clay because he can sing better. Face it.
  • Clay's Girll on April 15, 2003
    I LOVE CLAY!!!! HE HAS TO WIN!!! I HATE CARMEN!!! I CALL HER CARAMEN RATMUTANT!!! CARAMEN IS A FREAK!!!! I HATE HER BECAUSE SHE KISSED MY BOYFRIEND CLAY!!! CLAY'S NOT REALLY MY BOYFRIEND BUT IT COULD HAPPEN.
  • Clay's Girll (View Email) on April 15, 2003
    If you think either Clay and Carmen or Simon and Paula are dating, please email me. PLEASE EMAIL ME I HAVE TO KNOW WHAT OTHER PEOPLE THINK!!!!
  • sophie (View Email) on April 15, 2003
    yo!! Amanda B! Clay's last name is Akains! Hey I hope you can get your
    pictures!!!
    from,

    sophie
  • jeannie on April 15, 2003
    agh. i promised myself i would stop watching american idol if clay didn't get voted off but i just couldn't help myself today. it never ceases to amaze me how many fans clay has. why? are you all brainwashed or what? i just don't see it. i totally agreed with simon (who i love, btw) today when he told clay that he needs to stop making those weird faces. you know when he flutters his eyes and looks like he's gonna cry. *rolls eyes* it's getting so old. i just needed to vent. but i think it made it worse coming to this site and reading more from clay's fans. i lost respect in american idol. if clay wins, i hope there will be no american idol III b/c i will boycott against it for sure.
  • jeannie on April 15, 2003
    did someone actually refer to clay as hot? now i know you are losing your mind.
  • Jo on April 15, 2003
    Ruben should win because he sings with ease, picks the right songs for his voice, is versatile(He sang songs ranging from The Carpenters to Barry White with nooo problem), and has a star quality which the audience eats up. i can't get enough of him. Clay is good but he belongs on Broadway or in Vegas
  • Kyle (View Email) on April 15, 2003
    Ruben is so good, i just don't see anyone that is near his talent. Clay is good but he isn't a good recording artist. Out of the girls Trenyce has the best voise by far. Ricky being voted off had to be a mistake, Kimberly Caldwell, Carmen, and Josh are the worst by far.
  • Kimberly (View Email) on April 16, 2003
    WAY TO GO REUBEN!!! U KNOW HOW WE DO IT DOWN HERE IN BAMA!! I KNOW IN MY HEART YOU WILL BE THE NEXT AMERICAN IDOL. YOU DESERVE EVERY BIT IN IT. I MYSELF AND ALL OF 205 ARE BEHIND YOU 100%!!!! CAN'T WAIT TO SEE YOU BACK HERE IN B'HAM!!!! U KNOW U NEED TO GET W/ 95.7 F.M AND RELEASE A RECORD. MUCH LOVE TO YOU BABY!!!!!XOXOXOXO
  • Ashley (View Email) on April 16, 2003
    After this weeks performances, I think that Carmen needs to get the boot. She's a cute girl, but Carmen just dosn't have what it takes to win this competition.
  • Melissa (View Email) on April 16, 2003
    Yo Ruban deserves to win! He rocks and he has a great voice. Clay is good but not as good as Ruban! And Carmen stinks. Carmen and Kimberly Caldwell should get voted off they stink! GO RUBAN! It is prob. gonna be either u or Clay!
  • Haley Little (View Email) on April 16, 2003
    I think RUBEN is the best there will ever be on american idol if u doubt him your just stupid


    simon-your kool,funny
    Randy-your funny and real dog
    paul-your alsome
  • Erica (View Email) on April 16, 2003
    Hey i think rubn is sooo good im from birmingham(yes 205) and he is awsome!!!eveyone here has a 205 shirt representing ruban!!I think Ruban shoud be the next American Idol and bea bigger star than Jistin Timberlake!!
  • Cory (View Email) on April 16, 2003
    WHAT IN SAM JONES ARE YOU PEOPLE THINKING??? CARMEN'S GOAT VOICE SUCKS AND SHE SHOULD HAVE BEEN KICKED OFF RIGHT AFTER JULIA GOT KICKED OFF!!!! THE GIRL CAN NOT SING AND CAN'T DRESS WORTH A DARN!!! WHAT A ROLE MODEL FOR OUR LITTLE GIRLS IN TODAY'S SOCIETY (INCLUDING BRITTNEY AND CHRISTINA). THE MORE I WATCH THE SHOW THE MORE I WANT TO PUKE AFTER HEARING THAT BAAAAAAAAAAABAAAAAABAAAAAAABAAAAAAAAAD VOICE ALL THE TIME!!! COME ON PEOPLE LETS GET HER THE HECK OUTTA THERE!!!! WHO'S WITH ME ON THIS ONE??? RUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUBEN STUDDARD IS THE BOMB AND WILL WIN THIS COMPITITION!!! AND COMING UP BEHIND HIM WILL EITHER BE KIMBERELY L. OR CLAY WHICH DUDE I WOULDN'T EVEN BUY HIS CD IF HIS CD WAS THE LAST THING ON EARTH. THAT MAN IS SOOOOOOO UGLY!!! I REMEMBER BACK IN THE DAY WHEN I WAS A LITTLE GIRL SAYING THIS ONE SAYING ABOUT MY DADDY AND I WERE ON HIS MOTORCYCLE AND WE WENT THIS FAST AND YOU PUT YOUR HANDS ON CHEEKS AND PULL THEM BACK TOWARDS YOUR EARS, WELL THAT IS WHAT HIS FACE LOOKS LIKE!!! I DUNNO WHAT ELSE TO SAY, YES I DO ACTUALLY, KELLY C. FROM FIRST AMERICAN IDOL SUCKS AND WHAT WERE WE THINKING ON PICKING HER??? ANYWHO.........
  • bLaZeReTTe on April 16, 2003
    here are my opinions: kimberly C- i think she could really sing and she could dress to0. she would be the perfect pop star and if she wins i would prob. buy her cd unlike that donket sounding kelly clarkson! clay- he's alright :/ but his voice is to much for his small body. he should sing opera or broadway, anything other than pop. ruben- i love ruben. he's a really good singer could dress. he would make a good american idol and also a good role model to younger children. trenyce- she could sing but she never really picks songs that go well with her voice. i doubt that she'll win ricky- i got nothing to say about him since he already got voted off which i think was a big mistake! josh- he's more of a country singer and i dont really like him. it looks like he trys to hard when he sings and he makes these funny looking faces. i think he should get out of american idol and just go serve our country in the war in iraq cuz he aint gonna win. kimberly L- i think shes a really good singer but its just the songs that she picks which dont really bring out her voice. and finally..... carmen- i think she sux!!! she cant sing and i think she should have been voted off a long time ago. If she stays in the show its prob only because of her looks. i hope shes gone cuz i dont like her and simon doesnt like her and nobody else likes her either! so she needs to go home! i believe that the american public should have no say in who should be an american idol! they pick the stupidest ppl( such as kelly clarkson) i hope Kim C or Ruben win cuz their the best !!!
  • What the heck on April 17, 2003
    How does Carmen stay on week after week? She's HORRID. Utterly, utterly terrible. I think she's cheating or something. Self-centered, no talent - terrible.
  • 187um on carmen on April 17, 2003
    god damn who tha hell is voting for carmen rasmusen....so i can kill em all. damn i hate her she should have been voted off along ass time ago. she sounds like a freakin goat.
  • Jackie (View Email) on April 17, 2003
    Who does Carman know on the show - she should have never made it this far.
    Seems a little riged..
  • crystal on April 17, 2003
    I can honestly say im in love with Ruben!! haha hes the best,.. hes so cuddly looking and his voice matches his personality! If he doesnt win this shit is rigged!! :-) Ruuben #1!!!!!!Fer sure!
  • Sara (View Email) on April 17, 2003
    Go Carmen!!!!
    Clay looks like a RAT!!!
    RUUUUUUUUUBEN-you need to loose some weight
    Hey e mail me and tell me who think will win!
  • Jasmine (View Email) on April 17, 2003
    I love Carmen..its about time Kimberly was voted out..she has the stage presence but not the voice. I love the unique echo sound of Carmens voice..i hope she wins..she has the sweetness and the talent and the looks to be an American idol..she doesnt flaunt her body like some of the others..she needs to dress a little more appealing..and have a little more confidence to win. I really dont know how the judges have overlooked the fact that Kimberly Caldwell just doesnt have the voice..I like Josh as second place although being married might be a barrier for him. Clay is good but doesnt have the soul..he needs to move his body a little more.
  • JJ (View Email) on April 17, 2003
    And Then there were six! As awful as I tell everyone the show is, I can't help but tune in to see the next contestant get booted.

    The marine guy, he is terrible. Can anyone guess why he is still on? Actually the two best by far are Reuben and Clay. Now I'm deffinately no expert, but this Clay guy, sure he can sing but he seems so damn feminine. He's more like the homosexual version of American Idol. Not that there is anything wrong with that!! Reuben on the other hand he's not your typical pop star, but that guys voice drags me to fox every tues and wed night.
    One last note. Paula Abdul is still one of the sexiest women in the industry today. She can judge me anytime
  • yogibetts@aol.com (View Email) on April 18, 2003
    I REALLY ENJOY HEARING REUBEN STUDDARD SINGING HE HAS A REALLY SMOOTH VOICE VERY PLEASANT AND HE CAN REALLY FLOW AND GET THE CROWD STANDING ON THEIR FEET.AND HIS VOICE REALLY TOUCHES EVERYONE AND REALLY GETS THEM GOING AND TOTALLY STANDING ON THEIER FEET. REUBEN HAS MY VOTE TO BE THE NEXT AMERICAN IDOL YOUR NUMBER ONE FAN YOGIBETTS@AOL.COM
  • Tanisha (View Email) on April 18, 2003
    Rueben has my vote and so does Josh. Josh has a wonderful voice and he is a fellow service member. I admire him for what he is doing, I know his mind has got to be with his boys now more then ever and yet he seems to sing people away. Reuben well, he is very very talented and a teddy bear. His voice is so awesome and powerful. I don't know who I want to win, I think if its one of them I'll be happy.
  • Jami (View Email) on April 18, 2003
    hey lizzie carmen sucks ruben is much better thats why carmen was in the bottem 3 like 3 times
  • Jordan (View Email) on April 18, 2003
    I think Clay, and Kimberly Lock should be the last two contestants standing!! At first I didn't like Kimberly Lock, but when she sand New York State of Mind, she sure did change my mind about her!!! I also like Ruben and Josh. I think those should be the last four contestants standing, and Clay should be the next Idol!!!
  • Laney (View Email) on April 18, 2003
    CLAY !!!! He's mah man. Only reason I've watched the show since the beginning.

    Well, and Simon of course! He's perfectly right on everything he's said since the beginning. haha! GO SIMON!
  • jake on April 18, 2003
    I think for some one to be an american idol you have to have looks and that means clay is out. you have an amazing voice an all but its like simon said i perfer you with my eyes closed
  • Lauren (View Email) on April 18, 2003
    hey yew people!im lauren and i am the biggest american idol fan in the world!i swear!lol..but anywayz i really am cuz on kazaa i have download the auditions performances and everythinggg!but yeah anywayz,i so want rueban to win cuz he is juss awesome! and i want second place to be kimberly locke or trynece!but ya know i cant stand another wk with carmen and joshua! i mean they are really getting on my nerves! but anywayz,yeah if yall share this love of american idol with me please email me! love ya!!
  • me on April 19, 2003
    ruben is the best!!! u cant beat him!! GO RUBEN!!
  • josh (View Email) on April 19, 2003
    Kim Caldwell ROCKS. I love her so much. i so sucks that she was eliminated. that was a bad choice for american citezens. also Josh G. SUCKS ANUS . he claims to love this country but what has he shown to back that up besidesbeing a marine. it's not like he is the only one. he is such a show off with that faggot country smile he cant sing at a. he would have been gone a long time ago if it wasnt for being a marine. he needs to go and fast. dont get me wrong, I love this country more than ay thing it' just I hate josh as well. sstvoting for a talentss cowboy. kim c. rules and he will still be a huge sucsess despit her elimination. dont hate me, its just how i feel. we all have the right to our own opinion and this is mine.
  • laura (View Email) on April 19, 2003
    Rubin and Kimberly Locke should make babies! They are soooo Good! I hope Rubin wins! I just love to hear him sing!
    Go, Rubin, Go Rubin.........
  • Whitney Horton (View Email) on April 19, 2003
    Carmen sucks!
  • trisha (View Email) on April 19, 2003
    What does the "205" that
    Rueben always wears stand for?
  • JU (View Email) on April 20, 2003
    I FNK RUBEN WIIL WIN..I MEEN HES LIKED BY THE MEANEST JUDGE OF ALL..SIMON COWELL..UM..BUT HE REALLY KNOWA HOW T SING...AND CLAY AIKEN..OH HELL NO..I HATE IT HOW HE GIVES THT SMILE WEN PAULA OR RANDY SAY HES FANTASTIC..HE ACTS LIKE A PUFF.. BUT ALL I HAVE TO SAY IS..GO RUBEN!!!!!YOU WILL TAKE IT OUT!!!!!!
  • LIZ (View Email) on April 20, 2003
    I FNK RUBEN WIIL WIN..I MEEN HES LIKED BY THE MEANEST JUDGE OF ALL..SIMON COWELL..UM..BUT HE REALLY KNOWA HOW T SING...AND CLAY AIKEN..OH HELL NO..I HATE IT HOW HE GIVES THT SMILE WEN PAULA OR RANDY SAY HES FANTASTIC..HE ACTS LIKE A PUFFTA.. BUT ALL I HAVE TO SAY IS..GO RUBEN!!!!!YOU WILL TAKE IT OUT!!!!!!
  • Ruben on April 20, 2003
    GO RUBEN!!!!
  • adie (View Email) on April 20, 2003
    RUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUBEN is my AMERICN IDOL and he is GOING TO WIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Ali (View Email) on April 20, 2003
    My opinion: (final six)

    Carmen: Why is she still here?! It's like "Attack of the Mormons." She's a cockroach, she just wont die!! She sounds like she's gargling listorine!

    Kimberely Locke: I agree with Smokie, "This girl can SANG!" She should definately be at the last show, and should be second place, imho.

    Josh: I hate this country gig he thought up. I used to like him before he started faking his voice. Now he sounds stupid and it's pointless to keep him in the competition. He should be gone after Carmen.

    Trenyce: I really like her voice. She has alot of talent, and she should be 4th. The reason I put her there is because sometimes she growls or something, and it really gets on my nerves.

    Ruben: People need to learn how to spell his name. It isn't Reuben, Rubin, Rueban...god it's pathetic. Anywho, I think he has a very nice, average voice. He should be third because he sounds complacent, but has more control than Trenyce, and sounds a whole lot better than Goat-girl or Josh. The only "problem" is that he doesn't tounge his "t's." It sounds like "duh."

    Clay Aiken, I.E, American Idol:
    Clay rocks people! Wake up and hear the talent. Such control! Such tone! Such a range! *coughplushe'skindahotcough* He is such a role model as well and has a buttload of talent! Vote Clay A. all dah way!

    That's my opinion! Hope you like!
  • ruben's #1 fan on April 20, 2003
    ruben is so good i hope he wins.
    if he for some reasons gets kicked off i hope clay wins no doubt they will choose a male they have to.

    thanx
  • helper on April 21, 2003
    to trisha, 205 is his area code a representin!!
  • lisa (View Email) on April 21, 2003
    Did Simon insult Carmen so much so that she would get sympathy votes? Is that how she stayed on last week.. She was his wild card pick you know. I think it is rigged.
  • lisa (View Email) on April 21, 2003
    Josh looks like he is taking a dump when he twang out a tune.
  • jcrew on April 21, 2003
    man them stupid mormons need to quit voting for carmen i think CARMEN SUCKSSSSS!!!!!!!!!! i cant stand looking at her messed up face anymore. kimberly locke is looking fine now with them tight ass shirts she be wearing. oh yeah ruben is gonna win. i hate that [expletive] clay hes full of himself.
  • Ethel (View Email) on April 22, 2003
    Number one American Idol is RUBEN! Let's hear it for RUBEN!

    Kimberely Locke if Smokie said you can SANG believe me Girlfriend you can SANGGGGGGGG! Looking to pick up your "CD" soon.
  • Maria (View Email) on April 22, 2003
    Ok Carmen SUCKS! She is awful. I don't understand - I mean she's probably the "cutest" one up there but that's not saying much. The only people who like her are from Utah or Mormon. It pains me to hear her. I feel like my ears are bleeding. I think it's unfair to others that were EXTREMELY better than her that she didn't get voted off already. If for some incredible reason she won I would loose all faith in music. This whole season is filled with actual talent, except for Carmen.
  • brenda rodriquez (View Email) on April 22, 2003
    My comments are that.I really liked Kimberly Caldwell.I thought that she was a very outgoing person.But as for my choice in who I think the next american idol should be.My choice would be a toss up between Kimberly Locke and Ruben Studdard.Ruben has a great voice but I am leaning towards kimberly Locke because she has more to offer.She can change her voice and sing almost anything whereas Ruben has the same sound on everything that he sings.In closing I think that they are both great.In ending this I must say GO KIMBERLY LOCKE
  • ~Stephanie~ on April 22, 2003
    HEY HEY! SUP DAWG?! GO JOSHUA GRACIN!!!!!!
    U ARE SOOO TALENTED AND GOOD-LOOKING! LUV YA
  • ruben fan (View Email) on April 22, 2003
    Ruben is the man he is goin all da way, representin da 205 baby.
  • Gerry (View Email) on April 23, 2003
    Carmen stinks BIG TIME!!!! She needs to leave, NOW. It is LONG overdue.
  • Brad (View Email) on April 23, 2003
    Kim L: Damn sexy and will be in the top 3
    Trenyce: Nice mouth, but just a little too close too the ghetto..by-by
    Clay: great voice. He's starting to get on my nerves...top 3 but by-by
    Ruben: ...and the winner is...
    josh: get that stone faced jar head out of here...contrary to popular belief, he SUCKS
    by-by
    Carmen: How in the hell did this stupid little girl make it this far. She SUCKS consistantly every week. I don't know if its the acne, or if its the clothes, or the obvious stupidity, or the fact that her voice sounds like snip and fix time at the kennals but ...pleeeaasssseee America do not vote for this pin head. If I know anything about mormons they shouldn't be watching the show anyway(I think I heard Ryan say "crap" last week)-let alone voting for the pathetically underqualified bimbo.
  • Debi Landry (View Email) on April 23, 2003
    My favorite is Clay, he is an American idol. He is a very talent young man and by the way he performs he seems to be very true. Mostly I voted for him not only because he is the best singer but he is a caring young man. I have a special needy child and it takes a very special and loving person to interact with our children. If he can love and be loved by our children, then that makes him an American idol to me.
  • Rebekah (View Email) on April 23, 2003
    I love Ruben!! i think it will come down to Ruben and Clay but i think Ruben will win!!
  • Jordan McCraw on April 23, 2003
    I predict that Ruben will win...and he's adorable...but Clay should really be the winner. He is a true American Idol, in every way...e.g., working with handicapped children...he's just a very good person, and he is living proof that what really matters is what comes from within (whether that be a beautiful voice or a desire to help others).
  • paige anderson (View Email) on April 23, 2003
    i think Carmen or Joshua should win because they are really cute and pretty. They are the best people I have ever seen on American Idol. I also think Paula is pretty to and that makes me looking forward to watching American Idol. Carmen and Joshua also make me looking forward watching American Idol,
  • Lisa Raye (View Email) on April 23, 2003
    Kimberly Locke is the best I would love to see her win the whole thing. She just gets better and bettter each week. Clay and Ruben can sing and they are cool but they just seem the same week after week and as for the rest. Trenyce can sing if she picks the right songs and Joshua sounds only good singing country. As for Carmen Why is she still there if Kimberly C. isnt. She was better
  • Nick (View Email) on April 23, 2003
    Ruben- My favorite YOUR THE BEST RUBEN!!! ROOOOOO!
    Kimberly- My Second best , GOOD LUCK!
    Trenyce-Your ok, my third favorite
    Clay-I really hate you, troll.
    Josh-Im glad your a marine, but your not good enough to win this comp.
    Carmen-terrible, last on the list, like every thing else in your life im assuming...
  • Rubens g/f (View Email) on April 23, 2003
    I LOVE RUBEN SO MUCH! HE IS GONNA WIN! HE HAS SO MUCH TALENT AND HAS THE CUTEST DIMPLES!
  • Crazyhorse (View Email) on April 24, 2003
    Carmen didn't always sing well, but she always had my vote. Mainly, because she was a good girl and not a slut like some (Kimberly Caldwell). Kim C. should have been the first one to go, she looks and sounds like a horse who ate bad hay. I'm sorry Carmen is gone, she was so cute. Ruben & Clay will be on top....Kimberly, I don't know, she's getting better, but she has sucked it up a few times and is not a stranger to the bottom three.
  • Sirene (View Email) on April 24, 2003
    That's what I like about being an American. We can give our two cents and no one really cares. So...here's mine. This is a long entry. I don't suggest you read it. =) Ruben: judges' favorite, majority's favorite...I think he's the next American Idol, just because he's so marketable. I can see him in almost any genre of music. Josh: the Marines rule, and he's got a nice voice, but he's nothing out of the ordinary. Kimberley: beautiful voice. I hope she'll be in the top three because she can really sing. She's always been my favorite of the females, so I hope she does make it somewhere...even though she probably won't win. Trenyce: even better voice. Total professional. I hope she'll be in fourth place, though...that spotlight on her arrest wasn't exactly great. Clay: wow, such haters...I see.... Well, since a ton of people said how gay and ugly and geeky he is, I'd like to say the opposite. He has the most unusual voice of all of them. I just can't see him doing the idiotic things that J.Timberlake does...so it's Broadway for him. He's a really nice guy, so willing to help kids and so gentlemanly that America is just dying for him to reveal his true feelings for Ryan Seacrest. Haha, but really, Clay Aiken is my idea of what the American Idol should be--- angelic voice, gentlemanly manner, true goodness, shy but confident exterior...and the list goes on. And he's really hot, too. Beautiful green eyes, I swear. And if he is gay, or bi...so be it, it doesn't matter. People seem to think there's something wrong with that, which is unfortunate...because it shows exactly how narrow-minded our society is. Oh yeah...and... Simon: hey, sometimes he's right, and he's wrong. He's only human, he can't help being so blunt and cruel. Paula: great singer and performer, with great style, but she needs to cut back on those happy pills. Randy: definitely my favorite AI judge. He rocks and he's real. I love the way he talks. Ryan: complete...total...moron. I vote Ryan Seacrest off the show. Too bad so many people like him. That includes Clay, if you think about it. I was wondering about them when Ryan asked Clay, "So, what was your inspiration for this new hairstyle?" and he stared into his eyes for several moments and replied, "Well, it kinda looks like what's up there, don't you think?" Hah, that was funny. By the way, some people here need to stop using the caps lock key. I mean, I know you've got anger management issues (so do I), but it is painful to look at posts written all in capitals. Thank you.
  • Ella (View Email) on April 24, 2003
    Question:

    Does anyone know where to get a "205" shirt like Ruuuueben wears? I've been searching the net and haven't got a clue!!!!

    Please help!! Thanks

    A Big Rueben fan.
  • BH (View Email) on April 24, 2003
    Thank God goat girl is gone... Josh is next out.. Clay is such a twink, can't stand to watch his face, he rolls his eyes and flutters his eye lids, what a wuss... Trenyce, Kimberly and Ruuuuben will be tough decisions. Go Trenyce...
  • Jamie (View Email) on April 24, 2003
    www.205flava.com

    yay carmen is gone, she bleated like a goat, it made me ill. Josh the marine is next, and if america weren't in such a fervent patriotic seizure right now because of the war he wouldn't have made it this far. He is way out of his league...and he couldn't find a key with a spotlight.
  • VONDA BYRD (View Email) on April 24, 2003
    MY FAVORITES IN THE AMERICAN IDOL COMPETITION ARE RUEBEN STUDDARD AND KIMBERLY CALDWELL. BUT IF I HAD TO CHOOSE ONE OF THE TWO IT WOULD DEFINITELY BE RUEBEN STUDDARD!!!
  • Antionette (View Email) on April 24, 2003
    Ruben is #1 and should win. Clay sucks at sing the songs "we" buy. He is more like Disney songs or something. He is not an American Idol. Kimberly Locke and Ruben should be the only ones up there. Even if Ruben doesn't win, someone will be signing him! For sho'! What every happen to the first American Idol? If the American Idol win and then disappears off the face of the earth, then i don't won't Ruben to win. He deserves to be seen and heard by the public. He is America's Velvet Teddy Bear! Go Ruben!!!! 205!
    ~I love you Ruben!
    A fellow Bamania (Fairfield)!
    You Know!!
  • me on April 24, 2003
    ruben gets his shirt made like that
  • TJ (View Email) on April 24, 2003
    I definately hope that Ruben wins. He seems the most genuine of them all plus has an amazing voice with good range and can go deep. I can't stand watching Clay. He is so damn annoying. Especially how he winks at people and fake talks 'thank you' all the time. Just as Simon said--he should be singing on Broadway instead. I hate the way he hangs on the syllables. Does anyone else hear it too? Or are they blinded by thinking how nice he is? There are tons of people that help out people less fortunate than they are but that doesn't mean they should win this contest. This contest is for who would make the best songs, have the most fans and make them the most money. For these reasons I hope that Ruben wins. I haven't seen one person say that they hated Ruben, but MANY for hating Clay. For anyone that says that Clay is hot, etc: if you didn't know who he was and met him on the street you wouldn't give him the time of day. Now that Carmen is gone he will havta try to get with Kimberly....or Ryan? What's up with his purple lips too?
  • Donna Blackwell (View Email) on April 24, 2003
    Ruben and Clay have been my favorites the whole time and now Kimberly has joined them although I think Ruben will win the whole thing, I just love his dimples. but all three seem to be just what america needs a nice idol. The kids need to know you do not need to not have sex on stage or be half naked to make it...Just plain good old talent.
  • shay (View Email) on April 24, 2003
    Kimberly Locke and Ruben Studdard were my favorits from the start. For some odd reason I just thought they stood out form the rest of them. Size and looks had nothing to do with it. It was what I heard when they open their mouths to sing. It wasn't the songs that they song. All I heard was "I can sing" and I love it. Not to take anything from the rest of the contestant, because they all were good but I have my favorits. I would love to get a photograph of them.
  • ------- (View Email) on April 24, 2003
    don't be hatin'
  • mike (View Email) on April 25, 2003
    I think Ruben should win. He is never up and down, always constant. A guy shouldn't be here talking but what the hell. I like the man's singing and his 205 SHIRT!!!!!
  • Go Reuben, boo CLay and Carmen on April 25, 2003
    Reuben is amazing! THey should just stop the competition now and anounce Reuben as the winner.

    I hear ya TJ about Clay. I can't stand that tool. He looks like a character on southpark and sounds like a disney singer, not pop star. Maybe sing-alongs, Clay, but you won't get my vote. No sir.

    BUt even more than CLay, I hate Carmen. Ugh. Has anyone else noticed that she used globs of make-up to cover her hideous amounts of acne. And when she sings, she sounds like a goat. She actually bleats. And to think people like Kimberly Caldwell, CHarles, and Ricky Smith got out before her. I HATE that woman!
  • tasha (View Email) on April 26, 2003
    I DO BELIVE RUBEN WILL BE THE NEXT AMERICAN IDOL. BECAUSE HE IS BLESSED BY GOD. HE REPRESENTS THE 205 VERY WELL. BECAUSE I AM FROM THE 256. YOU GO RUBEN.
  • so sad on April 28, 2003
    This message board is so, so sad. Get a life people. This show is crap. All the contestants are terrible.
  • barbara (View Email) on April 28, 2003
    On the google search this site said that they don't like Clay, and they like Ruben, why????? Can Ruben hit the high notes like Clay? Does Ruben help children with autistic dideases? Does Ruben even have a job? no. He didn't make it this far because of talent, but because he has a dazed face and people think it's cute. Little velvet teddybear??? Why, because he's fat? Ruben has no chance to beat Clay. While Clay helps a thirteen year old boy, Ruben is at the closest McDonalds! Ruben just has ability to be athe trendsetter. 205, velvet teddybear, RRRUUUBBBEEENNN SSSTTTUUUDDDAAARRRDDD!! that is all to get attention. CLay doesn't need it because he has such an outstanding voice that he doesn't need stupid catchy phrases to get him votes. GO CLAY!!!!!!!! :) i HATE Ruben. Oh, and a nother thing, update your webpage!!! The conestants are alreadt down to five!
  • barbara (View Email) on April 28, 2003
    On the google search this site said that they don't like Clay, and they like Ruben, why????? Can Ruben hit the high notes like Clay? Does Ruben help children with autistic dideases? Does Ruben even have a job? no. He didn't make it this far because of talent, but because he has a dazed face and people think it's cute. Little velvet teddybear??? Why, because he's fat? Ruben has no chance to beat Clay. While Clay helps a thirteen year old boy, Ruben is at the closest McDonalds! Ruben just has ability to be athe trendsetter. 205, velvet teddybear, RRRUUUBBBEEENNN SSSTTTUUUDDDAAARRRDDD!! that is all to get attention. CLay doesn't need it because he has such an outstanding voice that he doesn't need stupid catchy phrases to get him votes. GO CLAY!!!!!!!! :) i HATE Ruben. Oh, and a nother thing, update your webpage!!! The conestants are alreadt down to five!
  • Marirose (View Email) on April 28, 2003
    I think clay and josh ruben should win they are my idol im glad carmen is out oh ya boooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
    simon you are so mean i hate you and whats rong w/ ya cant we here you sing god.........
  • melanie (View Email) on April 28, 2003
    Why is Josh still a contestant?? Why didn't he go on NASHVILLE STARS??
  • cari (View Email) on April 29, 2003
    i LOVE Rueben Studdard!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!He better win!!!
  • CuDdLeZ (View Email) on April 29, 2003
    COMING STR8 FROM NZ, I AM A PROUD FAN OF RUEEEEEEEEBEN !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    HE IS DA MAN WID DA BOMB AS VOICE WHICH WE ALL KNO YEAH YEAH !!
    RUEBEN U CAN DO IT.... TAKE DIS COMP OUT ....MAKE UR FAMZ & FRIENDZ PROUD
    NZ IS VOTING FOR YOU ASWELL........ GOOD LUCK......WE LOVE YOU......

    RUEBEN YOU ARE A GODESS...AND NO ONE CAN SING THE MANHATTANS LIKE YOU. YOU WERE BORN WIFF DA VOICE GO OUT THERE AND MAKE US PROUD
    DO IT FOR '' SWEET HOME ALABAMA'' AMERICA IM COMING HOME TO YOU LOLZ
    RUEBEN WE LOVE YOUUUUUUUUUUUUUU XXXXX
    UR NUMBA *2 COUNTRY NEW ZEALANDDDDDDDDDDDDDD.. BRING UR TALENT THESE WAYS LOLZ CYAHHHHHHHHHH
    FROM CUDDLEZ ....................
  • Olivia (View Email) on April 29, 2003
    First off, I LoVe Clay Aiken he is the most amazing singer... it is so weird when I watch this show I honestly compare them to singers today like Britnay Spears she's pretty and all and I like her music but she cant sing for shit! I think Simon is alittle on the harsh side and should clean his ear for some of the preformances but I do say a lot of the times his statements are so what considerable! Clay is gay! That is such a shock to me we don't no if its 100% sure but hell if it is I'll turn him StRaIgHt! He should defently win this compation! Rubin i dont understand.... there is nothing special about him yea he's a freakin massive teddy bear which is cool and all but his voice and vocal skills are ok! Clay is born to preform he's so hot and talented! All i want to do is meet Clay! He is the American Idol!!
  • nora on April 30, 2003
    Ok, I went looking for what America was saying about everyone on American Idol, and after reading some of the comments I am quite disappointed. Regardless of whether you like someone or not, none of the contestants deserve harsh comments about who they are as a person. These few were selected from thousands of people to be where they are now. Thank goodness that most of them seem like a nice wholesome bunch of people! They all have good personalities and are all very talented.


    With that said, I want to say that my pick for the top three is #3. Ruben #2. Kimberly Lock, and my number 1 choice is: Clay Aiken. Kimberly and Clay have the best voices, and for the Ruben fans, don't get angry..I think all three of the names I mentioned will have people knocking at their door for record deals..it is just that Clay is the most talented of the three. As for looks..who cares? I mean really? Personally I think Clay is cute, but I think someone above said he was a troll? Let's get serious here for a moment..if you were on stage, hoping to win because you love music and music was always a part of your life, would you want someone to tell you that you are ugly, or fat, or any of the negative names I have seen listed above as if it was the end of the world if you were?

    And I agree with Simon, Clay would be good for Broadway But I also bet that Clay would sound good singing anything. You could even give him "Row, Row, Row Your Boat" to sing, and he would still rock the house!

    I hope he wins, but if he doesn't..I know he will still have an album; and I will be there to buy it! (As well as Ruben's and Kimberly's).

  • Norma Becker (View Email) on April 30, 2003
    This secondd season is really very very special. The last contestants are all so very good and deserving. Josh is very polite and somewhat shy and very sweet. I do see him as the next Singing Cowboy. And he would be wonderful. The Sons of the Pioneeers are gone. As well as Gene, Roy and others. He could do it with all hands down. I really love Ruban and think he would be a wonderful recording artist number 1. He really has been the one who has had nothing but good at every performancem Now I give you the next FRANKIE Sanitra, Yes he has it all. The shy little winks and half smile (as someone else who was king. The girls are very good and they will be caught up with someone after the finalist have been choosen. Look at last seasons runners ups. So Mr. Wonderful and the American Idol for me is CLAY ATKINS Another STAR is born. and a note to Simon. I like you for not letting them think they are doing great and they are not. This really helps leting them down easy when it comes time to vote they are let down easier. So as I sid before they are all very good and I love all of them. But GO Clay GO Mr. Wonderful. 4/29/03
  • Marina on April 30, 2003
    Hey everyone ...
    I think that Kimberly Locke and Clay are awesome .
    Simon Is rude, Well Randy is all about the dawg and Paula is a sweet heart and she manges to tell it how it is nicely ... Wow imagine that Simon... Someone who knows how to be nice ... Take a lesson! :) well Everyone you are all doing a great job, so hang in there~ And simon i must admit you are not all mean cause when you do say something nice, I think its sound s very encouraging so yeah Way to go guys.
  • Jackie Martin (View Email) on April 30, 2003
    My family and co-workers LOVE this show. In fact I arrange my schedule as far as dinner, washing cloths, shopping, etc. around the show. There is so much undiscovered talent out there and it is really a pleasure watching these kids compete. I wish all of them luck--when they get into the final ten, even the ones voted off are good enough to make it in entertainment. However, this group we have this year are sensational. I love to hear Josh sing country but especially enjoy Clay and Ruben. They are amazing! Thanks for bring us this entertainment.

    Where can I buy a 205 Ruben T-shirt?
  • Da bomb (View Email) on April 30, 2003
    Ruban Studdard sucks and trenyce is Da bomb and Tamyra should have won the first a.i.
  • Can't Understand? (View Email) on April 30, 2003
    American Idol has to be rigged, how can Trenyce and Ruben have less votes than Joshua Gracin. I don't understand. Josh is in the wrong contest, he should be in Nashville Stars. Even in Nashville Stars I don't think he'll make it that far. Because he is a nice guy and from the marines does not mean he should advance to the next round. I do not believe he is a better singer than Trenyce. America needs to start voting for the most talented person.
  • leon maloney (View Email) on April 30, 2003
    I think reuben is good but i find him to be singing the same style everytime. To me he is boring. I hope Kimberly Locke wins or Trenyce. I hope that loser josh would just get off.
  • Marcus (View Email) on May 1, 2003
    RUBEN IS KING!!! HE SHOULDNT OF BEEN IN THE BOTTEM TWO! YOU SUCK AMERICA!!!
  • Karen (View Email) on May 1, 2003
    Rueben has the whole package. He has the stage presence,voice and personality. America,Rueben has been consistant all the way through. The other contestants hadto re-defined themselves as they went along. Clay has a nice voice but, Rueben clearly is the total package.
    Last night when I saw that Rueben was in the bottom two I knew then that America was not looking for the total package they are voting for their friends which is not fair.I stopped watching American Idol last year when Tamyra Gray was booted off which was unfair. Life isn't fair and you have proven that on American Idol 2. I will not watch this program any longer. Totally Discussed


  • Laurel (View Email) on May 1, 2003
    I don't think American Idol is rigged, I think that American is made up of mostly idiots. Josh has only made it this far because he is a marine. There is NO OTHER EXPLANATION. It just shows how the military has pervaded so many aspects of American society. He's terrible, Ruben has a terrific voice.
  • Aaron (View Email) on May 1, 2003
    Ruben should have never been in the bottom two this week. What are you thinking America? Josh frickin' sucks! He should have been gone a long time ago. I can't believe that Trenyce was voted off and JOSH wasn't even in the bottom two. Rooooooben Rules! Clay too!
  • OneOfWisdom (View Email) on May 1, 2003
    Hello All, I know that everyone has their comment about the singers. It is not necessary for anyone to bash another contestant. They are all someone's American Idol. Yes, Trynece went home this week. It had to be either this week or next week. Does it really matter which one it was. Remember to vote for CLAY and all will be fine. Yes, I said it. Clay is the American Idol. And for those who were upset that Tamara did not win last year. It is all about song selection and the week she was voted off she was worst than Nikki. Now, I know that all the other weeks she did do better than Nikki but that week she did not. So, YOU PEOPLE... Yes, AMERICA should not be upset. I can't get upset if I don't vote and last year I did not vote. But this year I am voting for CLAY. Becuase he is the American Idol. Have a wonderful day.
  • OneOfWisdom on May 1, 2003
    My vote is and always has been for Clay. I have been a fan since his audition. He is my American Idol.
  • Sherree (View Email) on May 1, 2003
    I LOVE RUBIN. HE HAS A LOT OF STAGE PRESENCE.I HOPE AND PRAY HE WINS THIS THING. I AM A LITTLE UPSET THAT TRENYCE LEFT BECAUSE I THINK WHOEVER THINKS OR WANTS JOSH TO WIN IS STUPID, CRAZY AND RETARDED. I FEEL THAT HE IS NOT COMPETITION FOR RUEBEN. EVERY ONE SHOULD SIT DOWN BECAUSE RUEBEN IS GOING TO WIN HANDS DOWN.
  • Kim (View Email) on May 1, 2003
    I absolutely think that everyone in the competition is talented. But everyone is not meant to be the next AMERICAN IDOL! Clay and Josh should definitely not win this competition simply because they are not fitting the criteria. RUEBEN has this competition in the bag. I was truly PISSED OFF that he was in the final two. Josh had his head down because he knew that it should of been him. We are not at a country western bar so in that case-he doesn't belong. Please be smart AMERICA and vote off Clay and Josh. Just open your eyes and listen to my REUBEN sing.
  • sheila (View Email) on May 1, 2003
    I think Reuben has a great voice but Clay has managed to win my heart. He can sing high notes, low notes and hold notes. Reuben has to sing something different he,s good but a little boring. I think Clay was gifted at birth with a natural singing voice.
  • Korey Sauers (View Email) on May 1, 2003
    Dear american idol,

    why won't pick rubn not josh next time please pick josh off the show please
  • lewis (View Email) on May 1, 2003
    This Show is rascist, whites vote for josh because they think too many blacks are on it. To all the whites, give up!!!!!!! Reuben will be a star
  • JeSs (View Email) on May 1, 2003
    I think ruben is the best no matter wat he sings very good he da man And josh sucks he should be out he is only on bc he is a marine well u no what he sucks! clay and ruben should be the last 2 then ruben should win...AND RUBEN IF U SEE THIS U ARE THE BEST NO MATTER WHAT HOLLA
  • Allison (View Email) on May 1, 2003
    I am not one to watch all of these silly reality television shows....except for American idol of course! I will not miss this show for anything. I love it! All the top 10 have been amazing and I congratulate all of them! I must say though that I am astonished that Ruben was in the bottom two! What is everyone thinking? He is absolutley amazing and I literally melt everytime i hear him. Ruben you are incredible, and wil take it all the way!
  • CJ (View Email) on May 1, 2003
    yeh i agree withLaurel....i do think americans are mosde up of mostly idiots.....y because they put Ruben in the bottom 2.....i mean serioiusly it should have been Clay cuz he sux ...and who the hell thinks clay is better then ruben??????....cuz they are friggin retaded.....ruben kills the competion and leaves Clay way behind
  • JOELLE (View Email) on May 1, 2003
    CLAY, CLAY, CLAY.
    CLAY IS THE BEST!
  • JOELLE (View Email) on May 1, 2003
    I LOVE CLAY. HE IS SO ADORABLE. I HOPE HE WINS. WHAT IS SO GOOD ABOUT RUBEN? IF U KNOW PLEASE TELL ME. AND DON'T TELL ME ITS BECAUSE HE IS A GOOD PERFORMER, BECAUSE WHEN IT COMES TO PERFORMING, CLAY IS THE BEST NO IFS, ANDS OR BUTS ABOUT IT. JUST FACE IT CLSY IS GONNA WIN, SO STOP HATING. HE IS CUTE, ALSO. HE IS NOT A TROLL. I WOULD BET A MILLION DOLLARS THAT HE WINS IN THE END.
  • Samantha on May 2, 2003
    Ruban should win Americian Idol because he is such a good singer and he deserves to win. To me Americian Idol is the best show in the world and I never miss a show but it still won't be the best as seeing Ruban up on stage singing.
  • Samantha on May 2, 2003
    IIIII LLLLLOOOOOOOVVVVVVEEEEEE RRRRRRUUUUUUBBBBBAAAAANNNNN!
    He is so going to win. Ruban if you read this you have my vote for Americian Idol.
    Clay: Good but not my favourite.
    Josh: Sweet but still should be kicked off
    Kimberly: She and Ruban should be the last two on Americian Idol but I still hope Ruban wins.
  • Tballs (View Email) on May 2, 2003
    I have two theories on Ruben being in the bottom two this week: 1) Conspiracy Theory - Ruben actually recevied the most votes, but the producers stuck him as second to last in an attempt to boost ratings and voting(ahem -AT&T Wireless is in on it too) Watch the spike in votes next week. 2) America figures Ruben is such a shoe-in that they cast their votes for their next fav. contestants to keep them from being booted, thinking to themselves "well, everyone else is voting for Ruben, I'm not wasting my votes on him, I'm gonna try to keep Kimberly Locke from getting the boot" Ruben however it happened, you didn't deserve to be in the bottom two... On Talent and allure alone you will be the next BIG thing - no pun intended!
  • Tballs (View Email) on May 2, 2003
    Oh - and PS - to Lewis "the Oppressed" - The show is not racist, go find another example to exploit affirmative action. You're stretching there...
  • Terri (View Email) on May 2, 2003
    I can't believe either that Josh is still on.
    The marines are controlling the contest. No one can seriously believe that he deserves to win. Would any of you buy his CD? The top 3 are Clay, Kim, and Reuben. Fans who are as disgraced as I am about Reuben being in the bottom 2 need to VOTE!!!
  • chelsie (View Email) on May 2, 2003
    Ruban you rock I LOVE your singing voice and I LOVE all the dongs you sing because you sound like a professional. And sheila josh is great to and ruban is great to and everyone dont vote josh or ruban off the show!!! go 205!Your a winner
  • crazy 4 american idol (View Email) on May 2, 2003
    sorry sheila i meant korey! dont vote josh off or ruban b/c i luv them both
  • Tonya (View Email) on May 2, 2003
    I was in utter shock when Rub was in the bottom 2, Josh knew he had it coming...
  • angel (View Email) on May 2, 2003
    i dont think it was fair that ruben was in the bottem two!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Kristy (View Email) on May 3, 2003
    I have been a singer for years. And I*m a voice coach by profession. I just recieved my masters in may....so i like to think i know what i*m talking about. Best Voice has to go to Rueben, with Clay very close but still behind. Simon is right. Clay would make a killing on Broadway. That is not an insult. it's a compliment. All the Clay fans need to get over that. Clay has a very annimated face and over exaggerates words when he sings them. Which makes him ideal for the stage. Kimberly has a great voice, but obviously lacks the carisma that Rueben has. Clay is very carismatic...but nobody does it like Rueben. Trenyce has a good voice too but lacks her own stlye. She seems to just sing the songs she picks the same way as the original preformers did it. She reminds me alot of whitney houston. That won is great. But i was once told is 2 people are alike..there is no need for one of them. I think American made a few mistakes in the voting. Like how the hell did josh make it this far?? Honestly he shouldn't even be one this show. He is always off key. People need to get off this marine thing. They last 6 should have looked something like this. 1. Rueben, 2. Clay, 3. Kimberly Locke, 4. Trenyce, and tied for 5 are Kimberly Caldwell and Ricky Smith. (Carmen should have gone b4 rickey, but she got lucky with the roll over votes!) American would have been doing ok with no harm done until this week when they didnt get rid of josh and his tone deaf voice. He keeps talking aobut how he's going country. Well that's great. he should have tried out for Nashville star. He would have no business being on that show though either. This is A.I. the search for a pop star. Rueben is my choice for the winner, becuz he is the best overall package. If this was Broadway star Clay would win all the way. And another thing will everyone stop hating on Simon. He is trying to find the best of the best. To do that u have to be hyper critical. They all can't win. Even the best musicians have areas to tweek. You can't expect him to say they are all grat every week. (Like Paula) I think she is really cute, but she doesn't really offer up much advice. she tells mostly everyone they were great. And if it is really bad and she cant even say that she says somethign about their clothes or somethig....totally cop out! It is ok to offer some criticism. None of these people are perfect.
  • A Mormon Blazer on May 3, 2003
    Why do ya'll bring up Carmen as being a mormon, like it's a big deal. when you say the only people that are voting for carmen are the people in utah and mormons..it's the same thing as saying the only people voting for ruben are fat black people from alabama. but that would be racist, wouldn't it be! it's okay to have an opinion and say she sucks, and personally i am glad shes gone, but dont bring religion into this. and why do you hate mormons anyways!
  • Kathleen (View Email) on May 3, 2003
    Wht is the web site that Ruden is selling 205 shirts? you better tell me the damn website
  • Kathleen (View Email) on May 3, 2003
    Wht is the web site that Ruden is selling 205 shirts? you better tell me the damn website
  • sarah (View Email) on May 3, 2003
    ruuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuueben is the best!
  • chan (View Email) on May 3, 2003
    rueben you will win. even if you are not the american idol you are an idol of god and your career will prosper. there is not a vote nnor any other obstacle that shall come your way and hinder your musical career. god bless you and keep pressing on. i love you!!!
  • freshi on May 3, 2003
    ruben deserves to stay. i have no clue how he got in the bottom two last time. that was bs. and even though trenyce has a great voice, she does look drag-ish with her wig. she should change her hair back to how it was before the top ten thing. too late now, though.
  • Amber (View Email) on May 4, 2003
    Has anyone else heard this rumor..... i've heard on quite a few websites that Josh was so upset after the show, that he left on his own. I heard that a few places but on one of his own fan websites. Just wondering if there was any truth to that.
  • who? on May 6, 2003
    ok, imma say this finnaly!! YOU CANT BUY RUBENS SHIRTS!!! he gets them custom made!!lord!!
  • zara (View Email) on May 6, 2003
    I think clay & ruben are going to be the finalists!
  • kim on May 6, 2003
    What was Ruben's number tonight? Hurry I need to vote.
  • Amie (View Email) on May 7, 2003
    I don't think the person who sed Ruben is FAT isn't very nice. His talent is great, and if someone sais they don't like him because of his size, thats messed up. AND, it's not his "cute little teddy bear face" it's his talent.RUBEN ROCKS!
  • idolfan on May 7, 2003
    To all of you who are bashing Josh...I think Josh has a great voice. Do I think he should have been the one to go last week? Yes. But nonetheless he his still there, and it is not because he is a marine. He has a voice that appeals to a lot of people. On that note...I'm for Clay all the way!! GO CLAY!
  • Katie (View Email) on May 7, 2003
    I LOVE RUBEN!!!!!! He has an amazing and awesome voice!! We all hope he becomes the next American Idol!! He's so sweet and we love him!!!!!! ~Katie~
  • Kim (View Email) on May 7, 2003
    Trenyce and Clay are my favorites
  • Tamea on May 7, 2003
    i would choose kimberly locke because she is the est singer on the show.
  • nikki D loves Ruben!!!!! (View Email) on May 7, 2003
    my whole family and I love roooooben!! Even my 4 year old little cousint loves him.. My 92 year old grandma wants to meet him!We all love him!! My mom and my sister and I always get everyone together to watch ROOOOBEN!! we make sure everyone we know is watching American Idol.. When ruben was in the bottom two i was histerically crying. I knew he would get sent back to safty tho because he is ruben and everyone loves him!I kno he is going to win because he is th best and he deserves it.. Ruben we are voteing for you and i know you will win it!Good luck to clay josh and Kimberly as well... watch out for ruben!! 205!! :)
  • MRS. VELVET TEDDYBEAR (View Email) on May 7, 2003
    RUBEN I KNOW YOU ARE GOING TO WIN I LOVE YOU JUST KEEP THE FAITH.WE LOVE YOU IN THE BAHAMAS
  • ruben lover (View Email) on May 7, 2003
    WHOEVA DOESNT LOVE RUBEN SUCKS!
  • rubens girl (View Email) on May 7, 2003
    YOU GO RUBEN!!!!!!1 YOU ARE THE BETS YOU R GANA WIN!!! 205!!!!!
  • kill clay! on May 7, 2003
    down with clay aiken! he sucks!!!
  • I agree on May 7, 2003
    KRISTY is said it all
  • BOOT_THAT_FOOL on May 7, 2003
    PEOPLE, PEOPLE ITS OKAY YA'LL CAN VOTE OFF JOSH WHO CARES IF HE'S A MARINE IT AINT LIKE HE GAVE HIS LIFE UP FOR US IN IRAQ. HE SINGS HORRIBLE!!!! COME ON NOW JOSH DOESN'T EVEN DESERVE TO BE IN THE TOP 10 LET ALONE THE TOP 3. I REALLY HOPE KIMBERLY LOCKE DOESNT GO BEFORE THIS JOKER!!!! PEACE OUT, THATS ALL I GOTTA SAY.
  • Guess Who Laurel on May 7, 2003
    Yo people. Ruben is too vicious, he should win. Kimberley is mad hot and has a nice, sexy voice. Where you at girl? I'm tryin to get to know you. I'm so glad the last girl left is not anorexic. Oh yeh, and Simon is on point most of the time. Paula is so damn sappy it's annoying. Shut the hell up. She is kinda cute tho, I don't mind the older ladies. Randy just doesn't really know what he's talking about, unless it's canines. Clay's real good somtimes, but not always. Josh is good at country, but nothing else. And did I mention that Kimberley is hot?
  • nicky07 (View Email) on May 7, 2003
    Personally, I love Reuben and Clay. Kimberly can sing but she does have the consistency. I am shocked by how so many people were shocked that Reuben was in the bottom two. I just wanted to know who voted for Josh and who did not vote for Reuben. Well, anyway it doesn't matter because all of the final contestants become famous anyhow. Whoever wins (between Reuben and Clay) congratulations.
  • 05 runs it on May 7, 2003
    yay kimberley!!
  • Marissa (View Email) on May 7, 2003
    I hate Clay he stinks.I think Rubin sould win he is da bomb!
  • Kristy (View Email) on May 8, 2003
    Thanks "I AGREE".....:)
  • 205 on May 8, 2003
    RUBEN IS THE BEST!!!!!
  • Beccan (View Email) on May 8, 2003
    I agree with one of you when you said that you LOVED RUEBEN! BUT WHOEVER SAID THAT CLAY SUCKS HAS NO BRAIN!!! HE IS SEXY AND HE CAN SING DAMN GOOD! (BUT I STILL L*O*V*E RUEBEN! HE IS DANM CUTE!) I WANT A HUG!!! ;o)*
  • Savannah Portis on May 9, 2003
    Ruben is number 1 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 205 Baby!
  • Savannah Portis on May 9, 2003
    I Love you Ruben!!!! Your number 1 fan Savannah Portis. Represent that 205.
  • TORA ALEXANDER (View Email) on May 9, 2003
    RUBEN IS THE MAN....................NO QUESTION ASK.................THANK YOU...........
  • Evelyn Wiant (View Email) on May 9, 2003
    Clay Aiken is my favorite for several reasons. He is a complete package: a beautiful voice that could be paired with someone like Celine Dion. Appealing looks which can be enhanced, humble, warm, knows how to accept criticism, is educated, and he helps those who have been eliminated by giving them a hug. He doesn't have an attitude like Kelly Clarkson who I wouldn't have selected as an American Idol. Good luck Clay!
  • Leslie Brown (View Email) on May 9, 2003
    Ruben is the man with the plan I see Ruben as the new American Idol.Clay is to dramatic he sings well but he needs to calm down.Kimberly is agreat singer also but this is between Ruben and Clay right now.
  • Rissa (View Email) on May 9, 2003
    Clay is the man!!! Sure ruben may have a good voice, but who brings it every week belting out song after song....not Ruben...it is definately my man Clay. The contest is about who is the best singer...not who is the "velvet teddy bear." GO CLAY
  • Maureen (View Email) on May 9, 2003
    OMG Clay is not cute. If he was just some guy that sat next to u in fifth period biology u would never notice him. People are just saying he's hot cuz he's on tv. u can't seriously look at him and tell me u think he's hot. He does have an incredible voice, but he's not hot at all! ALl the little 7th graders that are saying that are gonna grow up and realize what the heck was i thinking!
  • NATEASHA on May 9, 2003
    I LOVE RUBAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!RUBAN IS MY # 1 VOTE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!HE IS THE NEXT AMERICAN IDOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!205 fo sho
  • Lora (View Email) on May 10, 2003
    Reuben is my pick for the american
    idol,if he win he will show america that everyone has a fair chance at achieving their dream no matter what your race is, Clay is good but Reuben has the magic that make people feel he is singing just to them,which tend to make people feel warm all over after listening to hime, clay does not have that magic and never will it something born in you. I have been watching American idol because of Reuben. Good luck Reuben Iam praying for you. You are my idol regardless of how it turn out.
  • Kelly Larrt on May 10, 2003
    I think Ruben is da bomb he is such a great singer I wish i was him.205 all the way now baby!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! If u don't vote for RUBEN i don't know whats wrong with you but all i know is that theres definetilly somthing wrong with you!!!!!
  • alumna3 (View Email) on May 10, 2003
    RUBEN OR KIMBERLY
    i am so glad trashy trenyce is gone!
    i am so glad kimberly locke is gone 2we DO NO need another Britney Spears.
    i was worried that with 2 kimberlys(locke, caldweld, kelsey) the real good one KIMBERLY CALDWELL would not be chosen. but american voted and voted correclty.
    either her or Ruven is who i wan to win
  • Jessie (View Email) on May 10, 2003
    ugghh okay. Really you people (rubin fans) need to get a life. The only reason u make fun of clay is because you know he is giving ruben competetion and you know that he can beat ruben..so for instance you make up corny sayings like "clay is gay" give me a break do you really think thats going to affect peoples decison, because some immature 14 year old thinks hes gay? And also this broadway thing, another excuse. There are a million things i can say about rubin like oh he belongs in a gang or in the ghetto or some dumb thing like that. so lay off on the broadway things or the clay is gay because u really dont make any sense, you just sound like a fool.
  • noneyobizznass on May 11, 2003
    The final 2 should be Rubin and Clay. Then you'd have a fat black guy going up against an anemic white guy.
  • jay (View Email) on May 11, 2003
    i love to watch americain idol i think kimberly is the best i want her to win that show is the best
  • Aj (View Email) on May 11, 2003
    heres what i have to say people. i like ruben clay and kim locke..but ruben just stands there..i mean do u really want ur american idol to be like that?? just wobbles out on stage and stands there..kimberely locke has amazing talent..and im sorry but clays gonna win..and he's incredible maybe not the looks but there better than rubens
  • rrmomcat (View Email) on May 11, 2003
    RU((yaaawwn)) ...ben zzzzzzzzzzzz
  • Shantelle Lewis (View Email) on May 12, 2003
    I think that the winner should either be ruben or clay but i would rather have ruben
  • myob on May 12, 2003
    I hope clay wins, he's hot and awesome @ singing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Toria (View Email) on May 12, 2003
    CARMEN!
    CLAY!
  • albert (View Email) on May 13, 2003
    I would say rubean could win he makes the song his own and not only that ruban is a classic allrounder who can sing any song given to him, clay is a great singer but he is to ordinary doesn't have that all round american idol that an american should have, not enough r&b in him just plain.........if he had r&b taste I will see him win it, if clay wins this is all rigid
  • Joan Hall Hovey (View Email) on May 13, 2003
    My husband and I are big fans of Clay Aiken. He is a powerful and unique talent, a Frank Sinatra for the generation. Rubin is good, but in my opinion, he's not in the same league with Clay. Yet there's lots of media hype and the tide could turn in Rubin's favor if Clay's fans slack off on Voting - so Vote! Vote! Vote! He deserves to be the new American Idol. Cheering him on from Canada.
    www.joanhallhovey.com
  • sara (View Email) on May 13, 2003
    omg...Ruben is gunna win! He's so talented that even if he doesnt win, he'll still be a millionare!
  • kimmy on May 13, 2003
    whoa there now jessie. ruben is spelled R-U-B-E-N, not rubIn. that's just plain racism. ruben is in a gang? or in the ghetto? or is dumb? nice examples of stereotyping. well i see now what you think of black people. if you actually saw oprah interviewing them that day, you would have seen ruben as the more GENUINE of kim locke and clay. clay and kim were trying to sell themselves. clay said some crap like "oh this is a platform to help people..our fans...as a celebrity that is what we should do and american idol helps that." he was completely trying to look good and it totally showed. ruben is the most REAL of all of them. he is the most down to earth and the most talented as all of the judges agree. he is the least conceited and quite obviously the most consistently amazing singer. now who's the fool.
  • JC-512 on May 13, 2003
    JESSIE YOUR THE ONE THAT NEEDS TO GET A LIFE!!! DAMN YOUR POST WUZ SO LAME!!!
  • Andrea ,Tiffany (View Email) on May 13, 2003
    TIFFANY: Go Ruban ANDREA: GO Ruban Wanda:Go Ruban GO RUBAN
  • RACHIE (View Email) on May 13, 2003
    RUBEN,205 IS THE WINNER.IF NOT SOMEONE WAS PAID OFF.CLAY IS GOOD, BUT NO MATCH FOR RUBEN
    AND KIM .WHOS KIMBERLY!
  • marion ryan (View Email) on May 13, 2003
    Clay has an incredible voice. Hard to believe that he continues to shine week after week. I keep trying to vote for him by phone, but never can get through. Any suggestions? Marion
  • Tamyra was wronged on May 13, 2003
    that's right. Tamyra was wronged on the last one because she should have won. i cannot believe she lost to Nikki but i know the only reason she did was because her fans thought that she was safe. Tamyra was just as good as Kelly Clarkson, if not better (many people agree). Kelly just had a fun southern girl personality (kinda like that Bush personality) and that's why people liked her more but Tamyra was the better singer (just as Gore was the hetter candidate and the smarter one). anyways, i think rubin should win, although i don't really especially like any of the contestants now. tamyra is da bomb.
  • Clay (View Email) on May 14, 2003
    It doesn't matter what he sings his voice its so natural. From the beginning he never seems to try he always so cool and can sing anything to become a great singer, on movies shows 0r concerts he will make it.
  • Joan Hall Hovey (View Email) on May 14, 2003
    Clay Aiken is the Frank Sinatra for a new era. He's a powerful and unique talent, and deserves to be the next American Idol.
    Cheering for Clay in New Brunswick, Canada.
    www.joanhallhovey.com
  • Cathy (View Email) on May 14, 2003
    I have studied voice and performed for competition and Clay's voice by far is the most versitile. He sing with clarity, excellant pronunciation and I admire his perserverence. Last night 5/13 when he sung Vincent (a song he would have never chosen for himself) I though he did the best he could. I am tired of the ridiculous cruel statements from Simon. Whether Clay get first or second place and am positive that he will have a recording contract, especially after Neil Sedaka offered to promote and write his first CD!. Go CLay - you are awesome!!!
  • Jean (View Email) on May 14, 2003
    I think Clay clearly has the strongest voice and has come the farthest taking criticism well and improving his image. He definately seems much smoother and at ease. I like Reuben's voice but he seems shaky and scared sometimes and I also like Kim but they always are having her sing songs with too low of a range for her voice. My vote remains as always with Clay.
  • Melissa (View Email) on May 14, 2003
    I think that Ruban should win cause he has an great voice
  • Pam (View Email) on May 14, 2003
    Clearly Reuben should be the winner, He is a crowd pleaser and has an amazing voice and on stage presence. He also has character something needed in an idol. He is a born again Christian. What an impact he could have on our youth. Our youth need someone to look up and admire.
    And to the comment that Al Gore was the better candidate and smarter..are you kidding..? George Bush is the best president we have ever had.
  • Alicia (View Email) on May 14, 2003
    Why do u people always have to make race an issue? It takes the fun out of everything.
  • Corinn (View Email) on May 14, 2003
    Clay is THE best, and he should win. I don't see what's so great about Rubin. All I hear is Rubin Rubin Rubin! What about Clay Clay Clay!?
  • mickey (View Email) on May 14, 2003
    i think ruban should win because he has the best voice and he is hot i think he is such a teddy bear and he is nice he also can sing alot of difrent ways to sing and when he does actually sing he expr4eses his feelings i love you ruban all the way ya!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • tamara (View Email) on May 14, 2003
    I think RUBAN could win because hes the BOMB
  • mary (View Email) on May 14, 2003
    I will agree that Clay has a wonderful voice, but one I believe will not be special enough to last, Ruben not only has a wonderful voice also, but he has something about him that stands out..the name Velvet Teddybear describes him as he is a person one would want to be around and he has more going for him than the voice..I see Ruben going further even if Clay wins..GOOOO ROOOOOOOBEEEEEN
  • jessica (View Email) on May 14, 2003
    RUBEN IS THE BEST...I THINK CLAYS GONNA WIN CUZ EVERY ONE LIKES HIM....BUT RUBEN LOOKS SO SWEET AND LOVE HIS VOICE!!!WEW...GO RUBEN!!!!
  • Jean Johnson (View Email) on May 15, 2003
    I love Ruben and hope that he wins.He is so very talented and has shown this consistantly throughout the contest. He is very mannerly which is something I greatly respect. If he doesn"t win I hope that there is someone out there that reconizes his talent and is willing to give him the chance he needs.I wish the others well and hope that this experience will help them in the fields of the choice.
  • sherry (View Email) on May 15, 2003
    clay and ruben both have great voices. clay is a cutie. i think his voice is more suited for broadway musicals. if america is looking for a great recording star, i think ruben is the "one". his voice makes me feel all warm inside also. i would listen to him on radio,buy his cds and go to see him in concert. my vote goes to ruben.
  • CARYN GRABER (View Email) on May 15, 2003
    Ruben Studdard is the best singer and performer. He has a voice and he can sing. He doesn't have to try, it just flows with him. His appearance is fresh, his clothing is stylish, he is humble and he deserves to win!
  • Brittany Skinner (View Email) on May 15, 2003
    I just wanted to say that Ruben needs to win he is the best singer on T.V. and he knows how to sing so. This is a song for Ruben.
    Big Wheels Keep On Turnig, Primemarys keep on burning,Ruben,Ruben,Ruben's going to win it.
    Ruben i jsut wanted to let you know that everyone in Ranburne Alabama is pulling for you.Good luck to you were all the way behind you. May god bless you!
  • Lindsay (View Email) on May 15, 2003
    Hey Ppl.... Clay should of out went last night now Kimberly... make sure Ruben wins though and I will be happy!!! Peace Out!!!!
  • Clay's Girll on May 15, 2003
    I LOVE CLAY! NO OFFENSE TO ANYONE BUT I HATE RUBEN. I'M SORRY, IT'S MY OPINION. CLAY IS DEFINETLY GOING TO WIN!
  • jayme on May 15, 2003
    i think that ruben will win he is da best he is my teddy bear lol he can sing great he is gunna go all da way!!!


    GOOOO RUBEN!!! U ROCK BABY
  • ruben rulez!!!! on May 15, 2003
    i think that ruben will win he is da best he is my teddy bear lol he can sing great he is gunna go all da way!!!


    GOOOO RUBEN!!! U ROCK BABY
  • Marcella (View Email) on May 15, 2003
    I just knew that Ruben and Clay were going to be the two last people on American Idol because i had this dream that they both went to peoples doors and these were the words they said in my dream "who do you think is going to win?" I said well you are both good and they where giving out certificates to all. but I watch American Idol every week and been with all threw thick and thin and yah I cried and all that but at lease the three I loved and votted for were the last three so it's up to America to do the rest cause I voted for all the same ..... Thanks I love America and you all too.
  • SKY (View Email) on May 15, 2003
    I THINK THAT RUBEN SHOULD WIN. HE IS NOT ONLY HUMBLE BUT HAS CERTAIN KIND OF CHARISMA ABOUT HIM. HE HAS THE VOICE, THOSE CUTE DIMPLES AND THE ATTITUDE OF AN AMERICAN IDOL. I PRAY TO GOD THAT RUBEN WOULD WIN. HE HITS EVERY NOTE PERFECTLY. GO RUBEN ALL THE WAY!
  • Alexia (View Email) on May 16, 2003
    ruben stinks! no RANGE ..sings always the same tone and notes and seriously..whos really going to buy his cd...BORRRRING go clizzay
  • craven morehead (View Email) on May 16, 2003
    first marcella u r an idiot cause ur dream happend after the show and clay is definetly winning hes such a better singer and performer then ruben.ruben is humble because he is fat and cant even sing and is only backed up by bet. clay is the man and hes going to win.
  • Della Pagano (View Email) on May 16, 2003
    I want to start by saying that I am a 44 yr old single mom who has become obsessed with Clay Aiken! My daughters turned me on to the show and now they wish thet hadn't! Every week I freak if they even so much as drop a pin during Clay' performance. I have not seen a style like his since the 70's and 80's with James Taylor and Barry Manilow! Rusben is definately a contender but lets face it...there are alot of singers out there who sound just like him. America is ready for a new style and sound. Rueben doesn't even come close to the range that Clay can sing. Rueben sounds pretty much on the same note all the time, whereas Clay can hit that upper register like nobody's buisness! There is nothing he CAN'T sing.

    I will be extremely disgusted if America doesn't see the obvious.

    Thanks.
  • raz on May 16, 2003
    Rubin sucks and sweats way to much. Please someone get him a towel to wip that away!
  • Kayla on May 17, 2003
    Clay has to win! I mean who is more sensible? All Ruben cares about is signing autographs....Clay helps special kids and is a very caring person! Also Ruben stays at one pitch the whole time and gets boring...I can't stand listening to him. Clay can hit any not and he is so much more cuter that Ruben! It's Clay all the Way!
  • Sam (View Email) on May 17, 2003
    At first I wanted that julie chick to win but now that she is gone I think Ruben is defenatly going to win!
  • kim (View Email) on May 17, 2003
    I think both Clay and Ruben are of equal talent and ability only different styles. I voted for both of them every week until I realized I was just canceling myself out (LOL). I favor Ruben.
  • Sissy D (View Email) on May 17, 2003
    I LOVE RUBAN!!!! He is #1. WV loves Ruban. He is our velvet teddy bear he is the finest brother I've ever seen. {even thuogh i am really young lol} I Love his dimples and his smile. HE SHOULD WIN!!!! RUBAN ALL THE WAY!!!
  • I Love Clay! on May 17, 2003
    No offense to all the people who like Ruben but, I didn't think he did great last week and I think he should've went instead of Kimberly. It's MY opinion. But, Clay is DEFINETLY going to win.
  • Sissy D (View Email) on May 17, 2003
    Jessie you need to get a life and not only that but you practically said clay is gay yourself you said"Give me a break do you think that is going to change peoples decision" So some people might take that in a wrong way {like me} or they will take it in the way you want them to take it and I agree w kimmy 100%

    ps clay looks wierd and RUBAN IS #1

  • Rissa (View Email) on May 17, 2003
    Clay's voice is so much better than Rueben's. I think even the Rueben fans know that Clay rocks the house with his incredible voice!! GO CLAY
  • Shannon Rickus (View Email) on May 18, 2003
    I reckon Clay will take it.He'll win.he has the image, the voice and the skill
  • Jenny Staecker (View Email) on May 18, 2003
    Kimbery Caldwell has good voice and very talented she is better singer .I think she beat ruben
  • Jenny Staecker (View Email) on May 18, 2003
    I think that kimbery caldwell should win she very talented has good voice and charming of atitude of an american idol I pray to god that kimbery would win. she hits go kimbery all the way
  • Amanda (View Email) on May 18, 2003
    I am sorry...Clay CAN sing but He IS gay! I love when they show "Clay's Highschool friend" clapping in the audience. Yea, high school friend? I think Clay is good but Ruben takes it all. He is consistent every week. It will be a good show on Wed.! VOTE 205!!!!
  • linda (View Email) on May 18, 2003
    I hope that Ruben will be the next American Idol, but I believe that it will be Clay. Clay has a nice voice, but Ruben has that overall personality that it takes to be the idol.
  • Lorin (View Email) on May 18, 2003
    I think Clay Aiken should win. He has the best voice. Ruben's voice always sounds the same ad never varies. Clay always sounds differnt or better and he can song really high notes. Clay deserves to win!!!!!

    Thank You
    ~Lorin
  • I LUV CLAY (View Email) on May 18, 2003
    Clay is the best!!! CLAY DESERVES TO WIN. Ruben is a fat freak who sounds constipated!! He just stands there! Clay makes things exciting with his little dance moves in Grease! haha But his bes performance yet was unchained melody! Its made me cry!!! CLAY I LUV YOU!!!!!! and you are gonna win!!
  • Ann Hall (View Email) on May 18, 2003
    Let me put it to you this way, Clay do have a nice voice. But its not for an american idol. He have a theater voice, he can make the money, but not in that kind of entertainment...........Now Ruben have a voice all young people like to hear, only thing is missing is, he need some steps and shake what his momma gave him.
  • H. Todd (View Email) on May 18, 2003
    An American Idol should be whoever has the best talent, looks, showmanship and appeal.
  • canadian eh (View Email) on May 19, 2003
    Ruben is good, but not good enough to compete with Clay. Granted, Ruben has a great voice and what you called "cute dimples" but come on, listen to him, and listen to Clay.....Ruben can only sing "Barry White" notes while Clay can sing any note (high or low). Ruben can only keep a high note for a second. Sorry Ruben fans, but thats the truth. Have you ever heard Ruben hold a high note for a very loooong time? No! CLAY SHOULD WIN. Plus, judges are being nice to Ruben cuz they dont want to be called prejudice. Remember Simon said to Vanessa, Josh and Kimberly that they need to shed some pounds?, He never said that to Ruben cuz he's scared of the backlash.
  • christy (View Email) on May 19, 2003
    No Doubt about it....Reuben should definately win this competition. Well, he's already a winner. He has a wonderful personality and not to mention a rich, beautiful voice. A Luther Vandross voice. As Paul Abdul said, Baby making music.!! He's a cutie no doubt. I will be very disapointed if Clay wins this compitition. Clays not bad but he doesn't sing my style of music. He's kinda annoying. Something about him just annoys me. I have to agree with Simon. I prefer him with my eyes closed!!!!
  • christy (View Email) on May 19, 2003
    No Doubt about it....Reuben should definately win this competition. Well, he's already a winner. He has a wonderful personality and not to mention a rich, beautiful voice. A Luther Vandross voice. As Paul Abdul said, Baby making music.!! He's a cutie no doubt. I will be very disapointed if Clay wins this compitition. Clays not bad but he doesn't sing my style of music. He's kinda annoying. Something about him just annoys me. I have to agree with Simon. I prefer him with my eyes closed!!!! 205 all the way!!!!!
  • andrea Gibbons (View Email) on May 19, 2003
    paula
    you are so pretty but can you tell simon to go to the doctors and get some chill pills.
    i think you have a hard to pick the winner .
    from yuor biggest fan andrea Gibbons
    p.s write back to me please
  • anonymous on May 19, 2003
    Clay should definitely win. Ruben sings in one boring tone every week and passes it off as a good performance. Vote for Clay.
  • shea (View Email) on May 19, 2003
    I think that Clay, Kimberly, and Ruben are
    wonderful. I do like Clay better out of the three,but do remember people... These three have given us such a great time to watch on TV and what are we gonna do when this is over? Will there be a American Idol #3??????
  • essence gordon (View Email) on May 19, 2003
    hi im 14 years old and other people cant help that their fat and i dont think hes fat i think hes big bone and the news said that all of you said tht he might not be able to make it because he is fat ruben is a nice looking man that cant make something of his life and he has chosen to sing and if he made it this far i think he can do anything if he work hard and put his mind to it, and thats very sad that you jugde whats on the outside in stead of the inside i think on the in side is a very good men with a sensative heart and needs to be jugd on his perfromce instead of his looks and his weight and i think if randy can sit down on a chair and talk about people ruben can sang and do anything he wont and you should not jugde a book by its cover
  • Darien Sciallo (View Email) on May 19, 2003

    Ruban is the best...
    hes my big teady bear...
    i love his voice...
    and hes going to win.. i wtach this show eveyr night...
    im the biggest fan me n my family... my family wants clay but i want ruban to win.. caus he has the best voice by far ... and even if he doenst win i still hope he gets a musical career caus im gonna buy all his cd*s when he gets big... so ruban u got teady bear... caus ur going to win....
    I LOVE YOU... YOUR BIGGEST FAN.
    DARIEN MICHELE SCIALLO..
    p.s
    RUBAN is gonna be the next TRUMAN...
  • Amanda (View Email) on May 19, 2003
    I so think Clay should win he has improved the most throughout teh whole cometition and he's also the cutest. Paula you are so sweet it's so nice to have soemone with a positive additude on the show to watch. Simon is so funny i laughall the time when i hear him criticize people. I mean sometimes he can get a little carried away, but at least he's sharing is true thoughts. Go Clay
  • Dizturbed_05 (View Email) on May 19, 2003
    RUUUUUUUUBEN! He's got great dimples, a great personality, and i give him credit for getting up in front of America and doin' his thing. He definatly deserve to be THE "American Idol." I have a good voice but i'd be afraid to do anything cause im bigger and wouldnt have the guts! YOUR AWESOME RUBEN YOU DESERVE IT ALL THE WAY NOW GET UP THERE AND SHAKE THAT STUFF BABY!
  • June Dabney-Gray (View Email) on May 19, 2003
    I believe that Rubin should win. He out sings Clyde Aikens without a doubt. It is also time to let someone of another race become an American Idol. People overseas must think that the only people here in America that count are of the White race.
    Also, everyone shouldn't have to be stream-line in order to be an American Idol. It's encouraging to others to see someone win other than a tiny petite person all of the time, with blond and blue eyes.
  • tara (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    I think the big teddy bear should win... because he is the best Clay just can't sing as well as Ruban .....
  • Cindy (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    Ruben is my Fav! I just hope he wins this wednesday. I think he is so deserving and humble. And let's not for get that "melt me like butter voice"!
  • Kyle Redekopp (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    First off, I hate that fat lard Ruben, he can't sing and has no interesting personality.
    Secondly, I think Simon is the hottest, sexiest guy in the universe! WOOF WOOF.
    (tell Paula to start eating, she needs some meat.)
    Randy is a babe!
    I'm gay if you haven't noticed, but that's okay, cause that's what makes the world go round.
    Clay rules!
  • jawanna man Brown (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    I'm back, with my gay lover. Pie? did someone say Pie? anyways Ruben sucks, you suck, everybody sucks.luv ya ppl!!

  • ddrskforclay (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    Clay is an extraordinary singer! My vote is for CLAY. GO CLAY!!
  • Sylvia Haddock (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    I love Clay and think he is so talented.
  • Carla Patterson (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    I have been reading several comments regarding AI, and there favorite picks. Both Ruben and it's (spelled RUBEN not RUBIN) and Clay are talented men, you cannot take that away from either, and America seems to embrace both in there own special way. But it seems Clay's fans has to put Ruben down to boost Clay, and Rubens fans always say Clay can sing he is just not there pick.
    In my opinion Clay can sing, but so can Ruben. so why do you people and you know who you are, always have to down play everything.
    Why can't you just accept the fact a Big Black man with a Power house voice, and a wonderful personality, just might be the
    next AMERICAN IDOL.

    RUBEN STUDDARD ALL THE WAY.
  • matt (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    im a very good singer and i think clay sucks.ruban should win
  • Ashley (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    Ruben should win. he is sooo cute and has a great voice clay is too broad way and me and my family think ruben should win. The velvet teddy bear or the broad way star u chose is u chose the right one ruben should win
    205

  • Roxann Cokely (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    LET'S GO RRRRUUUUBBBBEEEENNNN!!! GOOD LUCK FROM EMPORIUM,PENNSYLVANIA. I WILL BE WATCHING YOU AND CHEERING YOU ON!!! 205
  • Sabrina (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    HEY EVERYONE.I THINK CLAY IS GOING TO WIN.BUT,WHO EVER WINS..THE OTHER ONE WILL GET A RECORDING CONTRACT NO MATTER WHAT.SO BASICALLY THEY BOTH WIN.BUT ONE CAN ONLY ONE CAN BE CALLED AMERICAN IDOL..SO GO CLAY GO...CLAY ALL THE WAY......

    Sabrina
  • Jo Callahan (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    I think Clay should win because he's the only one who has talent
  • madeline (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    clay should win because my friend emma bubels brother was mentally challenged and clay tought her brother he did a very good deed and also was very nice he also has a wonderful voice clay is my favoite!he is truley #1 you rock clay!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • BJ alexander (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    I think Rueben should win hes the best performer and who could listen to clay all day I mean he's good but not that good
  • Sarah (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    I think that Clay should win and will win this compitition. He is very cute and he has a kick ass voice. He IS the American Idol.:)
  • Amanda (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    CLAY GOT THIS PEOPLE! HE TORE IT UP!!!!!!!!!! ADMIT IT!!!!!
  • Anna (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    OMG! I so think that reuben is the winner!I mean Clay isn't bad but he is way worse than Reuben! Reuben has the right pitch and every thing! He is the Winner and has been the winner since he was ever on american idol! VOTE FOR REUBEN! We love ya Reuben!
  • Donna Hardeman (View Email) on May 20, 2003


    This season of American Idol was the best group of talent I have seen and heard in a long time. To the judges you all are great and I make sure my schedule is clear so that I can watch... Paula, Randy and Simon I look forward to seeing you all next season. Take care and god bless you all...

    Donna Hardeman
    Alexandria, VA
  • jess (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    i vote ruben
  • Ann (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    I think Clay should win. He sings different every time. I can understand him. He has a beautiful voice. I would buy his tape any time.
  • shelly/melina (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    how could you peps say that clay is gay dog thats just wack aney way i happen to be a close friend of his he is not gay i will tell ya that aney go clay you are such a good person and singer and ruben you are also amazing but i have to stay loyal to my b/f loue all yall and GOD BLESS
  • Aleshia Bumgardner (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    Clay and Ruban are both truely great
    Pouring their hearts out, while America decides their fate.

    Who will win and come out on top?
    Who will bare the title American Idol, or who will simply flop?

    As we make our final decission, lets all keep in mind, we owe Clay and Ruban thanks for showing us a great time!

    No matter who wins this contest...
    They are both 2 favorites of mine!!!!

    Good Luck Fellows!!!!!!!!
  • Kayla (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    Ruben is the best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! he is like a big teddy bear!!!!!!!!!!!!! Ruben should win!!!!!!!1 ruben, ruben, ruben, ruben, ruben, ruben, ruben, ruben,ruben, ruben, ruben, ruben, ruben, ruben, ruben, ruben, ruben, ruben, ruben, ruben, ruben, ruben, ruben, ruben, ruben, ruben,
  • Big Ruben's Fan! (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    Americain idol its a very good program...when we look at this program we are just tinking about something like WE CAN BE WHAT WE WANT TO BE! and i dont want to clay win this competition because i dont like him!! GO RUBEN!
  • Ruben (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    I think he has a nice voice, and he has a great personnality
  • katrina (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    reuben is my luther and i wish him all the luck in the world. he is my winner no matter what. so my vote is for reuben. may GOD always shine upon you and continue to be with you.
  • Dominique (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    I think that clay is good but RUBEN is #1
  • lynda (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    Ithink Reuben should win because he has a great voice and think he better than Clay and like everyone say he is a big teddy bear good lucky Reuben.
  • ricky (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    well i think that ruben should win. If Clay wins this will be the down fall of pop music. Hes got talent but Ruben is much better he shoudl win!
  • Dara (View Email) on May 20, 2003
    I want RUUUU-Ben to WIN!
    go Ruben! I love you!
  • sissy (View Email) on May 20, 2003

    ITS RUBEN

    he is so cute and i love the way he sings, it just takes my breath away.. i feel he should be the next american idol..

    he is just like a big teddy bear
  • aja (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    I LOVE RUBIN
    I WANT HIM 2 WIN
  • SARAH (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    CLAY IS THE BEST! I HOPE HE IS THE NEXT AMERICAN IDOL!:)
  • jim (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    Rubin will win on his looks but clay is the only one who has a voice that will sell CDs Poor Rubb is stuck with church singing
  • Jessie (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    Clay has a great voice, but i think he'd be better in broadway, like rent.

    Rueben is soo adorable. I just wanna hug him! Go ruben! He should win :D
  • CAM (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    Although yesterday was a pivotal time for both Rubin and Clay. I believe American was Clay. He has a very versatile voice and he has always been consistent, but Rubin gives him a good run. I am on Rubin's side. I would be kinda shocked if Rubin wins, but I that he will get a lot of attention after this Americal Idol competition. I only voted for Clay in the very beginning of the show, as the show went on I never voted for him again, only Rubin, and Kimberly Locke.
    I wish Rubin and Clay God's blessing, but I know only one can win. Let's go RUUUUUBIN.
  • Nakeya (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    I think Rub should win because he is one of the American blacks that we are dapending on to take this all the way to show that we have a chance in this world,you know like we have lots of talents but people dont notice because we are black. Other people think we cant nake it in the world. LOve

    Nakeya mcintyre you fan.

  • terry gallahar (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    CLAY !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • shaz (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    Ruben sings like an angel!! Clay has a good voice but creeps me out - he looks like he's made of wax (or perhaps, clay??)
  • brit (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    NO DOUBT CLAY SHOULD WIN!!!!!!!!!!!!1 HE HAS THE BEST VOICE BEST RANGE EVERYTHING THE COMPLETE PACKAGE!!!!!!!!!
  • llama (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    CLAY IS GAY!!!!!RUBEN ROCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! llama1

    Ruben totally stinks and CLAY is gonna win!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! llama2

    So what, CLAY Is SOOOOOOOOOOOO GAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11 HE STINKS, HE IS A BRODWAY STAR!!!! not an american Idol!!!! IF CLAY WINS, NO ONE WILL BUY HIS ALBUM
    !!!!!! BUT.....CLAY WILL LOOSE!!!!!! LLAMA1

    I so can not agree that Ruben is gonna win
    i'm telling you Clay is gonna win and i made a bet on this {so i better win!} i always thought that he was going to win and tonight he WILL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! llama2


  • Lisa (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    Simon you r the bomb! Don't listen to anyone that says u aren't and Ruben is the best he should win this compitition because he can sing better than Clay and he doesn't do those expressions!!
  • dude (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    CLAY SUCKS CRAP!!!!!!!!
  • Bj Alexander (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    Reuben is the best and should win american idol I could not and absolutely would not listen to a whole album of clay and the only way i would vote for him is if i was a ditz. Reuben is the best YOU ALL KNOW CLAY CAN'T SING HIS WAY OUT OF A PAPER BAG. Rueben is humble and has a great voice and if another honkey who cant sing wins I will absolutely have a fit.The show would have to be rigged for clay to win.
  • Rochelle (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    Clay is an excellent singer, he sing from the heart, But Rueben sings from the depths of his soul. I wish there could be 2 american idols. Since that isn't possible I must cast my vote for Rueben for he is the man...........
  • Kelly (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    First of all, Ruben and Clay are both very good singers BUT Clay belongs on Broadway. Ruben is an 'American Idol' with his personality and outstanding voice. Rueben Studdard deserves to be the next American Idol by far.
    RUUUUUUUUUUUUBEN..........I've been with you since the beginning!
  • caitlyn (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    I never have been an avid American Idol fan, but man, does America know how to choose a winner! The original idol, Kelly Clarkson, has so much talent...they couldn't have chosen someone better. I tried to watch American Idol this season, but my schedule is so busy I just haven't had the time. So, my choice is based on what I've seen in one show. I think that Clay deserves to win this competition. At first, I leaned in the direction of Ruben, but then I watched them perform. Both of them have great voices, but Ruben's voice is so plain, or as my friend calls voices like that, plain jane. I mean, it's good, but it sounds like all of the other voices out there. Clay puts his heart an soul into the music, and his voice really stands out among a lot of male performers today. He's been ridiculed by Simon, time and time again, but he's held strong. So, there you go. My American Idol choice, Clay Aiken.
  • J (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    RUBAN IS THE TRUE IDOL!!!!
  • Bootybia on May 21, 2003
    WHo knos rubens voting number? please tell me and vote for him!!
  • T.Edmonds (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    Winner Go!!, Go!! Ruben.

    Clay you are great.

    to american idol I am dissappointed. I have cast my vote every week, but last night I tried to vote from 8:00 pm cst to after midnight and could not get through. Why weren't there more line for 1 866 46357 01.
  • presious (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    first of all clay has a opera voice,he s a nerd trying to be cool wuth his gay moves be your self, ya you can pretend to be someone your not and you ll make it but it will only be five minutes of fame and then times up. if you look at ruben he may not have a better voice than clay but he s real and not pretending to be cool he just is, i would not buy clays album if he wins but i would but rubens because he s real has rythm and style.clays going to win but it wont last.GO RUBEN
  • Lella on May 21, 2003
    yo
    I've seen all these comments that say ruben sucks and it make me cry! I mean seriously! Sure, Clay may have a nice voice but he doesn't give it his all like Ruben does. Clay closes his eyes and sits down. Ruben stands up and claps and walks around on the stage and really gives it his all. Im really sorry if You like Clay and want him to be the next american idol U suck! You rule to all those velvet teddy beard lovers.... Ruben I LOVE YOU!
  • Christina (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    This is directed to Rubin and the judges well im a little young im only 12 but im Rubins biggest fan. i ownt shut up about him at school i have a t shirt with him all over it and all over my school books are the words I LUV RUBIN HES MY VELVETY TEDDY BEAR!!!! mY ONE DREAM IS TO SEE rUBIN HES MY ROLE MODEL AND HES SOOO CUTE.if he doesnt win im going to cry no doubt about it! I also luv Paula Randy and ya i luv u too Simon i think simon tells the truth but he is a little harsh i would still give u a big hug if u hated me. My one dream is to meet Rubin, Ryan(ur hott!!!i started a fan club) Paula, Randy, and Simon. I havent missed one show ask anyone all im aksing is one minute with him i luv u sooo much rubin i am positive im ur biggest fan i wear a tshirt of u everyday, even to school.. everyone thinks im crazy but i dont care cause i luv u soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo much u would never know i would luv to meet u all and if i dont get a reply i will honestly cry
  • Linda (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    I think that Clay Akin is the most awsome singer. It's rare when a singer can give me goose bumps and Clay does it everytine he pumps out a song. His voive is great and he deserves to be THE IDOL!!!
  • Vanessa (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    I've been watching americain idol ever since the first show with Kelly Clarkson being the americain idol. I was wishing that Kimberly Locke and Ruben Studdard would have been the bottom two and not Clay. I was very very dissapointed when Julia DeMato had left. She was my idol. (and Rubben). My favorite song has to be GOD BLESS THE USA!!. But cuz ruben and clay are bottom two... go RUUUUUUUUBEN!! #1 BABY!!
  • CHYENNE on May 21, 2003
    TO:LEEE@YAHOO.COM
    FIRST OF ALL I WOULD BUY RUBEN'S CD,CLAY IS ALRIGHT BUT HE IS'NT AS GOOD AS RUBEN.SO STOP HATING!
  • vanessa (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    I vote for clay #4365702 but i forgot the phone number so please consider my vote
  • SARIAH on May 21, 2003
    TO:JESSIE01AE@AOL.COM
    YOU TALK ABOUT OTHER PEOPLE BEING IMMATURE,BUT YOU KNOW YOU MEANT THE COMMENT ABOUT RUBEN BEING IN A GANG,AND THAT HE IS GHETTO.YOU MADE YOUR SELF LOOK STUPID BY WRITING THE THINGS YOU COULD SAY,WHEN ACTUALLY YOU REALLY MEANT THEM.SO WHO LOOKS LIKE A FOOL.I THINK YOU CAN ANSWER THAT.
  • jaziliza (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    if ruban doesn't win you're crazy not that clays bad
  • Kevin (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    Reuben, Reuben, and again Reuben!!!!!
    I'm sorry but I will put all my money on Reuben cause his voice is what we have been missing for years. Everytime you ask a celebrity where some of their best inspiration comes from they are going to say some old time singer with a beautiful voice. I feel Reuben is a modern day icon that will capture all audiences. Clay on the other hand has a nice voice but will not capture the audience that American Idol is looking for. He always have broadway to fall back to. As for Reuben, HURRY UP AND PUT OUT THE CD CAUSE I HAVE MADE A SPOT BETWEEN LUTHER VANDROSS AND BRIAN MCNIGHT TO PUT AND I AM LOOKING FORWARD TO YEARS AND YEARS OF YOUR MATERIAL. You have put 205 on the map. I would like some feedback on this comment. p.s. no matter what anybody else think you are the best in this competition hands down. thanks
  • Barbara Emigh (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    A fan from Blytheville,Arkansas is putting her vote for American idol winner--Clay Aiken! His performance last night was his best ever and I think American will tell him tonite--Here is American idol winner! CLAY
    He can sing any song that makes an girl want
    to be an fan of CLAY AIKEN and buy his first
    CD release!!!!!
    I LUV CLAY AIKEN!!!! Thank you from Arkansas!
  • i love ruben (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    I LOVE YOU RUBEN YOU CAN WIN AND IF YOU DONT YOU WILL STILL BE MY IDOL!!!!!!!!!!! GO RUBEN

    AND FOR PAULA I THINK YOU ARE THE BOMB!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Clay all the way! (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    I think Clay should win. They are both very talanted singers and will both have a great future in the music industry but Clays voice is sooo strong and amazing!! GO CLAY!
  • aly (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    clay your all that
    ur rock!!!!!
  • JEWELZ (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    Gooooooooooooooo Ruben Goooooooooooooooooo!
    I love you too bad your too young for me, hehehe!
    I know for sure you will make any woman very happy some day.
    for your a great son and if your a great son, you'll be a great hubby ad a great father. (O: and above all an awsme singer.. you can sing to me anytime.
    Love You Babe!!!! Go Go Ruben

    Clay go Clay Go
    Your both awsome singers diffrent voices and yet so unique i wish you both the best!
    God BLess and may the best man have his dream come reality.
  • pookey (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    Clay has a beautiful voice and i think he is going to win. I really hopes HE DO!!!!
  • melissa sullivan (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    simon you rock i am glad that there is a judge on that pannel that is able to say the truth to theese people. there was deffinetly a great amount of people that auditioned that i totally agread with you. i like that you do not hold back. i just think that all the judges should be like simon because if they were we might not have ended up with kelly clarkson
  • pookey (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    Clay has a beautiful voice and I think he is going to win. I really hopes HE LOSE!!!!
    Reben is sure to get a record deal any way.
  • Angie (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    CLAY all the WAY
  • Ruben is da best (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    OMG all u ppl that think clay is going to win have serious issues. Ruben is da best! Clay isn't! Ruben is going to win because he sings better that clay and Ruben doesn't do those freaky expressions Clay does!
  • GO RUBEN! (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    GO Ruben I think your awesome and you have this. Clay no hard feelings but my name for you is Gay Clay. Sorry but your just not fit to be the next American Idol now Ruben is and he knows how to sing. Clay you know how to sing but just lets not go there. So anyway GO RUBEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    GOOD LUCK RUBEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Jessica-Lynn (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    Clay should win... Yum. =)
  • Emily (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    GO RUBEN YOU SO HAVE THIS SORRY CLAY!!!!!!!!!
  • nina vlahaki (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    dear Americain Idol, Hi it is me nina vlahaki
    I want to tell you that i reallly like your showes that were on Television they were really great and all my friends really liked them to But this is want i wantto tell you all of my friends choose ruuuuben to be a winner of te americain Idol finalls .I want to also tell all of the other Americain idol singers that theywere really great .I want to WISH EVERY ONE GOOD LUCK FOR THE FINALLS.
    SINCERLY ,
    nina Vlahaki
  • cocoa (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    whats ^ all i want to say is that i hapoe ruben wins and that hes is like a pooh bear.He can sing and so can alkien but right now i have to go with pooh bear.

    cocoa,

    halla
  • colletta on May 21, 2003
    i love your show, i think that simon is so handsom &clay should win.
  • Annie Cordova (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    I love your singing Rubin! You diserve to win!! If you didnt you wouldnt have gotten this far !!!! YOU GO!!!
  • Bobbi (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    I think Clay all the way!! he is definatly the winner. So...... GO CLAY!!! LUV YA!!!

    and Paula you are soooooo pretty!

    write back.
  • sonia (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    hey i would like ot vote for clay atkins
  • Ashley on May 21, 2003
    I AM SO GLAD REUBEN WON!!!!!!!!!! I really like both Clay and Reuben so if Clay would have won i would have been so happy too! They are both awesome and I am buying both there CDS! Clay is funny and Reuben is SO COOL! 205!!!!!!!!!
  • Tara Edminsten (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    Joshua Gracin is my favorite. Is josh going to be in the american idol concert coming?
  • sissy (View Email) on May 21, 2003

    WAY TO GO RUBAN!!

    so happy that u made it,, good luck and best wishes to you,, don't forget your fans.. *S*.. we love u ruben..

    sissy from New jersey
  • jillian (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    RUBEN ALL THE WAY...... 205 HOLLA
  • Christie (View Email) on May 21, 2003
    Yey Rueben!!
  • A Fan on May 21, 2003
    ruben will win
  • april (View Email) on May 22, 2003
    i think reuben should definetely win because he sings from his heart and he knows what hes doing. he stands tall and competes with what he believes in. he is so comfortable on stage!
  • Rubens da bomb (View Email) on May 22, 2003
    LOOK IF YOU GUYS CANT READ OR YOUR JUST THICK AND DUM I THINK RUBEN SHOULD WIN. FIRSTLY I THINK HE HAS THE GREATEST VOICE IN THE WORLD!!! SECONDLY HE IS MY VELVET TEDDY AND IF YOU DONT VOTE FOR HIM YOU SHOULD SPEND THOUSANDS ON RUBEN THERAPY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • DragonStab on May 22, 2003
    Your picture in this article says "The final 8".

    But there are 9 contestants in the picture !!!!!
  • Zack (View Email) on May 22, 2003
    This show is the raping of creative music. Anyone, (as this show proves) can get up on stage and sing cover tunes. Everyone just watches to see that over inflated ego guy cut on everyone. I am not the smartest man in America, but even I can see that the show has no origanility, class, excitement, or creativeness to it. Just sucking on the tit of reality shows. Grow up people and patron real artists, you know the kind that struggle to make art!
  • Tiyah (View Email) on May 22, 2003
    Rueben is my big sexy teddybear!!! His voice makes me shiver and his looks make me quiver.
    I have one question for him...........
    WILL YOU MARRY ME????????????????
    Love the one and Only Le'Tiyah Shaw

    P.s. My Comment is that Rueben deserves to be the american idol, Clay can't and won't beat him. Rueben will always be my american idol no matter what!!!!!!

  • Sarah on May 22, 2003
    Ruben will win. It goes to show that you do not have to be tall and skinny to be on Americain Idol.If you don't like Ruben
    because hes black you're racest. i'm just 8
    years old.I sure know something..
    Rubens got my vote!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!




    P.S Clakin is ok
  • Simone Zulu (View Email) on May 22, 2003
    It would be nice to see duets. It's hard for two people to be good every time.
  • Simone (View Email) on May 22, 2003
    What happened to Josh on the last show. I wanted to see him with the others.
  • Deena (View Email) on May 22, 2003
    Clay deserverd that title!!! i love clay!! hes like my all-time favourtie and i wish that he won it but you know oh well cuz hes got a record deal and im happy cuz im seriously his #1 fan forever!!
  • Ruben Won!!! (View Email) on May 22, 2003
    America choose the best singer this season! Ruben Studdard continuously gave GOD the praise and glory every week and he was richly blessed for it. Both men sing really well but even Simon said that clay sounded the same on every song. He should have been voted of last week instead of Kim because he clearly forgot the words to the song he was performing. He does have the range but sometimes he has a pitch problem. So no matter how long he holds the note it does no good if it is out of tune. I am a singer and I know. It is better not to try them then to try them and mess up. Ruben,Kimberly,and Clay will all be famous but I think Ruben and Kim will stand above the rest. Congradulations Ruben you deserve it. They tried to vote you off but GODS will shall be done. Can't wait to buy your CDs!!
  • charmaine (View Email) on May 22, 2003
    I think american idol now i think CLAY IS GAY THESE WORDS RYME! anyway rubin or ruben whatever im one of your fans i wanna be in american juniors i started singing in crowds when i was 5 im continuing im 8 now=)
  • chris (View Email) on May 22, 2003
    who won
  • Rachel (View Email) on May 23, 2003
    OH MY GOD!!!!! I love Ruban!!!!!!!!!!!!! All though I thought that Clay was going to win, When Ryan said Ruban your our new american Idol! Me and my friends were screaming soooooooooooooo loud! I LOVE YOU RUBAN!!!
  • Moira (View Email) on May 23, 2003
    I think Ruban is gonna win!!
  • Kristen Martin on May 23, 2003
    hi everyone should know that Rubin rules and he deserved to win American Idol. hopefully the people that liked Clay know that Rubin is better than Clay and everyone else out there (no including Kelly Clarkson)
  • pk (View Email) on May 23, 2003
    Oh My Gosh! I LOVE RUUUUBEN! What a cutie and i don't think a single person on that stage is more deserving them him. He lights up the stage and his voice is infectious. I will definetly be looking for his new album and can't wait till he smokes Clay on the charts! Although I know they are friends I think Ruben is the TRUE IDOL!

    A Loving Fan!
  • Dina (View Email) on May 23, 2003
    regardless of the fact that Ruben won, I still love Clay!! He's still the TRUE american idol hands down. Ruben's ok, actually, but I find him so boring. like c'mon there are so many rnb singers out there who can sing as well him or better. but clay is unique.. a breath of fresh air who has a good taste in music. I'd laugh so hard if Clay's singles and albums outsellf Kelly, Justin Guarinni (that dude cannot sing) and Ruben. I'd laugh so hard, I ain't joking.
  • ~**~ on May 23, 2003
    YOUR AWESOME RUBEN!!! I LOVE YA U LITTLE TEDDY BEAR!!! XOXO GOOD LUCK !!
  • Patricia Brem (View Email) on May 23, 2003
    I believe American Idol has been a really refreshing show. Sick of sitcoms, ER, detective shows, etc. I love music shows and watching youg teen/adults progress in the last six months to be self-confident and well controlled as being satisfying to watch. Even my 15 month old grandbaby loves the show. I hope they keep it on for years to come and that many of the upper 10 finalists, especially the last 3 get work because they are all so great. Also, I thought that the 2003 contestants were much more talented. It was fun seeing the tape of what Clay Aikens and Rubin Studdard looked like when they just started out; I even liked Simon this season!!I rate this show AAA!
  • Patricia Brem (View Email) on May 23, 2003
    Rubin, Rubin, Rubin, I love your voice. Best of luck to you man. I love your dimples. You are a beautiful Christian. Don't let all the money change you. Stay true to God and always thank him for this opportunity of success. He gave you that voice, use it well. Bless You!!

    Clay, you gave your all also. It was very tight. I believe whatever you do, you will be successful.
  • carol pollitt (View Email) on May 24, 2003
    I love Ruban, he is awsome. I watched the show from day one and Simon was right when he said the show would be nothing with out Ruban, I said that to my husband the night before Simon said it. I loved the show so much, I am truley going to miss it. I will be there to buy Ruban and Clay's CD . Thanks Carol from Ontario
  • Lisa on May 24, 2003
    It was fixed. 4 of 5 people I know that wanted to vote for Clay couldn't. The phone lines were busy. Everyone that wanted to vote for Ruben could. I could care less who won but it should have been fair.
  • Amanda (View Email) on May 24, 2003
    I am so glad that Ruben won. I belived that he was the best from the very first time I heard him sing. He is the best singer that was on the show, and that's why he won. GO RUBEN, YOU'RE AWESOME!!!
  • I Love Clay on May 26, 2003
    I HATE Ruben! I'm not buying his stupid album! I'm buying Clay's! Who would you rather have as your American Idol, a fat idiot that sounds the same every SINGLE week or a guy that can actually sing and he helps children in special needs. I don't know about you but I would choose Clay! FYI It's MY opinion!
  • dustin lamoureux (View Email) on May 27, 2003
    it was great but i am better email me for the next american idol audtions
  • Courtney (View Email) on May 27, 2003
    CLAY IS THE BEST I LOVE CLAY. CLAY ALL THE WAY. CLAY IS MU SWEETHEART. MARRY ME CLAY. EVEN THOUGH RUBEN WON YOU ARE REALLY THE AMERICAN IDOL AND YOU WERE MUCH BETTER THAN RUBEN
  • BOB (View Email) on May 30, 2003
    I LOVED TRENYCE I HOPE SHE GET A DEAL IF ANYONE FINDS OUT THAT SHE GET ONE LET ME KNOW
  • Lynzi (View Email) on June 11, 2003
    Hey yall~! Ruben totally deserved to win! There was not a mess up w/ tha votes! Ruben, keep strong and remember to have faith in God

    Love ya boi~!
  • Y DU PPL LIKE CLAY SO MUCH? (View Email) on June 16, 2003
    Wuts up w/clay?Of course he can be a wonderful singer but his voice is so fake. He's just another one of those pop singers hu change they're singing style to make the song sound good. it duznt work! Maybe there was sum phone line probs but Rubin wud've won anyways and I'm glad he did. He's a tru singer dat sings out of his heart. Dont buy clay's cd, buy Rubin's or Kimberly's. By the way, Kimberly's also an awesome singer she and rubin should've been left first. Maybe there was phoneline problems for all the contestants except clay and maybe that's why he got so far. Sorry to be critic, just bein honest,
  • Brenna (View Email) on June 16, 2003
    Clay was the best by far. Ruben was great too but I wish so bad that Clay would've won. I am his number 1 fan and no one should be dissing my Clay! :P Clay is number 1 no matter what anyone says!
  • leesa on June 17, 2003
    I loved American idol. I am currently a high school teacher, and my students got me into the show. My comment comes as a response to the indiviual who called Rueban names, like " idiot" and ect. Ok big stuff, do you have the nerve to get in front of a large television audience every week, and perform your heart out! I applaud every contestant. Clay and Rueban are both excellent singers,and I am happy for Rueban! (from a writer with " common sense!")
  • tara molnau (View Email) on June 17, 2003
    u r so cute clay u should of won u r the worlds best singer come to minnesota for a concert and pull me up on stage and give me a kiss on the lips i will be wearing all orange but my shoes i am the biggest fan in the world ruban is great but u r the best in the world but god is most best
  • WANDA (View Email) on June 19, 2003
    I AM SO HAPPY REBEN WON. I REALLY THINK HE DESERVED TO WIN EVERY WEEK HE WOULD GET ON STAGE AND SING HIS HEART OUT.WAY TO GO REB I AM VERY HAPPY FOR YOU KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK.
  • George Herring (View Email) on June 21, 2003
    Ruben represents all people. Why don't you allow him to be the American Idol and quit allowing Clay's exposure as the American Idol. In the past their was only one American Idol just like we voted to have one president. The people chose and voted for the American Idol, So let's respect and enjoy him(Ruben)and his music.

    George Herring
  • Courtney (View Email) on June 22, 2003
    6/22/03
    I feel that a big mistake was made in who should have won. Clay Aiken has a beautiful voice that sent chills unlike anyonelse who competed on the show.
    Reuben was no comparison to the various in Clay's vocal abilities. I feel Clay could very easily sing vocals for children's movies such as was in Aladdin. He may not be a rock, country, or Jazz singer. Give him a chance Simon Cowell this guy could make a record company alot of money if looked at in the right light. Wake up!
  • Reality (View Email) on June 22, 2003
    Okay everyone, American Idol is OVER. Why on earth are you still fighting about it? Ruben won. Was he MY PERSONAL first choice? No, but I'm not complaining about it anymore. Listen, for all you Clay fans, his single is beating Ruben's on amazon.com, and for all the Ruuuuuuben aficionados, he won the title of American Idol. Both Ruben and Clay have accepted the results, and have moved on. I think it's time you all do the same.

    Reality Speaks
  • Linda Satterwhite (View Email) on June 23, 2003
    I have watched every show since the beginning. I loved Kelly Clarkson and Justin. But, and I say this with sincerity, there has never been a more clear and pure voice than Clay Aiken has put forth. He is truly unbelievable! Hope he makes it in the business. He is so very, very talented.
  • Kaitlyn Sato (View Email) on June 24, 2003
    Hi. I think that all of the competators that were in American Idol did a great job. I still think Ruben was the best of the best. No one could ever out sing him. Well mayber Kelly Clarkson and Justin Guarinni.
  • Esh (View Email) on June 25, 2003
    Ruban gives me chills every single time I hear him. He is the best thing since Luther Vandrose and Gerald Levert. He will make it big in the business. He deserves the title because he has been consistant in and out every single week! YOU GO BOY!!
  • JOYCE HALSEY (View Email) on June 28, 2003
    ALL YOU CLAY AND RUBIN FANS----LET THE RECORD SALES DETERMINE WHO THE FAN REALLY WANT. WOW!
  • Justine (View Email) on June 29, 2003
    Clay is the best. I wish he won he had such a great voice but so did ruben. . . so im still happy and i know Clay and Ruben will make it far in singing i now it Clay and Ruben are better then half the singers today.
  • Clarissa Davis (View Email) on June 30, 2003
    Rueben is my baby!!!!!!!!!!!
  • WHO'S THE BEST??? (View Email) on July 3, 2003
    WHO'S THE BEST??? Well, who won??? That cute, sexy singer, RUUUUUUUBEN! he deserved it and all yall out there can stop being pissed b/c he was da bomb! Ruben u r the truest American Idol of all time! Also u have the most beautiful voice in the world. i can listen to your songs all day.
    Clay is alright but Ruben is BETTER!
  • alicia (View Email) on July 3, 2003
    clay shoulda won. example....whenever im looking for his single its always outta stock, but guess whos is there RUBIN'S this goes to show u that clay is the true american idol
  • SHI on July 5, 2003
    I THINK THAT RUBEN DESERVED IT BECAUSE HE WORKED REALLY HARD AT WHAT HE DID. BUT THERES ONLY ONE THING I CANNOT FIGURE OUT IS WHY WAIT SO LONG TO BRING HIS FAME
    I LOVE RUBEN!!
  • Rachelle (View Email) on July 8, 2003
    When are the next auditions? I live in Houston. rockinrachelle05@netscape.net
  • Samantha (View Email) on July 10, 2003
    I would like to know about the next American Juniors auditions a.s.a.p.
    Please e-mail me.
  • chris (View Email) on July 12, 2003
    i love ruben he is the man i am so glad for him he will do well
  • Jermel (View Email) on July 15, 2003
    Ruben is all that and a bag of doritoes. He is way better than some country wanna-be singer, Clay. Who ever says tthat the votes were miss calculated were wrong.
  • clay (View Email) on July 20, 2003
    your my american idol
  • Shaunesy (View Email) on July 20, 2003
    Ruben and clay rule.i dont care wat other ppl think they rule!!!!I just cant wait to see them in concert on tuesday!!
  • Karen Eastes (View Email) on July 28, 2003
    I would like to contact Rubin Studdard. I want to tell him what a GREAT singer he is and one day I hope I can meet him.

    Love,
    Karen
  • Karlie (View Email) on August 22, 2003
    If people don't like clay they should get help. Not only is Clay cute he is also the most wonderful singer i have ever heard he should of won americain idol. I like ruben to but clay is wayyyyyyyyy AWESOME!!!!!!!!!I love Clay!!!!!! MERRY ME CLAY!!!!!!!!PLEASEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!
  • Ruben Studdard & Clay Aiken (View Email) on August 25, 2003
    YOU ARE A GR8 SINGER!!!! SO ARE YOU CLAY!! YOU BOTH ARE GR8!! GOOD JOB!!! YOU HAD ALOT OF COARAGE TO GO UP AND SING INFRONT OF THE COUNTRY....CONGRATS!
  • nicole (View Email) on September 16, 2003
    sooooooooooooo...HOT
  • A true AMERICAN IDOL IS CLAY on October 3, 2003
    An american idol should not just be for the voice, but for who they are. In my opinion, Clay had the best voice. Not only that, but Ruben had no job before. If you admire that then you have problems. Clay helped kids with autism. A very hard job to do but he did it with his heart. He helped kids as much as he can. Therefore he is an idol.
  • Dee (View Email) on October 15, 2003
    I only hope that Clay continues to rocket. After him being judged as #2, we all that have backed him from the getgo considered that ranking was a slap in the face. He has handled himself in an amazing manner. As for his popularity right now, I say take that "judges" and I use judges loosly. Simon messed up by not taking him under his wing. I guess he is not as know-all as he thinks he is!
  • Joanne Eisenhauer (View Email) on October 15, 2003
    Where's Ruben Studdard?? Since he won the american idol I never see him making tv appearances. Clay Aiken, was the loser and
    he's all over the place. Why is Clay singing the national anthem at the opening game and not Ruben? I'm confused.
  • Norma Becker (View Email) on October 16, 2003
    Clay Atkins is and has always been FIRST CHOICE. It has been a long long time where there is one that is looked up to. One who truely can wear the crown as THE HERO the PRINCE,the KING. Yes the King. Here is one who will beat the old and famous one. A New Frankie. HE has everything. Looks which had a good affect on him,he is able to sing it all. No one type of singing but ALL songs. Not like Rubin who is the velvet fog, or Joshua the NEW singing cowboy. Clays, Mack the Knight was really wonderful. As was his Wings of Love but ALL styles. He wiis supurb in all forms of music, and stage TV. All things. This is a young man who is a God fearing christian. One who cares for the children in need. Yes CLAY, you have the world by the string. you are absolutely a wonderful new KING. Rule well, but KEEP your Crown shined and keep your humbleness. This is who you are. This is really your charm. Do not loose that. YOU HAVE IT ALL. I shall adopt you as my grandson. Grandson number 5. Go for it all. God Bless You Aways. GRANDMA
  • R Wright (View Email) on October 19, 2003
    I would love to know what the American idol website is and the TV channel which hosts the show please?
    Also could you advise on when and where the next auditions are being held?

    R. Wright from Scotland, UK

    Ps Please can you also advise on any info regarding Canadian idol?
  • bailey (View Email) on October 23, 2003
    i loved joshua!! hes my idol!! joshua could sing!! he made me cry on more than one occasion! he does not just sing,he plays guitar, piano and saxophone!! he is amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Linda (View Email) on October 23, 2003
    Without a doubt, Clay Aiken is the true
    American Idol. Not only does he have an
    incredible singing voice, he knows how to
    conduct himself in a mature manner and he is
    a role model for what the American Idol should be. He has a way of caressing the lyrics to a song and delivering it in a very personal way. He completely owns his performances. He knows when to speak up and when to be quiet. He is a remarkable person.
  • Cathryn Brooks on October 24, 2003
    I really love Rubin. You go boy and show everyone you can sing. One day i am going to meet you and nobody is going to be able to get me off of you.
  • Riannon Murray (View Email) on October 25, 2003
    i would not like to vote for this i would atually like to vote for the pop idol that has Roxanne and Sam and Andy,Chris,Susane on really.
    please respond im only 8 years old
    Riannon Murray
  • go clay! on November 5, 2003
    the reason clay is appearing and singing at more events is because he is the better singer ( by far)-dont get me wrong i love ruben very much too i just thought clay whooped him in singing ability. ruben got it for his adorble personality. and to the " y do u like clay so much" person: clay's voice is not "fake" . and the reason he can change his voice so much is because he has TALENT
  • doll (View Email) on November 8, 2003
    I think that Ruben and clay are both very talented but what i love most about Ruben is that his presences just makes you feel gooood! not to mention his beautiful smile and voice. i just love ruben more all accross the board. one more thing i can't wait until he drops his new album. i'm going to try my best to be the first at the door! go ruuuben!!!!!
  • B. Straight on November 12, 2003
    Rubin was the one real person on that contest-He sang with his heart we all felt it and hope he NEVER stops. Rubin Give God the Glory and how about some Christian songs too. A Christmas album would be nice > You would be great with " I'll be home for
    Christmas" ! Rubin My prayer for you is -That God sends you the right songs .!
    America loves you and we proved it !!!
    I for one love your "Spirit" and want to hear more of your songs..Keep on keeping on..America is waiting on you Rubin.. God Bless You and yours. Ms Straight
  • Curtis (View Email) on November 12, 2003
    It's amazing how so many people wrote hate or don't like in their comments about either Rubin or Clay. It's simple, everyone liked one a little more than the other. I believe Clay should have won yes, but Rubin did very well himself. But I do have one question another person mentioned here, why are we seeing so much more of Clay on TV and in the music business than we are seeing Rubin? That question in itself tells you a lot. And I would love to buy Kimberly's album when it comes out as she was amazing as well. You rock Clay...........
  • K.R on November 18, 2003
    Whoever you think should have won, Rubin won and that is that. If you like one person over the other buy thier record and since I didn't see you on the show, I think I've said enough but I must admit Rubin can sing.
  • lyndsi (View Email) on November 20, 2003
    hey ruben i voted for you every time you perormed can i have your photo and your name sighned on it. Thanks i want to do american jonouirs.
  • Benji Martin (View Email) on November 22, 2003
    Rubin is the bomb!!!! He's awesome I never missed an episode with him on the show. Rubin you rock!
  • Miss Nita (View Email) on November 23, 2003
    Since REUBEN won thw contest, why is that when REUBEN has a guest apperance there is clay aiken? It seem that the runnerup has been pushed to front in an attempt to nullify the true winner. When kelly clarkson won Justin was now and then.
    I am truly at a loss to understand why would they(whoever they maybe) announce the winner and then turn around and push clay aiken.

    Just wanted to ask the question...Why are they not promoting MR. REUBEN STUDDARD?
  • Mary (View Email) on November 24, 2003
    OK why did Clay's CD come out first, they said at the closing that they were going to come out the same time. Were they afraid that Rubin's would far outsell Clay's and put him second where america put him? I do not understand why Clay is being spotlighted either??? Rubin won, he should be out there more, I can't wait to get his CD, listening to him sing brings peace and love to the soul! Rubin you are love! Thank you for being you!
  • Angie (View Email) on November 25, 2003
    I wonder why you are not promoting the last winner of American Idol Ruben Studdard, everywhere I turn there is Clay Aiken.
  • JeffreyK on November 27, 2003
    "They" probably delayed Ruben's album because it wasn't ready. "They" realize that Clay is the better singer and performer. Note: Clay's album is only him. Ruben's people are surrounding him on his album with other "name" acts in a last ditch attempt to try to just keep up with Clay's numbers. Please understand I'm a big fan of both those gentlemen. Ruben brought some of this on himself as well. He hasn't been able to overcome his natural shyness in interviews. He and Clay are both humble, sincerely good men. Clay is just adapting quicker to the entertainment scene. In the end, three years from now, they will probably,unfortunately, be nothing more than a fond memory.....
  • charlie-marie (View Email) on November 30, 2003
    hi i am charlie-marie from the uk
    i wanna know how i can audtion for pop idle and when the next auditond gonna be in the uk???
  • kylie (View Email) on December 2, 2003
    clay was so kool and so hot.i love him.iam like 1 of his biggest fans.all the kids in my
    class love his music my teach is 28 and plays your cd in class.everybody sings along



    RUBEN YOU SING FAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    CLAY YOU RULE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Sharyn DiFazio (View Email) on December 4, 2003
    I have been a Clay fan since the first time he opened his mouth and his appearance just made him that more endearing. I feel cheated as i was not able to vote the last two times for clay, the system (they say) was working just fine, i don't believe it and i feel that this was "fixed"....i will always believe that. Sincerely, a fan of clay's, but not the ethics of American Idol.
    Sincerely, Sharyn Difazio
  • Pebbles on December 9, 2003
    Ruben is the American Idol. Not Clay. Get it! Da! Not Clay. RUBEN STUDDARD!! Clay needs to be put to the side. And Ruben should be given his Spot Light. It is a shame that the American Idol Show is allowing this to happen. RUBEN WON NOT CLAY! Pomote Ruben Please, and stop with the Clay Mess. He is second runner up. Ruben is a great artist and a great guy!!! Let him have
    his Fame !!!
  • Jennifer L. (View Email) on December 9, 2003
    I have tried to understand what exactly has been going on with Ruben and Clay. Correct me if I'm wrong but, didn't Ruben win? It seems to me that Clay has been pushed to the forefront rather than Ruben. Don't get me wrong, Clay has a nice voice too, but Ruben was better.If this is the type of behavior that will be displayed in the future I will not be watching American Idol or any other Idol show. Ruben won; why has the glory of being number 1 been stripped from him?
  • stephanie (View Email) on December 10, 2003
    hi I rely luv your show. i want to now if you are going to do a ohter sow and if thers going to by an canabien Idlo.
  • Jeffrey K on December 11, 2003
    Lighten up on the AI people! It's the studios/labels who decide when to release albums - not American Idol.

    Obviously Ruben's wasn't ready when Clay's was. And remember this - THE ORIGINAL GAME PLAN WAS TO RELEASE BOTH THEIR ALBUMS ON THE SAME DAY!!!! Whose fault it it that Clay was ready and Ruben wasn't?

    I'm sitting here listening to Ruben's album and it's good. Not great, but certainly better then Kelly Clarkson's or Justin Guarini's. Clay and Ruben put those two wannabes to shame!

    Take it easy, enjoy your music and let's all wait a couple of months and see what the numbers (sales) say. America will vote with their pocketbooks - a vote that can't be rigged by any network or studio.
  • Bev Hanifin (View Email) on December 18, 2003
    Love that Clay. I'm 61 years old and have been waiting for someone to listen to that I can enjoy and understand the words to and then Clay came along.
  • J. (View Email) on December 18, 2003
    Clay Aieken belongs on broadway ..not on the radio.....but the fact is that who controls the radio....people with money...white america...and because of that Ruben might have a better voice but Clay is more marketable. As racist as that sounds, the fact is Country music is the number one selling genre of music, not pop , not hip hop but country! Who buys country music....WHITE people. I do belive that it is unfair but if Ruben really wanted it bad enough he could be on top. Clay Aieken sold more records than Beyonce. I belive Ruben needs to put forth more effort and be more energetic and entertaining if he wants to win over white america, in record sales.
  • Tom (View Email) on January 1, 2004
    Purchased the Ruben's CD and was very disappointed that the overall theme was not along the lines of many of the songs he performed. Expected more "soulful" type songs. This is what won my vote.
  • Kyla (View Email) on January 2, 2004
    Anyway... those comments about Reben are quite dumb if you ask me. Yah don't have no right to discriminate on a heavy set man, but you know what he sings his butt off so screw those who don't stand for the talent, but rather clown and it don't matter. They both are successful people and thats all that count. so screw those who hate on Reben and Clay. Its straight up petty. Kyla*
  • LEX (View Email) on January 5, 2004
    ANY HOW I THINK RUBIN WON BECAUSE HE WAS THE BEST I DONT EVEN THINK CLAY SHOULDA BEEN IN THE COMPITIITION HE LOOKS LIKE HOWDY DUDY WITH FRECKLES THE ONLY REASON PPL LIKE HIM NOW IS CAUSE HE WHITE, HE IS A ALBINO NERD LOOKING GUY, HE NEEDS TO GO HANG OUT WIT MICHEAL JACKSON!!
  • Kirsty (View Email) on January 7, 2004
    OMG.... you stupid idiot J cleveland.. hav u got no brain... country music, pfft... who the hell buy country music? except for u because u've got no taste... neway its called "POP" idol in sum countries
  • Tired of the Same Sounds on January 9, 2004
    One thing that always made me such a Caly fan was his ability to be so unique and different. He has a voice that stands out. Rueben has the kind of voice that can be heard on any street corner. It is very good, but he is just one of many with the same old sound.
  • Just a Thought on January 9, 2004
    We all know from the previous Idol show that both first & second place receive recording contracts. The question we should be asking ourselves is why Clay outsold Rueben?..The answer is easy. He tried harder. He put every effort into marketing himself as did his record label. That is the name of the game in music. One must make the best of every opportunity. It is the way of the world. He who hesitates looses. Blame Rueben for his slumping sales not Clay.
  • Lesson #1 on January 9, 2004
    Okay Kirsty just so you will know the crossover between pop and country is a major selling point in the music industry. There are more albums in the country genre sold worldwide that any other category. So apparently it is your brain that is not quite up to date.
  • FYI on January 12, 2004
    There seems to be a discussion ongoing in regard to American Idol and the intent of its music. Pop Idol is simply a british version of the show. American Idol is the given name of the show that is formatted here in the USA. To break it down the show it is not suppose to cater to a single genre of music. The winner is simply suppose to be able to sing, and to sing well. There is a fine line between the "quote" Pop and Country styles. They interchange and mesh with one another, as the pop country crossover charts will show. There was one Official Winner of the last American Idol, but it would be unfair to say that the others were losers. I heard the voices, and watched the performances. There numerous winners, not in vote tallies, but in sheer talent. I do however think that another fairer way of voting must be found. We all know Ma Bell is not the most reliable method. I look forward to the next American Idol. I also wish Rueben and Clay the very best. I say it was a tie in my eyes. To choose between them was almost impossible.
  • TERESA (View Email) on January 13, 2004
    TRYING TO FIND OUT IF RUBEN WON ON AM. IDLE
    OR ONE OF THOSE SHOWS
    THANKYOU T.
  • Beth on January 14, 2004
    Teresa.. It was Rueben who was voted the American Idol in the last show.
  • sabrina (View Email) on January 15, 2004
    hey wuz up i think is kool that both clay and ruban tied but i love ruban hes so sexy and hes voice is amasing and clay a good singer to but ruban tops all 3 from the 1st showes winner till now!!!!!
  • diana delnero (View Email) on January 16, 2004
    dear American Idol,
    I am writing on behalf of my son, matt he is 17 and has facalscapularhumeraldystrophy(fsh) for short. We are having a fund raiser for md in our town and we were wondering if you could spare a picture or a autogragh from someone for our raffle. we love your show and watch every week and cant wait for the new season.Please help us if you can, we would really appriciate it.thanks matt and matts mom diana
  • celynda (View Email) on January 18, 2004
    i wish i could win because i would like to join it and sing so i can win me and my friend and i think rubu should win because he gots good talent
  • sammy (View Email) on January 22, 2004
    yes i would like to know when the next american idle juniors auditions are and where they are so if you could please reply asap thank you and have a really nice day.
  • Symantha (View Email) on January 22, 2004
    What the deal Rubben! You are so fine you blow my mind! Your a sexy chocolate teddy bear. I wish i was the gurl in that video sorry 2004! Let me meet you one day plzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz! 1 LUV yah gurl RENEE AKA SYMANTHA
  • lil ginger (View Email) on January 22, 2004
    YOUR #1 TO ME. DON'T THINK ABOUT THOSE HATERS BABY. YOUR A STAR IN MY EYES. MUCH LOVE YOUR GIRL LIL GINGER.
  • Keyasha (View Email) on January 30, 2004
    My favorite person that as been on American Idol has been Ruban Studdard. I love him alot. I was so happy when they announced that he had won. He was a great singer and everyone that voted made a good decision. Don't get me wrong Clay Aiken was a good singer also but I liked Ruban better. I hope that there is someone that comes back to American Idol that is like him because I love watching this show. Thanks for listening to my commets. I want Ruban to know that he has done a wonderful thing in the world today. See whom ever this may concern later
  • tasha (View Email) on January 30, 2004
    wuz up nothin i am guestin well i just wont to tell you that i enjoy listenin to ur music .It make fell go sleep.If you only know that everyone lovs that song sorry 2004.
    Gotta go so holla
  • Anonymous (View Email) on January 31, 2004
    If i was on of the judges on American Idol It would have been hard to decide between Clay and Ruben , because they are both really good.This season I think the judges shoul pick the final 2.They should also pick the #1 American Idol.Thanks.peace out
  • brandon smith on January 31, 2004
    i love you ruban
  • mary plass (View Email) on February 2, 2004
    i really love rubbin
  • Mallory (View Email) on February 11, 2004
    I love you Simon,Paula,and Randy.I just wanted to ask you.How can you vote for the next american idol online?
  • Demarcus (View Email) on February 15, 2004
    I think Amercain Idol is the Bomb it is of the chain i watch it every it comes on.I like all the singers.The girls are fine.The boys are awesome.I like Randy,Paula,Simon,and Ryan.
  • Ashley Burgess on February 18, 2004
    Ruban Studdard rocks
  • andrew (View Email) on February 19, 2004
    i want to audition for american juniors i m 12 years old but i dont know whwen or how . please tell me
  • Cassandra (View Email) on February 20, 2004
    Hello

    this messages si for Simon Cowell. Hi how are you Simon? me fine. All pepople think you are not nice but me i think you are really nice and what you say is true..

    ok bye bye Cassandra-----
  • ASHLEIGH TYLER (View Email) on February 21, 2004
    I really think that some of the american idol stars can't sing,and I personally think you judges should have gave them more time to sing so that they could show their true singing talent.They might have blown you guys away on the audition,but on the show the blew the crowd away alright almost right out of the stadium.For you SIMON COWEL you need to stop crtisizing every little tiny winnie thing.THAT DOESN'T MAKE ANY SINCE AT ALL!!
  • Kaite Greene on February 23, 2004
    hi. I like Simon and Paula the best. I looooooooooooooooooooooooooove rubin Studdard
  • shelonda (View Email) on February 23, 2004
    Hi, My name is Shelonda Shente' Hampton and i'm in my 1years college and i love Ruben Studdard
  • Arturo (View Email) on February 24, 2004
    clay has a brain of a child of 1 mounth old!!!!
  • SALLIE BROWN (View Email) on February 25, 2004
    HI I WOULD LIKE TO BE ON AMERICAN IDOL PLEASE PICK ME ON THE NEXT GO AROUND. I REALLY WANT TO GO SOMEWHERE FAR AND I THINK I CAN WIN IF YOU GUYS HAVE ME ON YOUR SHOW. I HAVE A WONDERFUL VOICE. PLEASE CHECK ME OUT.
  • Tiffany Hash on February 26, 2004
    Hey I love you and always will keek it up
  • chazvernon on February 26, 2004
    Rubenan you is great i like you song keep making songs and you will be my top fan . love you
  • Mona Mills (View Email) on February 27, 2004
    I would love to meet Rubin Studdard. I love his new CD and I just wish him a lot of luck in the future. I am always happy to see another African American be successful.
  • diana (View Email) on February 27, 2004
    i think that american idol is the best show out know. i was watching it when it first came on.but the best person on their as a judge is simon .he tells everyone like it is .
  • nikki of vicksburg ms (View Email) on March 1, 2004
    Ilove Ruben Studdard i am his biggest fan and i love him so so much i will love to meet him one day and i hope its one day soon and very soon he is really my favortie american idol and i love him so much i will do anything to meet him I LOVE YOU RUBEN STUDDARD
  • Tiara (View Email) on March 2, 2004
    She is going to do a good job so pick her please if you don't that will hert her heart.
  • Simon (View Email) on March 2, 2004
    you are so hertful i can;t see how they pick you to be a jugde.
  • simon (View Email) on March 2, 2004
    simon is ugly
  • Carrie Neuzil (View Email) on March 4, 2004
    I love Rubin Studdard too . He is like a big teddy bear ! Rubin Rocks !
  • molly on March 9, 2004
    your soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo mean Simon, but funny( in a bad way!)
  • Tay Shizzy (View Email) on March 10, 2004
    I love you ruban keep on making those good songs.
  • Janet (View Email) on March 10, 2004
    Rubbin is so cool!! I like his new song something like sorry2004!!! The big teddy bear!!!! Luv ya rubbin!!
  • Jill Terrio (View Email) on March 11, 2004
    Simon- i think you need to lighten up. i mean i know that you are not trying to be mean you are trying to tell it like it is. but like you need to lighten up.
    Paula- luv ya paula u know how to judge talent and you dont bring them down as hard as simon does.

    Randy- my favortie dude! the best! u know how to judge talent!
  • Brittany (View Email) on March 13, 2004
    I think Simon needs to learn to be honest but nice at the same time(if thats possible). Paula is my favorite.but Randi is pretty coll to.I love them all!
  • Jenn on March 17, 2004
    Without Simon this show would suck he is the only hoest person alot of these people do SUCK and he tells it straight. KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK!!!!
  • Jenn on March 17, 2004
    I think that people should get of the Clay boat! He lost Ruben won! He should be getting all the attention and not be second to get his face on the cover of a magazine. Clay you SUCK get off it quit paying people to like you!!!
  • kiel (View Email) on March 17, 2004
    Caly Aikens is wonderful, so much better then the guy who won the show.
  • Jo on March 18, 2004
    i love simon... he totally roxx.. n he tells the truth as well ^-^
  • Casey Yonkers (View Email) on March 18, 2004
    i think clay is the best. he is the cutest guy i have ever seen
  • Ashley (View Email) on March 21, 2004
    3/21/o4
    When is a American Idol jr. and if there is still a American Idol jr. please tell the kids on American Idol.

    thank you have a nice day
  • Immajustagirl (View Email) on March 22, 2004
    I would just like to say that Simon has done the best job a judge could do. He only says what everyone else says or thinks but behind their back. I think it has to be a bit harsh some times, lol, come on people are we watching the same show here?? I have seen it and heard myself. Some these people actually think they are something great, and some of them really are, it is up to him to filter thru all of them and bring forth the best. And I for one think all three of them are a wonderful group of judges that veiw everyone from all angles in all different ways. Keep up the good work. And besides, it is the voters of America that really judge anyways.
  • kevin scroggins (View Email) on March 23, 2004
    GIT RID OF SIMOM, HE DON'T HAVE A EAR FOR MUSIC, DUMP HIM, AND YOU'LL HAVE A HIT, #1hh
  • chriss peterson (View Email) on March 24, 2004
    By far the best American Idol is Clay Aiken. I have seen and heard him sing all types of music and each performance gets better and better.
  • stephaine on March 26, 2004
    ruben studdard and julia were my favorite
  • rick (View Email) on March 28, 2004
    ruban was right to get first but kimberly lock should have gotten second. Just pointing out the facts
  • LISA ANDREWS (View Email) on April 1, 2004
    HEY RUBEN,
    I LOVE YOUR CD I THINK YOU ARE A VERY TALENTED YOUNG MAN, WITH A WINNING SMILE KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK. OUR FAMILY LOVES YOU....................
  • Victoria (View Email) on April 4, 2004
    I am so glad to picked ruben he was the best out of all of them i can tell you that far i am very proud of you.
  • Riley (View Email) on April 6, 2004
    I want to know When And wear American junuiors is?
  • TANYA WABWIRE (View Email) on April 6, 2004
    I THINK LATOYA SHOULD WIN AMERICAN IDOL.
  • ashley (View Email) on April 8, 2004
    good bye camille
  • Sharosca Mack (View Email) on April 9, 2004
    I'm 13 years old, so I'm to young for american idlo, and to old for american jr.Can you make show for teens this summer like American Teen's?
  • Sally (View Email) on April 9, 2004
    Hey i love your show it is the BAMB!!
    Ruben is my idol
  • lorraine (View Email) on April 11, 2004
    love simon! he does know what he is talking about. (usually) says we all are thinking.

    hope latoya wins.
  • George (View Email) on April 13, 2004
    I love Pamula she'd a nice lady i love what she says to the idols on the show every week.
    Simon is alright. So is Randy
  • abby (View Email) on April 13, 2004
    dianna is the best shes gonna prove herself tonight, come in to her own, she can do this

    paula is to soft tho but simon rules

    hope jasmine goes tonight, her ballad are starting to become boring.
  • tamera black (View Email) on April 14, 2004
    simon why are you so mean to the people who are singing?
  • rhonda (View Email) on April 14, 2004
    i need yall to tell me when the next auditions are 4 american juniors and if there are gonna be any !!!
  • yona on April 16, 2004
    Hi I am yona and I am 13 I would like to be on your show so that one of you can tell me how I sing me dad Robb helps me. I am very good at it and I could win.
  • Kylee VandenBerg (View Email) on April 21, 2004
    Dear all the Judjes I think your show is great, Americain Idol is all my Friends and I talk about every recess,your judjing is great I think John Stevens should be the winner!!!!!!!!!!!!Great job John!!!!!!!!!! I'm like the only one in my family that watches your show!!Sicerely Kylee Ann VandenBerg age 9and 2days old
  • katya (View Email) on April 21, 2004
    Hey guys,
    I have a comment for simon, because I like him and also that he has a mind of his own but I think he needs to spent more time of making a good desicon and I also like Paula...
  • Ronisha (View Email) on April 21, 2004
    Hi love your show I watch it every time it come on
  • barbara (View Email) on April 22, 2004
    thursday 22/2004 i do not no what happend last night but i no that no one in their right mind beleives that that groupe of kids won over jennifer; get real simon stop telling those kids they are to young because kids their age has cellu phones and they did this because of you they all voted for their age to win. i love you simon
  • leslie n. on April 27, 2004
    I name a horse after you Simon, because he is a jerk.
  • mary (View Email) on April 27, 2004
    I think the girl from highpoint did well and I would like to vote for her.
  • CASSIDY!! on April 29, 2004
    HAHAHAHAHA JOHN STEVEN GOT VOTED OFF I LAUGH IN HIS FACE LOL U KNOW SOMTHIN MY FRIEND IS IN LOVE WITH SIMON COWELL AND SHE IS ONLY 10!!!!!1 LOL FUNNY SHE THINKS HE IS SEXY!!
  • UR WORST NIGHTMARE on May 4, 2004
    the pensalesman is hot
  • chanel (View Email) on May 5, 2004
    I hope that DIANA wins!
  • shackera (View Email) on May 5, 2004
    HA HA john stevenit was time fro u to leave and everyone vote for lotoya she is the best and fantasia i bet they are gonna be the last 2
  • Jamie (View Email) on May 15, 2004
    Wow! I love the awesome details inside of the American Idle Part!


    ~jamie~
  • kayla (View Email) on May 18, 2004
    i think that simion is really mean he needs to learn some respect he puts down some of the best singers but i think he is ao0o mean well u just gor faded from a 13 year old girl u know i want to be on american idol but u would probably turn me down to my sister is a great singer she sound like Kelly Clarson .she is her idol she want to look just like here she wasnt her hair to be jsut like hers and she has the cd she sings to it every night well if my sister wanted to be on there and u turned her down man would u be cussed out my my mom,dad,sister,and me and u better believe it
  • Kim (View Email) on May 18, 2004
    FANTASIA is the best i love her. she is a really good singer, lotoya was very good to people need to vote better cause she was better then other two but it's not like saying is going to change anything iwas really upset when lotoya left. GO FANTASIA GO I BELIVE IN YOU!
  • Christopher Williams (View Email) on May 19, 2004
    hi your show is great and im voteing for phantasha
  • kristen (View Email) on May 20, 2004
    Daina ROCKS! WHat more can i say.
  • JennyPoo (View Email) on May 20, 2004
    K one thing Fantasia U r my Idol weather u win or lose :) meber that girl!! 2nd thing Once Amercain idols done im creating my own show Called *** Vote Off The Judge*** Simon i hope u can come on my new show * Well Good luck 2 both Diana and FANTASIA <---> Jenny Poo OUT !!
  • jankah (View Email) on May 22, 2004
    i think diana should get kick off
  • amanda (View Email) on May 22, 2004
    hey everybody add me!!!! and simon great job
  • sharika (View Email) on May 24, 2004
    i think that Fantasia u r pretty. if u don't win i think that u win still be a winnner in my eyes. i think that u should win because u r very talented n u have a strong voice. ur voice makes me wanna cry it's so good. ne wayz i hope u win and even if u don't u noe that some1 elese will want u on their lable.u will be an idol 2 me no matter wat.u go gurl
  • Riley (View Email) on May 24, 2004
    I know you arent doing american junuiors but i
    would like to go and get in it so please do it next season?!?!?!?!!? P.S And start auditions in Utah.
  • Denzel (View Email) on May 25, 2004
    1866 Idol text vote 5702
  • sheldon (View Email) on May 25, 2004
    1866 Idol text vote 5702
  • timothy (View Email) on May 26, 2004
    dinia
  • Megan (View Email) on May 26, 2004
    Diana I believe that you diserve to win because you are always giving your best and have a great personality. Simon is correct when he says you are good for a 16 year old. I also want you to know never give up you are beautiful and heart warming you have all of my relatives votes you go girl. Ooh my god I am only 14 and I have you as an idol.
  • Cory (View Email) on May 27, 2004
    Hi my name is Cory. I thought Dianna should have won.
  • trevell (View Email) on May 29, 2004
    i love ull
  • Lakeisha on June 2, 2004
    this is old but i think who deserved to win did win and that is Fantasia
  • Tory (View Email) on June 2, 2004
    When can we find out when auditions will be for American Juniors? And where will they be?
  • rabar (View Email) on June 6, 2004
    hi i'am from iraq where are you from ?
  • !! on June 10, 2004
    fanfan all the way
  • ??? (View Email) on June 28, 2004
    Hi, As a lot of kids want to know... Ummm When can i find out when the American Idol Auditions are going to be and can they be in Washington,D.C.?
  • a different message from the s (View Email) on July 5, 2004
    this is just about the judges. people think Simon is mean, but as a judge you have to speak your mind. people think he is unfair because they have different opinions.now about Paula, it is pretty nice to say good things about a person's singing, but saying nice things about a person's clothing when they lose is just wierd.now last but not least...Randy.he is an in between judge.sometimes he's like paula and sometimes he's like simon.now if you are reading this Randy here is a memory.remember the first American Idol? remember in one of the auditions simon called the person who was auditioning a loser?you guys started fighting.i wouldn't have been suprised,you guys had just done a few auditions together.

    P.S again will you please tell me when are the auditions for American Idol Jr.( cause i'm 10 ) and please please pleasssssssse stop at Washington DC first?

    P.S.S My favorite judge is the one and only Simon!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • jaimie on July 12, 2004
    hey y'all!
    its jaimie!PLEASE STOP IN MASSACHUSETTS FOR AMERICAN JUNIORS AUDITIONS!!!!I"M 11 1/2 and I was in a school talent show, singing camp, auditions for a singing group, national anthem 3 time s IN PUBLIC asked ALL times!
    PUHLESE!!!!!!!!
  • ERIKA (View Email) on July 15, 2004
    HI IT'S ERIKA I HAVE BEEN IN 2 DIFFRENT TALENT SHOWS.I WOULD HIGHLEY IT IFYOU STOPPED IN SACRAMENTO I WOULD REALY TRY MY BEST TO BLOW YOU AWAY.
  • Tre'von (View Email) on July 27, 2004
    hey this Tre'von and when can we find out when the American Juniors going to have adutions. when ever PPPPPPLLLLLEEEEAAASSSEEE stop at St.LOuis SOOOON.
  • Brooke Childers (View Email) on August 6, 2004
    Hi,my name is Brooke.I won't to become a famous country singer.I would love tyou to send me the schedule for American Jr.I am willing to work very hard.I am very serious about my singing.I live in Milan,T.N.

    Thank you,
    Brooke Childers
  • chelsey on August 10, 2004
    hey my name is chelsey and i am 13 years old and i have 2 friends and we sing together in a band called "charmed" we write our own songs and we can sing really good i was wondering if american jrs is goin to come to baltimore maryland.
    thanks, chelsey!
  • Jamie Gaita (View Email) on August 15, 2004
    Hey my name is Jamie Gaita I have been singing for a while know and i have a lot of excperience in front of people i have been in a few compitions and i have placed in every one of them i would really like to try out for american jrs cause i really really want to be a singer so please tell me when the auditions are and where thanx so much
  • al (View Email) on August 24, 2004
    hey my name is alex, im 13, and i have been singing for a while now and i have had experiences with singing in front of my school, and i have done a thing at my school where judges rate ur singing and i got a perfect abyways i would really like to be on american jrs so please tell me when and where auditions are for american jrs i realllllly want to be a singer but i want to see if i have what it takes so please give me the information. thanx a bunch!
  • Caitlin (View Email) on September 27, 2004
    hey when is American Jrs. auditions.
    Start in Ohio PPPPEEEEAAAASSSSEEEE

    Thankz much
  • Brittany (View Email) on November 25, 2004
    IThink lil'kim in the house should win because she was on the mike she was blowing up those jams. She was good. i think she should get 1st place.



    I'll holler at you later
  • Steph. (View Email) on December 15, 2004
    Hi. I just LOVE my singing and I SURELY know you will too. I can improve my singing if you help me..and PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE send me the schedule for American Jrs.Auditions. Its been my life's dream to be a singer. I know everybody else could have this dream but I..I..just want to be a singer..Its not because I want to become rich,famous,or popular..its just because it has been so long and..I want to accomplish my dream. I've always heard people say "You sing GREAT!" or "I love your voice." I just want my lifes dream to come true..I dont want to keep dreaming and I dont want to day dream about it too..I want it to be real and I want it to really happen..
    Thanks..
    Love,
    Steph. San.
  • lalalal on January 3, 2005 at 9:55 PM
    come to florida
  • allison (View Email) on January 3, 2005 at 11:43 PM
    hi i am a 13 year old girl from bradenton floroda i need to ask if you can send me a e mail telling me wen american idol jrs are coming i love to sing and my mom has a band and i sing w/ her and every one tells me that i will be a star and i want to be one now plz send me the list and stop some whare a round florida so i can show you i can sing
  • Erica Diaz (View Email) on January 5, 2005 at 11:38 PM
    Please take a little time to view my music video thank you.
    RealPlayer: h html

    website: http://www.ericadiaz.com/
    email: info@ericadiaz.com
  • jessica (View Email) on May 4, 2005 at 8:13 PM
    i think u are all great and i wish you the best of look to all
  • janel (View Email) on March 2, 2006 at 9:59 PM
    I think its just messup how all of a sudden they have american idol Jr and next thing you know it kids are waithin for it to come back i still want to do it but all i can do is wait, singing is my dream and i would love to show the world my singing. I hear alot that i should got to american idol jr because im almost 13 and i sing in choirs all AROUND AND WAS IN A SING GROUP CALLES THE BEginning middle and end I live i Maryland near dc and from the bottom of my heart pleezz send me ANYTHING about american idol jr this is my dream!!!! Thank you
  • Nick Lindsey (View Email) on March 14, 2006 at 8:43 PM
    I am doing a project on you!
  • Ashley Lindsey (View Email) on March 14, 2006 at 8:50 PM
    I think that Kevein is HOT!!!!! He is cute just like Johnny Cash. I think you are cute too!!!!!!
  • Kelcee (View Email) on April 27, 2006 at 10:57 AM
    I would love it if they brought american idol jrs back because i would love to try out i am 13 years old and i love to sing and dance !!!
  • Eva Longoria (View Email) on May 1, 2006 at 5:11 PM
    Pick Pickler........................$40.00
    Soul Patrol.........................$4.00
    McPhever......$1,000,000,000,000,000,000,000

    This is how much they are worth.
    P.S. Kellie is a bottle blonde and WHITE TRASH!!!!! HA HA HA HA HA HA HA AHA AHA
  • Brittany (View Email) on May 10, 2006 at 10:10 PM
    I dont want to watch american idol if chris is not on it.
  • countrey A on January 26, 2007 at 10:56 AM
    how do i sign up for this?



  • judy (View Email) on March 23, 2007 at 10:19 PM
    Hi, just wonted to say I love the show this year if they let the guy named Sanjava win, I will not be watching any more! The guy can not sing, and People need to leave simon alone ,He knows what he is talking about,
    thanks
  • lizzy (View Email) on May 2, 2007 at 9:29 PM
    i dont like simon. he is so mean. i wish he got fired. he needs to get new clothes because he looks like he is wearing his p.j's. i love polla. she is the best. she is always nice. she always says atleast 1 thing nice about a person who is singing, but all simon says is...
    " YOU STINK"
  • antoo (View Email) on May 19, 2007 at 10:58 AM
    i don't speak english very well, because i'm from uruguay,
    well, i only want to tell you that i love simon he is the best,
    she says all taht people in their home think, so, SIMON: you're great!!
    well, bye!!
  • chloe (View Email) on May 23, 2007 at 5:01 PM
    hey im chloe and im nine yrs. old but i have a really good voice contact me @ 706 793 0079
Jump to first comment