Thursday, May 24, 2012 9:31 am
Montgomery Blair High School's Online Student Newspaper
Tags: print
Nov. 22, 2004

National Treasure is just fool's gold

by Christopher Consolino, Page Editor
In the late 18th century, the Founding Fathers inherited and hid the largest treasure in the history of the world, leaving obscure clues as to its whereabouts. Now, Benjamin Franklin Gates (Nicholas Cage), a direct descendent of the one man who was entrusted with the first clue, is on the verge of discovering the unimaginable wealth of earth's greatest empires somewhere within U.S. borders.

In National Treasure, the Founding Fathers were all members of a secret fraternity known as the Freemasons. That detail, which is not wholly true, represents nearly all of the factual accuracy in this movie. The treasure was compiled by ancient kings and conquerors before the original Masons re-discovered it in Egypt during the first crusade. It was then transported to colonial America, remaining completely unnoticed during the voyage.

Fast forward to 1974, when Gate’s grandfather tells him the story of the treasure and gives the young treasure hunter the first clue. The story then jumps to modern day as Gates looks for the first clue inside a gunpowder-loaded colonial ship located in the middle of a polar ice field. After he discovers the first clue, Gates decodes a riddle left on the artifact, revealing that there is a treasure map on the back of the Declaration of Independence. Gates and his comical partner Riley Poole (Justin Bartha) then find themselves in Washington D.C., where they steal one of the most protected documents in the world with relative ease to protect it from the devious Ian Howe (Sean Bean).

From then on, National Treasure is absurdly unbelievable. Abigail Chase (Diane Kruger) teams up with Riley and Gates and uncovers the "invisible map" by spreading lemon juice over the back of the Declaration of Independence, then using a hair dryer to make the rest of the clue magically appear.

The animation and action scenes compensate for the shortcomings of the plot, however. One particularly well-made scene shows the Declaration of Independence rapidly dropping into a vault and being secured by guards. The realism of the computer animation does add to the suspense and tension of the movie.

Additionally, the music score is so amazing that it steals the show. The fast-paced and loud sounds of trumpets along with other equally thundering horns sounded much like the Pirates of the Caribbean soundtrack, lending the film an emotional authenticity if nothing intellectual.

Regardless of aesthetic merits, the sheer historical fallacy of the movie prevents any viewer with any basic knowledge of U.S. history from accepting Gates' illogical arguments.

Although the story of a fellowship questing for a treasure of unimaginable proportions would make an excellent movie, as is, National Treasure is nothing more than a movie written before the writers did their homework.

National Treasure (100 minutes) is rated PG for action violence and some scary imagery and is now playing everywhere.



Share on Tumblr

Discuss this Article

  • tyler (View Email) on November 23, 2004
    National Treasure is a good movie.
  • are you kidding? on November 23, 2004
    This was an amazing movie. It wasn't supposed to be non-fiction. It was supposed to be fiction. It was a great, fast-paced, action-filled movie. It wasn't supposed to be historically correct. Maybe you should do your homework before writing a review.
  • saw it on November 24, 2004
    I agree completely with Chris. Although the movie did have some redeeming features, overall it was pretty awful.
  • .... on November 24, 2004
    I agree with 'are you kidding?'. Although I havent seen the movie yet, this review offers no good evidence on weither or not i should see this movie for the actual content not the historical correctness.
  • eh on November 28, 2004
    I know the movie was fiction, but it was still kind of ridiculous. While I was entertained, I don't think it was a particularly good movie.

    Nicholas Cage plays a very intelligent character. I'm sorry, but he just can't pass that off. His "reasoning" for everything is unrealistic and very poorly thought out.

    Also, this movie bears a striking resemblance to "The DaVinci Code"

    Entertaining, but poorly made. Instead of DaVinci it's Ben Franklin. The sequence is very similar, and Cage's character is very similar to Robert Langdon.

    While I enjoyed watching the movie, looking back at it I realize that it was very amateur and unrealistic(even for a fiction).
  • treasure beliver on December 5, 2004
    Their might be a possibility that the treasure very much exists. Nicolas Cage (Bengimin Gates)
    belives that the treasure really exists. so why wouldn't it.
  • cactusjack22 (View Email) on May 24, 2005 at 3:55 PM
    Very good movie.
    I'd recommend it to any adventure-lover.
  • ? (View Email) on June 13, 2006 at 8:13 PM
    is there really a treasure
Jump to first comment