Is Miss USA really Miss Universe?

Dec. 22, 2012, 3:57 p.m. | By Stacy Mathew | 11 years, 5 months ago

Miss Philippines had to leave without her deserved crown

88 beauty queens traveled to Las Vegas, Nev., on Wednesday night to battle it out for the highly coveted title of Miss Universe. The contestants are judged on overall beauty, floor presence, outfits and responses to questions asked by the judges. As the pageant progressed, contestants were eliminated and the final five came down to Miss Philippines, Miss USA, Miss Brazil, Miss Australia and Miss Venezuela. To my surprise, Miss USA, Olivia Culpo, took the crown as Miss Universe 2012. And by surprise, I don't necessarily mean anything pleasant.

Read More: Transgender contestant disqualified from Miss Canada pageant

Falling out of the competition

Whether it was the right decision or not, Miss Philippines shared Miss USA's happiness in becoming Miss Universe 2012. Photo courtesy of NY Daily News.

As only viewers of the pageant, we totally understand that these beauty queens are human and it is impossible to avoid making mistakes. But we do, however, hold an expectation for a contestant of Miss Universe to be able to walk gracefully in high heels, whether she has to come down stairs or spin around in them. Miss USA stumbled in the evening gown portion of the event, and while many argue that she couldn't be criticized for that because she didn't fall to the floor, it's important to keep in mind that the other contestants in the top five were able to make it through their walk perfectly.

Wait, what did she just say?
Miss Venezuela was definitely a crowd favorite in the beginning of the pageant and could easily be seen taking the first runner up spot or Miss Universe 2012. However, when the question and answer portion came around, she made the mistake of choosing to speak in English, which was clearly not her first language, as her responses made absolutely no sense. I honestly don't even know if she got out even one grammatically correct sentence, but I will say that she was at least smiling the whole time!

Miss Philippines, first runner up for Miss Universe 2012, got a lead in the pageant with her well thought out answer. Photo courtesy of Emirates 24/7.

Once Miss Venezuela messed up, the pressure was on for Miss Philippines, and boy, did she ace that question. Judge Nigel Barker asked Miss Philippines, "As an international ambassador, do you believe that speaking English is a prerequisite to be Miss Universe?" to which she responded, "For me, Miss Universe is not about being able to speak a specific language, it's about being able to influence and inspire other people. No matter what language you speak, as long as you have the heart and a strong mind, you can become Miss Universe." This answer definitely gave Miss Philippines the push she needed, or at least the push viewers thought she needed to become Miss Universe.

While everyone was switching their bets from Venezuela to Philippines, Miss USA picked her question, which was whether she had ever done something she regretted. Culpo answered, "I'd like to start off by saying that every experience no matter what it is, good or bad, you'll learn from it. That's just life," she said. "But something I've done I've regretted is probably picking on my siblings growing up, because you appreciate them so much more as you grow older." A solid answer, but as the crowd began clapping, she ruined it by saying, "But I don't regret it!" Well, Miss USA, thank you for making all of America face-palm as you completely missed the point of the question.

Home court advantage

Boston University sophomore, Olivia Culpo, was crowned Miss Universe 2012.  Photo courtesy of Us Weekly.

This year, Miss Universe was hosted in America, and the pageant itself is co-owned by Donald Trump. With a mediocre answer, a basic evening gown and a personality that's easy to forget, how else could Miss USA have won? Despite arguments that America has hosted the pageant plenty of times without choosing an American winner, it may have been that Trump and other American judges agreed it was America's turn.

I am not saying that Olivia Culpo is a disgrace to pageants. She is a beautiful, smart woman who has definitely done a lot of good deeds for this world. What I am saying is that almost everyone would have guessed that she would have become fourth runner up, rather than the winner. In my opinion, Miss Philippines was the most qualified woman of the pageant, performing flawlessly in each category, and deserved that title.

Tags: beauty pageant Donald Trump Miss Universe Miss Philippines Miss USA Nigel Barker Olivia Culpo

Stacy Mathew. More »

Show comments


No comments.

Please ensure that all comments are mature and responsible; they will go through moderation.