Montgomery Blair High School's Online Student Newspaper
Sunday, May 27, 2018 11:04 pm
Jan. 10, 2013

News Chips: Marriage without love

by Lily Gates, Online Features Editor
Editor's Note: Article updated 7:05 p.m., Jan. 25. Correction: Original article incorrectly stated that the U.S. is a member of Human Rights Watch.

NewsChips is a weekly blog focusing local and national news and thinking critically about its impact on society. Come back next Thursday for the next edition of NewsChips.

For most 15-year-old girls in the U.S., fitting in and having fun are their main priorities, and their typical worries usually consist of trivial drama and upcoming exams. However, in nations such as Saudi Arabia, the common fear many young girls face is the possibility of being forced into childhood marriage. According to Reuters, each year, around 1.5 million girls worldwide become child brides.

 Many young women in nations such as Saudi Arabia fear the possibility of being forced into child marriage. Each year, there are at least 1.5 million child marriages that occur in the world. Courtesy of Too Young to Wed
Many young women in nations such as Saudi Arabia fear the possibility of being forced into child marriage. Each year, there are at least 1.5 million child marriages that occur in the world.
During the past few days, many human rights groups and activists have been outraged at a forced marriage between a 70-year-old Saudi Arabian man and a 15-year-old girl. This case in particular has been a focus this past week because of the 70-year-old's behavior after his newlywed wife fled back to her family two days into their marriage. According to CNN, the man went to a local official to complain that the girl's family had taken her back and that he'd been scammed into giving her family a $20,000 dowry. The man's complaints reveal a disgusting objectivity of a young, innocent girl.

The man implied that the girl did in fact want to marry him and the only reason their marriage ended was because her family took her back. However Daily Mail and CNN reported that she locked herself in a bedroom on their wedding night and later ran away after a fight. Only real love would cause someone to avoid their husband after getting married and flee for her life after a single argument. Clearly, she was highly enthusiastic about the marriage and it was the parents' fault that their marriage ended badly.

After the man went to a local official, Saudi Arabia's Human Rights Commission (HRC) sent an investigator to the girl's home to help her and her family to legally dispute the marriage. On Wednesday, the investigator helped successfully grant the divorce between the girl and the 70-year-old man.

Although the dispute has formally been resolved in the courts, human rights groups and activists continue to express anger towards this specific instance of child marriage. In a CNN interview, Dr. Suhaila Zein al-Abedin, a member of the government supported Saudi National Association for Human Rights (NSHR), explained how the significant age difference and large dowry raises suspicious alarm that their marriage was not based on love. "It looks more like this was not a marriage, but like the girl was sold. The girl's parents need to be held responsible for this," he said.

Al-Abedin's statement seems accurate. Based on the available news reported so far, there is little to no evidence that this marriage was based on love. However, contrary to al-Abedin's opinion, the girl's parents should not have been held accountable for allowing this child marriage. Instead, those who should be held responsible are members of the Saudi Arabian government.

In the U.S., child marriage isn't a prevalent problem because the U.S. has minimum age requirement laws that determine if someone can legally marry. In Saudi Arabia, there are no such laws. Although there are currently no age restriction marriage laws, human rights activist groups, like the HRC, have been proposing legislation that requires anyone under 18 to have court's consent in order to get married. However, extremely conservative religious scholars continue to oppose the activist groups' proposed legislation.

In order to prevent the travesties of child marriage in nations such as Saudi Arabia, the U.S. should support human rights activist groups and help them pass marriage-age legislation. The U.S. must take initiative to help nations with human rights issues, because as a member of the "

Share on Tumblr

Discuss this Article

Silver Chips Online invites you to share your thoughts about this article. Please use this forum to further discussion of the story topic and refrain from personal attacks and offensive language. SCO reserves the right to deny any comment. No comments that include hyperlinks will be posted. If you have a question for us, please include your email address or use this form.

  • Anonymous on January 11, 2013 at 1:16 PM
    This article's pretty terrible. It was hard to understand, disjointed, and sometimes inaccurate. Sarcasm should not be used on the Internet. The US is not part of Human Rights Watch, nor is any country. And why shouldn't the parents of the girl be held accountable?
  • Anonymous on January 11, 2013 at 1:20 PM
    This is ridiculously biased. The act of selling yourself in marriage is actually treated as an honor in most countries. The way that you write about this subject disrespects the traditions and beliefs of a huge number of people.
  • Anonymous on January 17, 2013 at 9:10 AM
    This is an interesting article. However, the author is insensitive of people of other cultures. These people have had such traditition for centuries. It should not be us as Americans to invade into the cultures of other people. This is part of the "Crusade" that has continued since the Middle ages and is basically the same as the War in Afgahnistan and Iraq. We should really accept other cultures and understand that not everyone in the world wants to follow our "American " way.
  • Angry about Ignorance on January 17, 2013 at 10:18 PM
    I usually have high expectations of sco, but this article has really fallen flat and is clearly subpar. in terms of practice. Personally, would i marry a seriously underage girl? no. A 70 year old marrying a 15 year old girl is kind of weird, but i think what Lily misses is that marriages DONT HAVE TO BE BASED IN LOVE. In fact, in many cultures, (like my own), many times its not based on love. The other point that we have to note is that this WAS an ARRANGED marriage and to say that arranged marriages are wrong will get EVERYONE angry (who follow eastern culture tradition) and is incredibly naiive. Arranged marriages tend to actually be more successful than true "love marriages". Also, in terms of the dowry, that's not a human rights issue if the perspective of why it is done is understood. Thats a traditional practice that is accepted by many cultures: the husband provides something as the family "loses" a daughter. That attachment to a daughter is something not commonly understood here, where family ties are less valued. So i understand the perspective of the man as well as the daughter, both are in the right and both are in the wrong...but to say that something has to be done on it...i would hold off. It's not our morals and philosophies that we're dealing with. If you dont want someone to tell you what your morals should be, why should have the right to tell other people what their morals should be? Unless a conflict arises where philosophy is HARMING others who DONT believe in the same thing, (genocide, violence, racism, the crusades) then change shouldnt be enforced. It is the belief that others are wrong and that we must "save" them that has led to so many conflicts in the past. We must be careful when we make claims about other cultures: we need to learn their perspectives with an open mind before passing judgment.
Jump to first comment