Montgomery Blair High School's Online Student Newspaper
Wednesday, May 23, 2018 12:29 pm
Latest:
Nov. 29, 2017

Victim blaming is the new normal

by Mahnaz Habib, Staff Writer
In a country built around the construct of race as a system of power and oppression, victim blaming is just another form of discrimination that people of color face. "Victim blaming" is a term used when victims of violent crimes are held completely or partially responsible for the harm that befell them. People of color are often the ones who must carry the weight of victim blaming, especially women. Victim blaming has become a natural psychological reaction to many crimes, especially those affecting women of color. Even when a victim has done absolutely nothing wrong, holding a victim responsible allows people to think that such a crime could never happen to them and that the victim is just paying for the consequences of their actions.
Kenneka Jenkins was found dead in a hotel freezer in Rosemont, Illinois after a party. Courtesy of NDTV
Kenneka Jenkins was found dead in a hotel freezer in Rosemont, Illinois after a party.

On Sept. 8, Kennka Jenkins, a 19 year old black girl, vanished from her home after attending a party with her friends at Crowne Plaza Hotel. When she didnít return, her parents filled out a missing person report, and on Sept. 10, her body was found in a freezer in the hotel building. There was little information released regarding the official investigation of Jenkins death, and authorities suspect that she accidently walked into the freezer intoxicated. There is not enough substantial evidence leading to this suspicion, but was instantly assumed by police officers after medical examiners found that Jenkins had no interaction with anyone immediately before her death and suffered no trauma due to abuse. Authorities often neglect the death of black people, and take a few quick looks at the investigation to determine the death as the fault of the victim.

The story of Nabra Hassanen highlights the same issue in the case of Jenkins. She was a 17 year old girl who was raped and murdered by a man named Darwin Martinez Torres. She was walking with her friends, when Torres approached them. Hassanen was unable to escape, and was beaten, raped and killed before being thrown into a pond. Although many expressed disgust after her death, others blamed Hassanen. She was blamed for wearing a hijab, being out late at night, and not doing what Torres asked of them.

Women dying of homicide is tragically common, and is increasing the system of victim blaming. Black women, such as Jenkins, face the highest homicide rate. In a study of female homicide victims per 100,000 women, black women are killed at a rate of 4.4 per 100,000 people, and indigenous women at a rate of 4.3 per 100,000. Every other race has a homicide rate of between 1 and 2 per 100,000.

Victims of homicide are often undervalued or demeaned, because people internally blame these victims for their own death. They begin to question the victimís lifestyle, wondering if maybe their relationship with the murderer played a role in their death. This just goes to show how normalized victim blaming has become for people of color, Jenkins just being one example.

Victim blaming is often a method of distancing oneself from an unpleasant and disturbing event. People feel a sense of reassurance when they can think to themselves, "because I am nothing like her, this will never happen to me." This mindset is especially harmful to people of color, because many white police officers are using it to blame them for crimes, rather than looking into the facts of the case. This issue is especially prevalent as white people make up 52.2 percent of police in America, while only 16.1 percent of police officers are black.

This unconscious phenomenon of victim blaming highlights the effect of discrimination that has been embedded into American culture. As soon as people find out that the victim is a person of color, it is as if they deserve what happened to them. "Thereís just a really strong need to believe that we all deserve our outcomes and consequences," says Sherry Hamby, founder of APAís Psychology of Violence journal.

There are many reasons why Kenneka and Hassanen's death has not received justice, but being a women of color is a large contributing factor. Living in a country that systematically oppresses black people, Jenkins and her family are left vulnerable. The loss of any life should not be treated with negligence, but rather with care and compassion. People must protest and stand up for victims of crimes who are being unfairly blamed, rather than keeping silent. And when police are investigating a crime, they must thoroughly look into the case and make conclusions based off of substantial evidence, regardless of the gender, race, or ethnicity of the victim. Maybe then we can find out what really happened to Kenneka Jenkins.



Share on Tumblr

Discuss this Article

Silver Chips Online invites you to share your thoughts about this article. Please use this forum to further discussion of the story topic and refrain from personal attacks and offensive language. SCO reserves the right to deny any comment. No comments that include hyperlinks will be posted. If you have a question for us, please include your email address or use this form.
 

  • Phil (View Email) on December 2, 2017 at 7:29 PM
    This article is not journalism. "and authorities suspect that she accidently walked into the freezer intoxicated. There is not enough substantial evidence leading to this suspicion, but was instantly assumed by police officers after medical examiners found that Jenkins had no interaction with anyone immediately before her death and suffered no trauma due to abuse." Surveillance footage showing her stumbling down the hallway of the hotel and walking in the direction of the freezer, then being found dead in the freezer, is not enough evidence she was intoxicated and walked into the freezer? How about the reality there was no evidence she was assaulted or taken to the freezer by anyone other than herself. I suppose the reality she was over the legal limit of alcohol and was stumbling down the hallway is not good enough evidence. "The story of Nabra Hassanen highlights the same issue in the case of Jenkins. She was a 17 year old girl who was raped and murdered by a man named Darwin Martinez Torres. She was walking with her friends, when Torres approached them. Hassanen was unable to escape, and was beaten, raped and killed before being thrown into a pond." Apples and oranges, buddy. You are comparing a case where someone was raped, beaten, and murdered to a case where someone got intoxicated and walked into a freezer. "There are many reasons why Kenneka and Hassanen's death has not received justice, but being a women of color is a large contributing factor." I suppose the main reason why Hassanen's death has not received justice is because the trial of the killer has not concluded. "Fairfax County prosecutors will pursue the death penalty against the man accused in the high-profile killing of a 17-year-old Muslim girl, who was abducted as she walked to her mosque over the summer, authorities said." https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/public-safety/prosecutors-will-pursue-capital-murder-charge-against-man-accused-of-killing-muslim-girl/2017/10/16/b343391e-b2a7-11e7-9e58-e6288544af98_story.html?utm_term=.143f4285770f Kenneka Jenkins' will not receive justice because she was not murdered. Who is to blame for Kenneka Jenkins' death? She's an adult, she went to a party and got highly intoxicated, and wondered into a freezer. Was she forced to drink alcohol? No. Was she forced into the freezer? No. Even though the death was a tragic accident which could have happened to many people who partied in their youth (myself included) we still like to think that adults are responsible for their own actions. Her actions leading up to the accident were her choices. She decided to go to a hotel party and drink Hennesy. "People must protest and stand up for victims of crimes who are being unfairly blamed, rather than keeping silent. And when police are investigating a crime, they must thoroughly look into the case and make conclusions based off of substantial evidence, regardless of the gender, race, or ethnicity of the victim. Maybe then we can find out what really happened to Kenneka Jenkins." How about demonstrating she was a victim of a crime first. How about demonstrating the conclusions of the coroner/investigators are not based off of evidence. We've already figured out what happened to Kenneka Jenkins. She died of a tragic accident.
Jump to first comment