Discuss this Article

• Katie on November 20, 2002
  Last year when I was in 9th grade, my least favorite book we read was Great Expectations and my favorite was To Kill A Mockingbird.
  Reply
• Kevin L. (View Email) on November 20, 2002
  Best: Ender's Game
  Worst: Bridge of San Luis Rey
  Reply
• Kevin Fang (View Email) on November 20, 2002
  Best: Fahrenheit 451 and 1984
  Worst: Great Expectations
  Confusing but great: Sound and the Fury
  Best that I didn't read for school: Ender's Game
  Reply
• Dan Curl on November 20, 2002
  Catcher in the Rye, easily.
  Reply
• Matt Castner (View Email) on November 20, 2002
  9th
  Favorite: The Human Comedy (not listed)
  Least: Antigone
  10th
  Favorite: Grapes of Wrath
  Least: Nineteen Eighty-Four
  11th
  Favorite: The Autobiography of Malcolm X
  Least: The Bridge of San Luis Rey (not listed)
  12th
  Favorite: Yellow Raft in Blue Water
  Least: The House of the Spirits
  Reply
• Elliott Wolf (View Email) on November 21, 2002
  Favorite: Black Boy, by Richard Wright
  Least Favorite: Great Expectations, by Charles Dickens
  Reply
• Nora on November 21, 2002
  I have been impressed with the books we have been reading thusfar in 12th grade. House of the Spirits, Song of Solomon, and Snow Falling on Cedars have been fantastic. I especially liked House of the Spirits. My least favorite book throughout high school had to be Hard Times.
  Reply
• Amy on November 21, 2002
  Matt, I can't believe you didn't like the Bridge of San Luis Rey! I think that was my favorite of all the books we read last year!
  Reply
• Jessica Yen on November 22, 2002
  9th Grade:
  Best: To Kill a Mockingbird
  Worst: Farewell to Arms
  
  10th Grade:
  So far at least, I've enjoyed greatly both Night and the Joy Luck Club, although I expect to dislike The Odyssey when we begin to read it.
  Reply
• Meg on November 22, 2002
  9th- Best-to kill a mocking bird
  worst-April morning
  10th-best- Balck boy
  worst- things fall apart
  11th-best- Animal dreams(not listed), Macbeth
  worst-brave new world
  12th-so far House of the sprits, song of solomon, and sonw falling on cedars have all been really good.
  Reply
• Dan on November 22, 2002
  Best: Catcher in the Rye
  Worst: Tie b/w Great Expectations and Grapes of Wrath
  Reply
• andrew busick on November 22, 2002
  best: catcher in the rye
  worst: my antonia
  Reply
• Sebastian Galeano (View Email) on November 22, 2002
  best: One Hundred Years of Solitude
  
  worst: song of solomon
  Reply
• Omar Karim (View Email) on November 22, 2002
  9th : Best- Les Miserables
  Worst: To Kill A Mockingbird
  
  10: Best: Julius Caesar
  Worst: Lord of the Flies
  
  11: Best: Crucible
  Worst: As I Lay Dying
  Reply
• Karen on November 22, 2002
  9th- Ender's Game [awesome series]
  10th- Farenheit 51
  11th- One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest
  12th- so far, none..
  Reply
• Lindsay on November 22, 2002
  9th: To Kill A Mockingbird, Les Miserables - great
  House on Mango Street - weird
  10th: Lord of the Flies, Darkness at Noon -good
  11th: Great Gadsby, Macbeth - good
  Crucible, Scarlet Letter - not so good
  12th: Snow Falling on Cedars - good
  Reply
• Spencer on November 22, 2002
  9th:
  best - To Kill a Mockingbird
  worst - House on Mango Street
  10th:
  best - The Grapes of Wrath
  worst - Lord of the Flies
  11th:
  best - Death of a Salesman (with Native Son a close second)
  worst - The Great Gatsby
  12th:
  best - Metamorphosis
  worst - Crime & Punishment (but I've only read 3 books so far)
  Reply
• avon jackson (View Email) on November 22, 2002
  9thbest--Of Mice and Men
  worst--Tale of Two Cities
  10thbest--Princess Bride(all-time)
  worst--Things Fall Apart
  11thbest--The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn(all-time)
  worst-- (none)
  12thbest--Song of Solomon
  worst--House of The Spirits
  Reply
• Junior on November 22, 2002
  9th-Enders Game
  Reply
• Chris Wilhelm (View Email) on November 22, 2002
  Worst- Glass Menagerie
  Best- Grapes of Wrath
  Reply
• Daniel Coyle (View Email) on November 22, 2002
  9.) least favorite- Great Expectations
  Favorite- Of MIce and Men
  10.)Least favorite- Black Boy
  Favorite-All Quiet on the Western Front
  11.)Least favorite- A lesson before dying
  favorite- Adentures of HUckleberry FInn
  12.)Least favorite- SOng of SOlomon
  Favorite- SNow Falling on Cedar
  Reply
• senior03 on November 22, 2002
  the best two books that I've read throughout high school would have to be Catcher in the rye and lord of the flies. My least favortie book would have to be death of a salesman.
  Reply
• osman (View Email) on November 23, 2002
  Excellent Literature: Great Gatsby, Huck Finn, Death of a Salesman, Invisible Man.
  
  farewell to arms-not much can be said about this book except i thought Old Man and the Sea was better.
  
  It helps to have read the above books if you go to UnivMaryland and take american lit 1856-present.
  Reply
• 2-oh oh, 2 bad you weren't a s on November 24, 2002
  9) Best: TIED! Of Mice and Men and A Raisin in the Sun
  
  10)Best:TIED! Julius Ceasar and Black Boy
  Worst:Dandilion Wine (EWWWWWW)
  
  11)Best: Great Gatsby (With Dr. Porter Teaching)
  Worst: Scarlet Letter
  
  12) Best: TIED The Kitchen God's Wife and The Sound and the Fury (With Ms. Adamson Teaching!)
  Worst: Their Eyes Were Watching God (Second worst book ever next to Old Yeller!)
  
  Reply
• LEICIA MONFORT (View Email) on November 25, 2002
  9) Least favorite-Tale of Two Cities
  Favorite-A Raisin In The Sun
  10)Least Favorite-Animal Farm
  Favoite- T he Odyssey
  11)Least Favorite-Death of A Salesman
  Favorite-A Lesson Before Dying
  12)?
  Reply
• Harry on November 25, 2002
  9.) worst - House on Mango Street
  Best - Ender's Game *Best of the Best*
  10.) Worst - Joy Luck Club
  Best - Fahrenheit 451
  11.) Worst - A Lesson Before Dying
  Best - Cat's Cradle
  12.) Worst - not sure
  Best - Snow Falling on Ceders
  Reply
• Harry on November 25, 2002
  9.) worst - House on Mango Street
  Best - Ender's Game *Best of the Best*
  10.) Worst - Joy Luck Club
  Best - Fahrenheit 451
  11.) Worst - A Lesson Before Dying
  Best - Cat's Cradle
  12.) Worst - not sure
  Best - Snow Falling on Ceders
  Reply
• Abhi on November 26, 2002
  9th: Of Mice and Men - best
  10th: Princess Bride - best
  11th: The Crucible - best
  12th: coming soon
  
  Reply
• Melissa Dookharan on November 27, 2002
  Worst book-Les Miserables
  
  Best Book- House of Spirits
  Reply
• Heather (View Email) on November 29, 2002
  9th grade-
  Best: Ender's Game, followed by To Kill A Mockingbird
  Worst: Romeo and Juliet and House on Mango Street
  
  
  10th grade-
  Best: I'll get back to this one when we actually read a somewhat entertaining book
  Worst: The Odyssey and Lord of the Flies
  Reply
• Martino Choi on November 29, 2002
  9th Grade:
  Best: Ender's Game and To Kill a Mockingbird were good.
  Worst: House on Mango Street.
  Interesting but long and tiresome: Les Mis.
  Reply
• matt baron on November 29, 2002
  9) Best: Les Miserables
  Worst: Farewell to Manzabar
  
  10) Best: The Catcher in the Rye
  Worst: The Grapes of Wrath (too long and sentimental)
  
  11) Best: Huckleberry Finn
  Worst: The Crucible
  
  12) Best: Hamlet (awesome, especially after watching the Kenneth Branaugh movie)
  Worst: Metamorphosis
  
  I also enjoyed Camus' "The Stranger" which I read in French class.
  Reply
• Rachel Cooper on December 1, 2002
  9th Grade: I had to read this HORRIBLE book,Maggie; A Girl Of The Streets. My favorite book was definitely The Human Comedy.
  
  10th Grade: So far, my least favorite book was The Grapes of Wrath...it's soo long!! My fave was Lord of the Flies!!
  Reply
• Jacinda (View Email) on December 2, 2002
  9) Best: Raisin in the Sun
  Worst: Great Expectations
  
  10) Best: Catcher in the Rye (would be 1984 if we had read it)
  Worst: Black Boy
  
  11) Best: Cat's Cradle
  Worst: Death of a Salesman
  
  12) (so far...)
  Best: Yellow Raft in Blue Water
  Worst: House of Spirits (which isn't actually that bad...)
  Reply
• Katie (View Email) on December 4, 2002
  9)Best:To Kill a Mockingbird (and Ender's Game is good too, thogh I didn't read it in class....also Cat's Craddle which ninth grade cappies read....that was good, but it's not up there)
  Worst:Catcher in the Rye...I know, it's not on the ninth grade list, but cappies read it...and I can tell you, it sucked
  
  10)Best:The Odyssey, Princess Bride (and All Quiet on the Western Front, though I didn't read it for school)
  Worst:Lord of the Flies, Catcher in the Rye
  
  11)Best:so far...I really liked The Crucible
  Worst:Brave New World (though I actually read it a long time ago....also, The Scarlet Letter wasn't so great)
  Reply
• Katie on December 8, 2002
  9th) Best:Les Miserables/Inherit the Wind
  Worst: My Antonia
  
  10th) Best:Darkness at Noon/Nineteen Eight-Four
  Worst:Bridge of San Luis Rey
  
  11th) Best:Adventures of Huck Finn/MacBeth
  Worst: The Scarlet Letter
  
  12th) Best: Crime and Punishment/Hamlet/Jane Eyre
  Worst: Metamorphosis
  
  Reply
• enigma on December 8, 2002
  9th grade:
  BEST: Cry, Beloved Country and To Kill a Mockingbird
  WORST: Tale of Two Cities and Of Mice and Men
  
  10th grade:
  BEST: Black Boy
  WORST: Grapes of Wrath and Lord of the Flies
  
  11th grade:
  BEST: A Lesson Before Dying and The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn
  WORST: The Awakening and Brave New World (two of the CLEAR worst, i think.)
  
  12th grade:
  BEST: Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead
  WORST: The Metamorphosis
  Reply
• Nick S (View Email) on December 8, 2002
  9) Best-Of Mice and Men
  Worst-Ender's Game
  10) Best (of all 3 years)-Lord of the Flies
  Worst (of all 3 years)-Joy Luck Club
  11) Best-Brave New World
  Worst-Into the Wild
  Reply
• Charlie (View Email) on December 8, 2002
  9th grade: The worst book was A afrwell To arms, after reading it i had the strongest urge to take the book and beat hemingway with it
  9th grade: the best would be Les Miserables
  10th grade:the best was julius ceaser and the odyssey
  11th grade: best is the crucible
  12th grade: best is King Lear
  Reply
• Bernardo Perez (View Email) on December 8, 2002
  Best book- Great Gatsby
  worst- The international house of spirits and pancakes
  Reply
• Martin Brown (View Email) on December 9, 2002
  10th best Night and worst Catcher in hte RYE
  Reply
• Ben on December 9, 2002
  Here are a few of my opinions, in randomized order.
  
  VERY GOOD:
  Ender’s Game
  Animal Farm
  Fahrenheit 451
  
  THE WORST:
  Great Expectations and many misc. plays such as "Antigone," "Raisin in the Sun," etc.
  Reply
• truth on December 9, 2002
  Their Eyes Were Watching God
  -Pure Garbage, doesnt have a moral or anything. Zora Neale Hurston pretty much through her career away in this novel. Blair dont bother teaching it!
  Reply
• S. on December 10, 2002
  Best book (9th): Les Miserables (but it has to be the full 14-- some pages version)
  
  Worst book (9th): Jubilee
  
  Best book (10th): Picture of Dorian Gray, 1984
  
  Worst book (10th): Ethan Frome
  
  Best Book (11th): Macbeth, the Crucible
  
  Worst Book (11th): Wuthering Heights (the most evil and boring book in history!)
  Reply
• Chip on December 10, 2002
  The Great Gatsby was good. I also liked the Lord of the Flies. I really didn't like My Antonia though.
  Reply
• luke (NOT hanlein) (View Email) on December 10, 2002
  best books on that list are, in no particular order: ender's game, beowulf, lord of the flies, brave new world, cat's cradle, and a man for all seasons. the worst have been numerous, but the worst of those are ethan frome, fences, and the scarlet letter.
  Reply
• luke on December 10, 2002
  p.s.-enigma, black boy was terrible
  Reply
• Anonymous on December 10, 2002
  Les Miserables!! a disgustingly LOOOOOOOONG book...
  Reply
• Lynn Favin on December 10, 2002
  Worst: Ethan Frome. Hands down.
  
  Book-a-minute has this summary of the book: "Narrator: I met a man named Ethan Frome. His life sucked."
  Reply
• Rodney Dennis (View Email) on December 11, 2002
  Song of Solomog is the best book i have read. I really love it because of its historical and literary highlights. If you haven't read it yet u should consider doing so. Very inspiring, action packed and funny. You wouldn't regret reading it.
  Also: Crime and Punishment and House of the Spirits.
  Don't have a wrost book, because i appreciate the hard work and effort that writers put into their work.
  Reply
• Shola (View Email) on December 11, 2002
  9th Grade
  Best-Of Mice and Men
  Worst-To Kill A Mocking Bird
  
  10th Grade
  Best-Night
  Worst-The Odyssey
  
  11th Grade
  Best-Chronicle of a Death Foretold
  Worst-they were all pretty good...
  
  12 Grade(so far)
  Best-Metamorphisis
  Worst-didnt like Their Eyes Were Watching God too much
  Reply
• Feza Kikaya on December 12, 2002
  9th Grade
  Best: Great Gatsby & To Kill A Mockingbird
  Worst: Maggie A Girl of the Streets
  
  10th Grade
  Best: so far none, prob Black Boy
  Worst: Lord of the Flies
  Reply
• Ian (View Email) on December 12, 2002
  worst book I have read is: Raisin in the Sun
  
  And
  
  The best is: Enders Game
  Reply
• I, student... on December 12, 2002
  A Tale of Two Cities
  It might be OK if I didn't have to get up at six every morning.
  Reply
• ian (View Email) on December 12, 2002
  hey truth, learn some grammer and learn the difference between through and threw. Your just embarrassing yourself.
  Reply
• Alumnus '99 (View Email) on December 13, 2002
  Pride and Prejudice was by far the most trivial, pointless, and tedious book I ever read.
  
  Today in college it still sends shivers down my spine.
  Reply
• Tom Porter on December 13, 2002
  11th best book is Spot and the worst books are long ones.
  Reply
• Jake Riley on December 13, 2002
  The best book i have ever read is Deathwatch. The worst book i have ever read is all the others.
  Reply
• Super Smart Girl on December 14, 2002
  Best: Tess of the D'Urbervilles, The Stranger, Siddhartha, Cuckoo's Nest, Old Man & the Sea, and Catcher in the Rye.
  
  Worst: Woman Warrior, The Illiad, Julius Ceasar, and Lord of the Flies
  Reply
• Bridge (View Email) on December 14, 2002
  Easily Catcher in the Rye
  
  Farewell to Arms is another classic.
  Reply
• Damian m-s (View Email) on December 19, 2002
  The best is most definetely Ender's Game. However, far outshadowing the light of Ender's Game is the cold, bitter, dank, musty, skanky, repetitive, bleak, boring, sedative Devil-incarnate-of-a-book itself...TALE OF TWO CITIES. Please kill me should I ever so much as touch that horrible excuse of a book again.
  p.s. in case you can't tell, the worst book is Tale of Two Cities
  Reply
• bump on December 28, 2002
  Cat's Cradle and Catcher in the Rye are the best (even though I read them out of school ^_^;;) Kurt V. is one of the best authors to date.
  Reply
• Lisa on January 1, 2003
  To Kill a Mockingbird is a great book.
  Tale of Two Cities......let's just say I used sparknotes to get through that book. Charles Dickens is the greates writer my [butt]. He sucks, so do his books.
  Reply
• yourgod on January 1, 2003
  catcher in the rye is the best
  Reply
• el on January 2, 2003
  i must say, Romeo and Juliet is definitely one of the best plays EVER written. its great to watch too and be in(especially when certain people play romeo...)
  Reply
• Sunny on January 12, 2003
  Tale of two cities is the best! My antonia is the worst!
  Reply
• Alex Mont (View Email) on January 14, 2003
  BEST BUT WITH VERY STUPID AND IN SOME CASES INCOMPREHENSIBLE CHARACTERS: The Odyssey
  VERY VERY BAD DUE TO LACK OF ANY SEMBLANCE OF PLOT: The Joy Luck Club
  Reply
• Jennifer Collins (View Email) on January 22, 2003
  I think the best booh assigned is Of Mice and Men. the worst and most boring books I have ever read is A Tale of Two Cities.
  Reply
• : on February 3, 2003
  ian :: iscroggs@hotmail.com :: 12/12/2002
  hey truth, learn some grammer and learn the difference between through and threw. Your just embarrassing yourself.
  
  "grammer" should be "grammar"
  "your" should be "you're"
  
  I think you're the one embarrassing yourself.
  Reply
• L.D. on February 6, 2003
  I dont know what you guys got against great expectations, I thought it was pretty good. Also, Catcher in the rye is one of the best books i have read.
  Reply
• Freshman on February 7, 2003
  The Best book I have read so far has been To Kill A Mockingbird. The Worst book was A Tale Of Two Cites.
  Reply
• fresh dude on March 5, 2003
  by far... tale of two cities sucked, dont know why teachers make us read dat, best wuz to kill a mockingbird
  Reply
• Alex Mont (View Email) on March 6, 2003
  *** "MOVIE STYLE" RATINGS OF BOOKS *** The Odyssey: This is probably my favorite book of all time. Although the hero acts quite unheroically at times, from foolishly leading his allies into death-traps to brutally murdering hundreds unnecessarily, it is quite entertaining to figure out how he could have succeeded without doing tose things. Another thing I learned while reading this book is that the so-called Greek "Goddess of Wisdom" was actually quite dumb, foolish, malevolent or some combination of the above. Warning: some material is inappropriate for children. MPAA Rating: R (for two scenes of sex and a high level of extremely graphic violence) Star rating: 5 out of 5 ---------- The Joy Luck Club: This was a bad book because it focused almost solely on character development and had no semblance of a plot. It focused on the lives of 8 main characters (4 families of 2), but there was no clear overall plot. This made the story much more difficult to follow and less interesting. for those who are looking just for character development, it might be goodm but not for anyone else. MPAA Rating: PG (for minor implications of sex) Star Rating: 2.5 out of 5 ----------- The Grapes Of Wrath: This was a very good book because it had a plot as well as good character development, and talked about an important social problem in the time period. It also has good themes including courage, cooperation, organizing against a common enemy, and differing conceptions of "sin" and "morality". Overall this was a very good book. MPAA Rating: PG-13 (for several disturbing violence scenes and theme of oppression) Star Rating: 4.5 out of 5
  Reply
• Loloa Ibrahim on March 12, 2003
  Charles Dickes IS a great writer. A Tale of Two Cities is not an easy read nor is it his most exciting work...but then there's Oliver Twist, David Copperfield...
  If I had to choose I'd say To Kill a Mockingbird, The Catcher in the Rye, The Bluest Eye (I've never heard of any teachers assigning that) & Jane Eyre are A FEW of the great books...the worst?-The Scarlet Letter and Hedda Gabler. I think Henrik Ibsen's work is loaded with meaning but very uneventful and boring to read.
  Reply
• jake s on March 13, 2003
  i think that the best book that any of us could read is an oldy but goody, the Bible. if more people were reading this book, i think that we might be better off as a society. by the way this is true of any holy book, i'm not limiting it to the Bible.
  Reply
• Perico Entre Ellas on April 16, 2003
  (Grade 10)
  
  The worst book I've read this year had to have been Ethan Frome. It is so horribly boring. It is sad if that Climax of a story is the breaking of a pickle bowl. It is also sad that Ethan and Mattie didn't just die and end the horror... but no, instead they have to live in misery. How irony because misery was put upon anyone who reads that book.
  
  The best books I have read are, Brave New World (Aldous Huxley is great and very random) "Hoity-toity." Another good book is Fahrenheit 451, very cool book (the movie is pretty hillarious how horribly made it is). And the last is Animal Farm. It's a great book if you like reading about dysutopian societies.
  
  Any book my Zora Neale Hurston is horrible (ex. Their Eyes Were Watching God). Feministic writers are no fun. Objectivists are pretty bad too. Ayn Rand is crazy.
  
  To Kill a Mockingbird is just a really funny book, and so is the movie. The funniest part (of the movie) is how the kids are all hicks and atticus throws in a slightly british accent. "I cain't go without muh pants!" "SPIT OWN IT!!!"
  Reply
• Taylor on May 31, 2009 at 7:37 PM
  9th
  best- life of Pi
  worst- to kill a mockingbird
  10th
  best- Absolutely LOVED A Tale of Two Cities
  worst- cry, the beloved country and Fahrenheit 451
  11th
  best-Night Theoreau Spend in Jail
  worst- the crucible
  Reply