Thursday, May 24, 2012 8:22 am
Montgomery Blair High School's Online Student Newspaper
Tags: print
Dec. 9, 2003

A triumphant Return to Middle Earth

by Ely Portillo, Page Editor
On Thursday, Dec. 4, the American Film Institute showed a special one-night East Coast premier of The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King.

The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King is a fantastic and breathtaking cinematic conclusion to J.R.R. Tolkien’s epic trilogy, replete with stunning battle sequences and poignant emotion.

The movie opens with a fascinating scene depicting the shriveled Gollum’s (Andy Serkis) acquisition of the Ring of Power and his harrowing transformation from a happy simpleton to a twisted killer who desires only his “precious." Then Return of the King picks up where The Two Towers left off, following stoic hobbits Frodo (Elijah Wood) and Sam (Sean Astin) as they continue their hopeless trek to Mordor.

Meanwhile, war is brewing on the borders of Gondor, the last mighty kingdom of men. Heroes Aragorn (Viggo Mortensen), Gandalf (Ian McKellan), Gimli (John Rhys-Davies) and Legolas (Orlando Bloom) return from their victory at Helm’s Deep only to find that they are needed to defend Minas Tirith, the majestic capitol of Gondor.

Despite the heroes’ efforts, few hold hope for triumph the impending battle. Not only does Mordor's strength in arms dwarf their own, but their only hope of victory invested in two exhausted hobbits lost somewhere in the wilderness, and one of their own, the Steward of Gondor, Denethor (John Noble), has gone insane and sabotages efforts to defend Minas Tirith.

The fate of Middle Earth hangs in the balance as the main plots effortlessly intertwine to create an awe-inspiring climax to the trilogy.

Return of the King is one of those rare movies that successfully conveys the grandeur of epic events while simultaneously keeping the audience focused on the individual characters. The film includes many touching, deeply felt scenes. Denethor and his son Faramir (David Wenham) have possibly the most emotionally charged scene, Denethor shaming Faramir into a suicide mission. That mission becomes the film’s most evocative battle scene, as a thin line of cavalry charges silently into a deadly forest of arrows.

But the centerpiece of the 195-minute epic is, without a doubt, the siege of Minas Tirith. The sheer scale of the armies involved is amazing. Catapults and trebuchets fire enormous stone blocks into the city and back into the lines of orcs, hulking trolls smash through walls and defenders, and thousands of cavalry gallop across the field of battle while foul Black Riders wheel through the sky, plucking up and devouring men. Legolas does a stunt during this sequence that actually made the audience clap.

Despite the carnage, director Peter Jackson never lets his viewers forget that the characters are real people, not just sword-wielding machines. He shows as many of their tears and failures as their triumphs.

The film also presents moral themes and the overarching struggle of good vs. evil without preaching or moralizing. The main characters are heroic but not idolized, and the battles are beautifully filmed but don’t gloss over the violence of the conflict. All of the characters and their struggles are exquisitely realistic and believable.

In fact, every aspect of this movie is fantastic. Even the terrific sound work bears mentioning. All of the music is perfectly timed, and the battle sound effects are so well done that every blow and crash reverberates through the theater. Of course, the visual effects are also amazing and unparalleled in recent filmmaking.

The plot of Return of the King has not been significantly altered from Tolkien, and only the post-climax part of the book has been seriously shortened. However, because of time constraints and the difference in medium, the movie does present a simplified and less subtly shaded version of the story, designed to appeal to the masses as well as die-hard fans.

But most of the changes are small and improve the flow of the film, and most hard-core fans will come away feeling satisfied. No review can adequately do justice to a movie of such sheer scale as Return of the King, and to truly appreciate the film, viewers will have to wait for it to hit theaters.

The Lord of the Rings: Return of the King will be released Dec. 17 and is rated PG-13 for life-like depictions of violence and frightening situations.



Share on Tumblr

Discuss this Article

  • Lasco (View Email) on December 10, 2003
    I would think twice before using the common adverb "dwarf" in the context of a review of this particular film.
  • me on December 10, 2003
    the LOTR movies are awful. especially number 2, it is just a war movie, i can see that any time. The LOTR series is nothing special.
  • d on December 10, 2003
    WUT LOTR IS VISCOUS!! LOTR THINK UR NOTHIGN SPECIAL!!
  • good on December 10, 2003
    good review
  • I on December 11, 2003
    This is one of the Greatest movies i've seen you first think it's dump but if you see it you'll enjoy it i can't wait till it comes out!
  • dancer on December 11, 2003
    Awesome!!! I really want to see it. It all sold out in Uptown, though...
  • junior cappie on December 11, 2003
    great job ely, cant wai tto see the movie.
  • Fidan on December 13, 2003
    Great review Ely! But not fair you got to see it before me. Anyway, good job!!
  • Jeremy Hoffman on December 15, 2003
    ---I would think twice before using the common adverb "dwarf" in the context of a review of this particular film.---

    Hahaha I agree.

    I'm impressed that Silver Chips got into this. Awesome!
  • Max on December 15, 2003
    "The plot of Return of the King has not been significantly altered from Tolkien". Ely, have you read the books? I'm not challenging that it's not a great movie. I agree that it's amazing, but it diverges from the book more than the previous two movies combined. Still, the movie is a masterpiece, no doubt about it. You got this review right.
  • Strider (View Email) on December 16, 2003
    For those of you fans who are saddened by the news of PJ changing the plot slightly, remember he didn't film it much differently from the book (but one exception, see below), he only CUT it out for length issues. We still have the Extended Edition DVD to look forward to.
  • You Are Wrong! on December 16, 2003
    me, you are stupid. Lord of the Rings are awesome movies!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • ? on December 16, 2003
    What are you talking about? The movies changed the first two books greatly!

    They were still good movies though!
  • Strider (View Email) on December 17, 2003
    They filtered out my spoilers part, oh well. Nevermind then.
  • g on December 28, 2003
    I agree with the review (it was fantastic!) but I disagree that the third movie "from the book more than the previous two movies combined." The second movie is the clear winner for that. Not only did Peter Jackson base almost the entire 'Two Towers' around a battle that lasted only a few pages in the book, but he killed off an important character that wasn't even there!
  • me on February 27, 2004
    lord of the rings owns you
  • John Doelman (View Email) on February 29, 2004
    I agree with reviews...this movie is outstanding!!!!!1
Jump to first comment