Montgomery Blair High School's Online Student Newspaper
Monday, July 16, 2018 11:59 am
Feb. 25, 2008

"Vantage Point" weak from all angles

by Greg Kohn, Online Sports Editor
Hollywood's latest attempt at turning the War on Terror into a compelling movie script begins with an assassination attempt on the President. Shown from five different points of view, "Vantage Point" had the utmost potential to be a clever, impressive movie. Unfortunately, it failed on almost all fronts, relying on implausible and disconnected events and desperately clinging to its novelty.

"Vantage Point" opens in Salamanca, Spain, as the U.S. president arrives at a global summit for anti-terrorism and takes the stage at a large outdoor rally. Seen through the eyes of the news team covering the event, the audience witnesses the president being shot and spectators falling victim to a bomb explosion.

Vantage Point

(released February 22, 2008)
Chips Rating:
2 stars
User Rating:
2 stars Votes: 1
A terrorist plot against the President unwinds through the eyes of eight witnesses. Photo courtesy of Columbia Pictures.
The scene is then repeated from the viewpoints of Secret Service agents Thomas Barnes (Dennis Quaid) and Kent Taylor (Matthew Fox), Spanish policeman Enrique (Edward Noriega), spectator Howard Lewis (Forest Whittaker), President Ashton (William Hurt) and the assassination mastermind Suarez (Said Taghmaoui).

"Repeated" is used deliberately, each new view enlightens the audience to slightly new information, but too many of the scenes were redundant and predictable. Lewis's scene, for instance, reveals that there was a bomb, an event already clear. When the scene rewound for the fifth time, an audible groan resounded in the theaters.

Moreover, aside from its novelty, the movie offers very little. Its plot more often than not relayed promising details that were never explained. When the movie finally moves away from replaying the assassination, the contrived scenes are almost redeemed by a few unexpected twists. However, these inklings of plot are 50 minutes too late and fall far short.

The climax is reached in a stunning car chase scene where Agent Barnes pursued those responsible for the attack, though the cinematography and frenetic editing may induce a headache. In tiny and crowded city streets, Barnes' blue car danced impossibly through traffic. And luckily for Dennis Quaid and the plot, it's only a movie and several collisions (including being smashed into a wall by a twenty-wheeler) aren't enough to keep Barnes down (or even make him bleed).

Despite everything, "Vantage Point" had the potential to be saved by superior acting. No such luck. After opening with a strong but brief performance by Sigourney Weaver as a news director, the acting is lackluster at best. Taghmaoui is unconvincing as a terrorist, and Fox seems "lost" without his fellow islanders. Quaid and Whittaker are the only two that provided solid performances.

But you can't entirely blame the actors. Director Pete Travis in his big screen debut and screenwriter Barry Levy gave the cast very little story, character development or motive to work with.

By the end, "Vantage Point" was really a 40-minute movie that lasted an hour and a half, dragging out its already thin plot. Action is important to drive a story, but there must be a consistent and believable story to begin with. There were moments of brilliance, where the different perspectives of witnesses were interconnected just right so unexpected details were maximized. But these moments were far and few between, and the rest was just fancy editing with no meaning.

From the vantage point of the movie-going public, this is one film to forego.

"Vantage Point" (90 mins) is rated PG-13 for sequences of intense violence and action, some disturbing images and brief strong language.

Share on Tumblr

Discuss this Article

Silver Chips Online invites you to share your thoughts about this article. Please use this forum to further discussion of the story topic and refrain from personal attacks and offensive language. SCO reserves the right to deny any comment. No comments that include hyperlinks will be posted. If you have a question for us, please include your email address or use this form.

  • anonymous on February 27, 2008 at 9:48 AM
    Wow this is great writing Greg Kohn. Keep up the good work!
Jump to first comment