Hollywood's latest attempt to adapt a children's book into a film is a confusing disappointment
"Alexander and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Day," directed by Miguel Artecta, is a sappy and unrealistic children's film about a series of unfortunate and frustrating events that shifts a family's outlook on life. The film lacks plot focus and direction, which even the moments of comic relief cannot hide.
Ed Oxenbould stars as Alexander Cooper, a sweet if dorky middle-schooler who just can't seem to catch a break. Disappointed by his family's lack of understanding or sympathy, on his twelfth birthday Alexander wishes that his family be able to relate to his frustration. Poor Alexander wakes up the next morning to find all of his family members experiencing their own personal chaos. His brother Anthony (Dylan Minnette) wakes up to an irate girlfriend and takes a disastrous driver's license test. Alexander's sister, Emily (Kerris Dorsey), star of her school's theater production, wakes up to a cold that threatens her singing. Alexander's father (Steve Carrell), the stay-at-home rock of the family, finds it difficult to search for a new job. His mother (Jennifer Garner), a successful publisher, experience chaos when things go awry at a book printing. The entire family spends the day battling their terrible luck.
Carrell delivers a well-balanced performance, providing hysterical comic relief, while still making a respectable attempt to add a serious element to the plot and validate his family's "struggle." Jennifer Garner is less convincing in her role. She seems too casual and light-hearted in her performance during the more serious sections of the film, contradicting Carrell's more grounded performance. Dorsey gives Emily an amusingly gutsy and free-spirited attitude, while Minnette is predictable but nevertheless believable in his interpretation of a typical teenage boy. Oxenbould, however, is the star of the show. He's quirky and funny in his portrayal of Alexander: his demeanor and tone of voice throughout the film are sincere, but also perfectly embody his character's awkwardness.
Despite convincing performances, the film is still extremely confusing. The basic premise is flawed as a result of the film's desperate attempt to make one family's admittedly terrible day merit a life-changing epiphany that affects all family members and changes their mental perspectives on life. It is unclear at many points throughout the film whether the audience should feel sympathy for the family or if they should laugh at the ludicrous spectacle playing out before them.
The music is an embarrassment. It's reminiscent of a theme song for a television show geared towards three-year-olds. Its overly bouncy and electronic undertones are distracting and downplay the few serious and emotional plot components of the film. The same two songs essentially repeat throughout the entire film. The musical accompaniment was clearly not given much thought, and it showed.
Disappointingly but unsurprisingly, the film digresses a lot from the original book. How could it not, when the book is only thirty pages long? The book was much more brief and engaging, whereas the move is essentially one boy's long, drawn-out complaint about the trivial every-day inconveniences that often plague people. Unlike the book, it fails to arouse much sympathy.
Unfortunately, the comedic and cheerful elements of "Alexander and the Terrible Horrible No Good Very Bad Day" cannot make up for the dramatization of what is actually a very trivial, nonsensical plot and the confusing contradictory tones established by the script and acting. Though the essence of the film is sweet and cheerful, it is also confusing and, ultimately, forgettable.
"Alexander and the Terrible Horrible No Good Very Bad Day" is rated PG for rude humor including some reckless behavior and language and is now playing in theatres everywhere
Amalia Chiapperino. Hello and welcome to SCO! I'm Amalia, a senior and one of the managing editors. I love to read and spend most of my time outside. Cold weather and rain make me unbelievably happy, and I am a huge fan of history and foreign languages. More »